Anthropology › Section M · Religion and culture › Topic M.2

Symbolic and sacred space

Religions are full of symbols, and many of the most powerful are places: a doorway, a shrine, a mountain, a whole homeland. Anthropologists ask how people mark places as sacred, how sacredness is made and remade through use, and what happens when sacred places collide with other interests.

Signs and symbols

A sign is connected to what it indicates by nature or cause: smoke indicates fire, and a footprint indicates that someone walked by. A symbol stands for something by convention alone, so its meaning has to be learned. Nothing in two crossed lines means Christianity until people teach it. Some religious symbols work like metaphors, linking unlike things, as when Christians call Jesus the Lamb of God. Others work like metonyms, letting a part stand for a whole, as the cross, one moment in the story of Jesus, stands for the whole faith. Most religious symbols are also multivocal, carrying several meanings, as Victor Turner showed with the Ndembu mudyi tree in Cultural groups and aggregates.

Key symbols

Sherry Ortner, in an essay of 1973, asked how anthropologists can tell which symbols matter most in a culture. She suggested signs: people say a symbol is important, react to it strongly, meet it in many settings and surround it with rules. She distinguished summarising symbols, which gather many feelings into one object, such as a flag or the cross, from elaborating symbols, which help people sort out experience and act. A flag explains nothing but calls up loyalty at once; a story of a hard-working ancestor offers a model for living.

From space to place

Anthropologists distinguish space, an unmarked physical extent, from place, a location filled with meaning. The geographer Yi-Fu Tuan (1977) described place as space that people have come to know and value. Keith Basso's Wisdom Sits in Places (1996) showed how Western Apache people in Arizona use place names and the stories attached to them to teach moral lessons: mentioning a named spot can remind a listener of a story about someone who behaved badly there. The land itself becomes a moral teacher. Religious places are the most concentrated form of this process, places where people believe the sacred has appeared or can be reached.

Eliade's sacred place

The historian of religion Mircea Eliade, in The Sacred and the Profane (first published in German in 1957, English 1959), called any appearance of the sacred a hierophany. He proposed three features of sacred places. A threshold separates the sacred inside from the profane outside, and crossing it is often marked by gestures such as removing shoes or bowing. A centre, the axis mundi or axis of the world, connects earth with heaven or the realm of spirits, often at the spot where a hierophany occurred. And the place forms an imago mundi, an image of the world as the faith understands it. Critics note that Eliade generalised from texts more than fieldwork.

Worked example: reading a mosque

Apply Eliade's features to a mosque, while checking them against how Muslims describe it. 1. Threshold: worshippers remove their shoes and perform ritual washing, wudu, before prayer, marking a move from ordinary to prayerful space. 2. Centre: the mihrab, a niche in one wall, shows the qibla, the direction of the Ka'ba in Mecca, so every mosque is oriented towards one sacred centre. 3. Image of the world: most mosques avoid images of living beings and use calligraphy and geometric patterns, which many Muslims see as expressing the oneness of God. 4. Check: Muslims do not regard a mosque as God's dwelling; the word masjid means place of prostration, so the model fits orientation better than presence.

Sacred places at home

Sacred space is not only public. Many Jewish households fix a mezuzah, a small case holding a parchment with verses from Deuteronomy, to the doorposts of their home, and some touch it when passing, turning each doorway into a threshold. Many Hindu families keep a household shrine where images of deities receive daily offerings of light, flowers and food in puja. Chinese families have long kept altars where ancestors are honoured with incense. Such domestic places weave sacredness into ordinary routines, so the boundary is crossed many times a day.

Places made by practice

Is sacredness in the place itself or in what people do there? Jonathan Z. Smith, in To Take Place (1987), argued that ritual makes a place sacred: a place is sacred because of the attention it receives. Anthropologists taking a phenomenological, experience-based approach agree that meaning emerges from use. Some sacred places are deliberately temporary. Wiccans, part of a modern Pagan movement that took shape in England in the mid-twentieth century, cast a circle for each ritual and close it afterwards. During the Jewish festival of Sukkot, families build a temporary shelter, the sukkah. A Muslim may unroll a prayer mat in an office or an airport to pray.

Country and the Dreaming

For many Aboriginal Australian peoples, land is not property but Country: a living whole of land, water, sky, ancestors and law, to which people belong as kin. Ancestral beings of the Dreaming are understood to have travelled across Country, shaping its features and laying down law, and their tracks are remembered in songs, dances and paintings. People hold responsibilities to care for particular places. At Uluṟu in central Australia, the Aṉangu traditional owners long asked visitors not to climb the rock, which is sacred to them; the climb was permanently closed on 26 October 2019, after a decision by the national park's board, which has an Aṉangu majority.

Worked example: Juukan Gorge

In May 2020 the mining company Rio Tinto blasted two rock shelters at Juukan Gorge, Western Australia, to expand an iron ore mine. Excavations had shown people using the shelters for about 46,000 years, and they were sacred to the Puutu Kunti Kurrama and Pinikura peoples. Analyse the conflict. 1. Legality: the company held state consent granted in 2013 under Western Australian heritage law. 2. Two values: archaeologists stressed scientific heritage; traditional owners stressed a living sacred connection. 3. Power: the law let a minister approve destruction, and owners said they could not stop it. 4. Outcome: public outrage, a parliamentary inquiry, and the departure of Rio Tinto's chief executive. 5. Lesson: legal is not the same as respectful.

Sacred time

Sacredness also marks time. Eliade argued that religious festivals let people re-enter the time of origins rather than merely remember it. Calendars divide the year into ordinary days and holy days: the weekly Sabbath, Ramadan, Easter, Diwali, Passover and Lunar New Year among them. Because the Islamic calendar is lunar, Ramadan moves about eleven days earlier each year through the solar seasons. Sacred time and space often meet: pilgrims travel to particular places at particular times, and a temple may be crowded on a festival day and quiet on others.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing signs with symbols: a symbol's meaning is learned, not natural. Second, assuming a symbol has one fixed meaning. Third, applying Eliade's model mechanically, without checking how believers describe their own places. Fourth, treating sacredness as only a property of buildings, when practice can make a place sacred, even temporarily. Fifth, describing Aboriginal Country as scenery or property rather than as a living set of relationships and responsibilities. Sixth, assuming that because an action is legal, as at Juukan Gorge, it respects a community's sacred places.

Key takeaways

Signs have natural links; symbols are conventional, may work as metaphors or metonyms, and are often multivocal. Ortner (1973) distinguished summarising from elaborating key symbols. Place is space filled with meaning, as Basso (1996) showed for Western Apache place names. Eliade (1957) described thresholds, an axis mundi and an imago mundi, but his model must be tested against believers' views. J. Z. Smith (1987) argued that ritual makes places sacred, and some sacred places are temporary. Aboriginal Country links land, ancestors and law; Uluṟu's climb closed in 2019, and Juukan Gorge's destruction in 2020 showed sacred places at risk. Festivals create sacred time.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Sign

Something linked to its meaning by nature or cause

Smoke indicates fire.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which is a symbol rather than a sign?

Question 2 of 5

In Eliade's terms, what does the mihrab of a mosque, showing the direction of the Ka'ba, most closely express?

Question 3 of 5

What did Jonathan Z. Smith argue in To Take Place (1987)?

Question 4 of 5

The destruction of the Juukan Gorge rock shelters in 2020 was carried out with state consent. What lesson do anthropologists draw?

Question 5 of 5

Why did Sherry Ortner call a national flag a summarising symbol?

← Previous topicNext topic →