Anthropology › Section M · Religion and culture › Topic M.1
What is religion?
Every known society has beliefs and practices that outsiders would call religious, yet no definition fits them all. Anthropologists study religion as lived human experience, asking what people believe, who leads them, which beings they relate to and how religion changes as societies grow.
Studying religion as anthropologists
Religion appears in some form in every known society, but its shapes vary enormously: a village spirit medium, a Hindu temple festival, a Quaker meeting held in silence. Anthropologists study it with methodological agnosticism, neither affirming nor denying the truth of religious claims. The question is not whether ancestors or gods exist but what they mean to people and how belief and practice shape social life. Many languages have no term matching the English word religion, so the category itself needs examining.
Three classic definitions
Edward Tylor, in Primitive Culture (1871), offered a minimum definition: religion is belief in spiritual beings. Émile Durkheim (1912), as The sociological approach to religion explained, defined it by sacred things set apart and the moral community they unite. Clifford Geertz, in an essay of 1966, called religion a system of symbols that creates powerful, lasting moods and motivations by formulating ideas of a general order of existence so that the moods and motivations seem uniquely realistic. Tylor stresses belief, Durkheim social life, and Geertz meaning and feeling. Many anthropologists work with a broad version: shared beliefs and practices concerning the relationship between the natural and the supernatural.
Questioning the definitions
Talal Asad, in an essay of 1983 later collected in Genealogies of Religion (1993), argued that Geertz's universal definition carries a modern Protestant Christian assumption: that religion is chiefly a matter of inner belief and meaning. In many traditions what counts most is practice, discipline and authority, such as learning to pray correctly or keeping a fast. Asad also showed that the idea of religion as a separate sphere, apart from politics and science, has its own European history. Cognitive scientists such as Pascal Boyer ask instead why religious ideas spread, arguing that minimally counterintuitive beings, like an invisible person, are easy to remember. Most anthropologists still use definitions, but as tools rather than truths, and they test them against the ways each community describes its own practices.
Religion, spirituality and worldview
Three related terms need separating. Religion usually means shared membership in an organised tradition. Spirituality refers to more loosely structured beliefs and feelings about a person's relation to the sacred, often held individually. Worldview is the broadest: a learned outlook on the nature of life that every person holds, whether religious or secular. Pew Research Center's 2023-24 study found 29% of US adults religiously unaffiliated, yet most of those nones are not atheists, and many pray or call themselves spiritual. Counting membership alone misses much of what people believe and do.
Gods, spirits and ancestors
Religions relate people to many kinds of beings. Deities are named gods and goddesses with personalities and powers; the Sociology topic World religions introduced monotheism and polytheism. Spirits are usually less powerful and often tied to particular places, animals or tasks. Ancestors remain active members of many families. Among the Merina of Madagascar, families hold famadihana, the turning of the bones, every several years, opening tombs to rewrap relatives' remains in new silk shrouds and dance with them, honouring the dead and renewing family ties. Some traditions also recognise impersonal power: mana, a Polynesian and Melanesian word for sacred power that brings success, and tapu, the restrictions that surround it.
Animism, old and new
Tylor used animism, belief that souls or spirits animate people, animals, plants and places, as the starting point of an evolutionary ladder that rose towards monotheism. That ranking has been rejected, because it treated other peoples' religions as early stages of Europe's. The word has been revived with a new meaning. A. Irving Hallowell, working with Ojibwe people around 1930 to 1940, described a world of other-than-human persons, such as certain stones, animals and thunder beings, with whom humans have relationships. Nurit Bird-David (1999), studying the Nayaka of South India, argued that animism is a way of knowing through relationships, not a mistaken theory about objects.
Religious specialists
Most traditions have people with special religious roles. Anthropologists call full-time officials of organised institutions priests, whatever their local title, whether rabbi, imam, pastor or monk; they lead regular rituals and represent established teaching. Prophets call for renewal or change, often from outside the establishment. Max Weber described their authority as charisma, a quality that followers see as extraordinary or divine. Shamans are usually part-time specialists who enter altered states, through drumming, dance, song or fasting, to contact spirits on behalf of clients, for healing or finding game. The word comes from the Evenki language of Siberia, where Europeans first recorded the practice.
Worked example: who is the specialist?
In a hypothetical town, three figures lead religious life. Classify each. 1. A woman trained at a seminary leads weekly services and baptisms in a national church, salaried by that church: a priest, holding an office in an institution. 2. A farmer, after a vision, preaches that the church has grown corrupt and gathers followers who leave it: a prophet, whose authority rests on charisma. 3. An elderly man, called to the work after a serious illness, enters trance with a drum when families ask him to find the cause of a child's sickness: a shaman, a part-time specialist serving individual clients. 4. Check: over time the prophet's movement may train its own priests, as Weber expected charisma to become routine.
Religion in states
As societies grew into states, religion was often institutionalised: full-time clergy formed hierarchies, temples became centres of wealth, and written doctrine set out official teaching. Rulers drew authority from the sacred; Egyptian pharaohs were treated as divine, and Inca rulers claimed descent from the Sun. Religions such as Buddhism, Christianity and Islam spread widely by seeking converts, a practice called proselytisation. States still relate to religion differently: Iran's Islamic Republic (1979) gives senior clergy political power, England has an established church, and France's law of 1905 separated churches and the state. Religion can also fuel resistance, as in Latin American liberation theology, though Karl Marx called it the opium of the people.
Worked example: a shrine at New Year
Millions of people in Japan visit a Shinto shrine in the first days of the year, a custom called hatsumōde, to pray for good fortune, yet in a 2023 Pew survey 42% of Japanese adults said they had no religion. Apply the definitions. 1. Tylor: the shrine honours kami, sacred beings or powers, so the visit fits. 2. Durkheim: the shrine grounds are set apart, and the crowds share a collective act. 3. Geertz: bells, purification with water and paper fortunes create a mood of renewal and hope. 4. Asad's caution: visitors stress what they do, not what they believe, so a belief-based survey question misses the practice. 5. Conclusion: no religion on a form can coexist with active religious practice.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, assuming religion is mainly about belief; in many traditions practice and authority matter more. Second, treating animism as primitive or as an early stage of religion: Tylor's ladder is rejected. Third, equating nones with atheists. Fourth, using priest only for Christian clergy, when anthropologists use it for full-time officials in any tradition. Fifth, assuming shamans are found only in small-scale societies; shamanic practices appear within many religions.
Key takeaways
Anthropologists study religion with methodological agnosticism. Tylor (1871) defined it as belief in spiritual beings, Durkheim (1912) by the sacred and moral community, and Geertz (1966) as a symbol system creating moods and motivations; Asad (1983, 1993) warned that such definitions reflect a belief-centred, Western model. Religion, spirituality and worldview differ, and 29% of US adults were unaffiliated in 2023-24. Religions involve deities, spirits, ancestors and impersonal powers such as mana. New animism sees relationships with other-than-human persons. Priests hold offices, prophets have charisma and shamans enter trance. States institutionalised religion in many different ways.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Studying religion without affirming or denying its truth
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What was Talal Asad's main criticism of Clifford Geertz's definition of religion?
Question 2 of 5
Pew found 29% of US adults religiously unaffiliated in 2023-24. Which conclusion is correct?
Question 3 of 5
A man called to his role by a serious illness enters trance with a drum to find the cause of a child's sickness for her family. Which specialist is he?
Question 4 of 5
How does the new animism of Hallowell and Bird-David differ from Tylor's use of the word?
Question 5 of 5
Many Japanese who visit a shrine at New Year say they have no religion. What does this case show?
