Anthropology › Section D · Evolution, primates, and early hominins › Topic D.1
What is biological anthropology?
Humans are animals with a long evolutionary history and a remarkable range of bodies. Biological anthropology studies that history and that range, and it has had to rebuild itself after an early era of scientific racism.
The biological side of a holistic discipline
The topic The four-field approach introduced anthropology's subfields. Biological anthropology, also called physical or evolutionary anthropology, is the one that treats humans as a living species. It asks where we came from, how we are related to other primates, and why human bodies differ from place to place and from one era to another. It never works in isolation, though. Diet, work, migration, inequality and medicine all leave marks on bodies, so biological anthropologists constantly draw on archaeology and cultural anthropology. That biocultural outlook, in which biology and culture shape each other, is the field's signature.
Six areas of study
Palaeoanthropology reconstructs human evolution from fossils and the stone tools found with them. Primatology studies living and fossil primates, our closest relatives, in the wild and in captivity. Human biology examines variation in living people, from height and skin colour to adaptations to altitude or cold. Genetic, or molecular, anthropology reads DNA, including ancient DNA, to trace population histories and disease. Bioarchaeology studies skeletons from archaeological sites to learn about diet, health, work and burial practices. Forensic anthropology applies the same skeletal skills to legal cases, identifying the dead and documenting how they died.
Bones as biographies
A skeleton records a life. Bioarchaeologists read growth arrest lines in long bones and horizontal grooves in tooth enamel, called enamel hypoplasia, as signs of illness or hunger in childhood. Worn joints suggest heavy labour, and healed fractures reveal injuries and care. Culture can be written into bone directly. In several societies, including the ancient Maya and peoples of the Andes, infants' heads were gently bound to shape the skull, and the resulting shapes can signal family or social identity. Forensic anthropologists use similar evidence for the recent dead: from 1984, the American forensic anthropologist Clyde Snow helped train the Argentine team that identifies people killed under the military dictatorship.
A troubled history
Early physical anthropology was entangled with scientific racism. In the nineteenth century, researchers such as Samuel Morton measured skull collections to rank supposed races. The ranking itself rested on racist assumptions; whether Morton's measurements were also biased is still debated, after Stephen Jay Gould's 1981 critique and a 2011 re-measurement that found them largely accurate. Much of the field's early effort went into sorting people into racial types. In 1951 Sherwood Washburn called for a "new physical anthropology" built around evolutionary processes rather than classification. The change continues: the American Association of Physical Anthropologists, founded in 1930, voted around 2020 to rename itself the American Association of Biological Anthropologists, partly to step away from that legacy.
Human variation is not race
The scientific consensus, set out for example in the association's 2019 statement on race and racism, is that humans are not divided into biological races. Most traits change gradually across geography, in patterns called clines, rather than stopping at boundaries. Different traits follow different maps, so skin colour, blood groups and body shape do not sort people into the same groups. And most genetic variation lies within any population, not between populations. Race is real as a social category with powerful effects, including on health through discrimination, but it is not a natural biological division of our species.
Worked example: reading a skin colour cline
Skin pigmentation is often treated as the marker of race. Analyse what it actually tracks. 1. Map it: among long-settled populations, skin tends to be darker where ultraviolet (UV) radiation is intense and lighter where it is weak. 2. Explain it: the anthropologists Nina Jablonski and George Chaplin argued that dark pigmentation protects folate, a vitamin needed for healthy pregnancies, from strong UV, while lighter skin lets people make vitamin D where UV is scarce. 3. Test it: many sub-Saharan Africans and Aboriginal Australians have dark skin, yet they are among the most distantly related human populations, because strong UV kept favouring dark skin in both regions; lighter skin arose separately in Europe and East Asia, partly through different genes. 4. Conclude: skin colour is an adaptation to sunlight, not a sign of shared ancestry.
Measuring where variation lies
Geneticists compare the variation inside populations with the variation in the species as a whole. One measure uses heterozygosity, the chance that two copies of a gene drawn at random differ. If \(H_T\) is the heterozygosity of the whole species and \(H_S\) the average within populations, the share of variation that lies between populations is
The rest, \(1 - F_{ST}\), lies within them. In 1972 the geneticist Richard Lewontin used blood-group and protein data to conclude that about 85% of human genetic variation lies within populations, and genome-wide studies have broadly confirmed this pattern.
Worked example: apportioning variation
Suppose a study of one gene finds a heterozygosity of 0.30 across all sampled humans and an average of 0.26 within local populations. What share of the variation separates populations? 1. Identify the values: \(H_T = 0.30\) and \(H_S = 0.26\). 2. Subtract: \(0.30 - 0.26 = 0.04\). 3. Divide by the total: \(F_{ST} = 0.04 \div 0.30 \approx 0.13\), so about 13% lies between populations. 4. Find the remainder: about 87% lies within them. 5. Interpret: two people from the same town can differ genetically almost as much as two people from different continents. Real human estimates are typically around 0.1 to 0.15.
Why the field matters now
Biological anthropology has practical work to do. Forensic teams help identify victims of disasters and wars. Studies of growth and nutrition guide public health. Ancient DNA has rewritten the history of human migration, as later topics such as Tracking genomes: the human story show. Primatologists support the conservation of endangered apes and monkeys. Each of these tasks raises ethical questions, from the consent of living communities to the handling of ancestral remains, which the topic Collections, museums, and repatriation takes up. Studying bodies responsibly means working with the communities whose ancestors and relatives are being studied.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking biological anthropology is only about fossils: it also studies living people, primates, DNA and forensic cases. Second, treating races as biological groups: variation is mostly clinal and mostly within populations. Third, reading one trait, such as skin colour, as a sign of overall relatedness: distantly related populations can share similar shades because they live under similar UV. Fourth, assuming biology and culture are separate: practices such as diet and head shaping change bodies. Fifth, mixing up the two heterozygosity values: \(F_{ST}\) is the between-population share, not the within-population share.
Key takeaways
Biological anthropology studies humans as an evolving, variable species and takes a biocultural view. Its areas include palaeoanthropology, primatology, human biology, genetic anthropology, bioarchaeology and forensic anthropology. Skeletons record health, labour and cultural practices. The field grew out of racial classification and has rejected it: the American Association of Physical Anthropologists, founded in 1930, became the American Association of Biological Anthropologists. Human variation is clinal, traits vary independently, and most genetic variation (about 85% to 90%) lies within populations, as \(F_{ST}\) measures. Race is a social reality, not a biological division.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The study of humans as an evolving, biologically variable species
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A researcher studies growth lines in children's bones from a medieval cemetery to learn about famine. Which area of biological anthropology is this?
Question 2 of 5
Which statement matches the scientific consensus on human variation?
Question 3 of 5
A gene has a heterozygosity of 0.40 across all humans sampled and 0.36 on average within populations. What is FST?
Question 4 of 5
Many people of sub-Saharan Africa and many Aboriginal Australians have dark skin, although the two populations are distantly related. Why?
Question 5 of 5
Why did Sherwood Washburn's 1951 "new physical anthropology" matter?
