Astronomy › Section B · Observing the sky › Topic B.2

Ancient astronomy

Long before telescopes, people across the world tracked the sky closely enough to keep calendars, predict eclipses and cross oceans. Greek astronomers went further, working out the shape and size of Earth and building a model of planetary motion that lasted well over a thousand years.

Sky-watchers around the world

Many ancient societies studied the sky for practical and religious reasons. Egyptians used a 365-day calendar and watched for the first predawn appearance of the bright star Sirius, which came near the season of the Nile flood. Babylonian scribes kept centuries of written records of the Moon and planets and learned to predict lunar eclipses from repeating cycles. Chinese astronomers recorded comets, sunspots and "guest stars", including the 1054 explosion whose remains we now call the Crab Nebula. Maya astronomers tabulated the cycles of Venus, and Polynesian navigators steered by rising and setting stars across thousands of kilometres of open Pacific.

Monuments aligned with the sky

Before writing reached Britain, people there built stone circles that line up with key points in the Sun's and Moon's yearly cycles. The best known, Stonehenge, was built and rebuilt in stages from roughly 3000 to 1500 BCE, with the great stone circle raised around 2500 BCE. Its main axis points towards sunrise at the summer solstice and sunset at the winter solstice. Archaeologists debate how much more astronomy the builders encoded, and claims that it was a precise eclipse computer remain disputed. What is clear is that marking the turning points of the year mattered enough to move stones weighing many tonnes.

Greek evidence for a round Earth

By about 2,500 years ago, educated Greeks thought Earth was a sphere, an idea some linked to Pythagoras. Aristotle, writing in the 300s BCE, gave observational reasons. First, during a lunar eclipse Earth's shadow on the Moon always has a curved edge; only a sphere casts a round shadow from every direction, whereas a flat disc would sometimes cast a thin line. Second, a traveller heading south sees new stars rise above the southern horizon while the northern pole of the sky sinks lower, which could not happen if the ground were flat. Ships also vanish hull first over the horizon.

A moving Earth, rejected

Aristarchus of Samos, in the 200s BCE, proposed that Earth orbits the Sun. Most Greek thinkers rejected it, and they had a real scientific argument. If Earth moved around the Sun, nearby stars should appear to shift slightly against more distant ones over a year, just as nearby trees seem to slide past distant hills when you ride in a car. This apparent shift caused by the observer's motion is parallax. No such stellar parallax could be seen. Either Earth stood still or the stars were unimaginably far away. The stars are in fact that far: stellar parallax was first measured only in 1838, by Friedrich Bessel, with Thomas Henderson and Friedrich Struve close behind.

Eratosthenes measures Earth

Eratosthenes, a scholar working in Alexandria in the 200s BCE, measured Earth's size with geometry. The Sun is so distant that its rays reach Earth as parallel lines. At noon on the summer solstice the Sun stood directly overhead at Syene, near modern Aswan, but in Alexandria, to the north, a vertical rod cast a shadow showing the Sun about 1/50 of a circle, 7.2°, from overhead. Since the rays are parallel, that angle equals the angle between the two cities at Earth's centre. He took the distance as 5,000 stadia, giving 250,000 stadia around. How accurate this was depends on the length of his stadium, which is uncertain: estimates range from close to the true 40,000 km to roughly 20% too large.

Worked example: measuring Earth yourself

Two schools 500 km apart on a north-south line measure the Sun's angle from vertical at the same local noon. One finds 18.0° and the other 22.5°. What is Earth's circumference? 1. The difference in angle is \(22.5^\circ - 18.0^\circ = 4.5^\circ\), and with parallel rays this is the angle at Earth's centre between the schools. 2. The fraction of a full circle is \(\frac{4.5}{360} = \frac{1}{80}\). 3. So 500 km is 1/80 of the circumference: \(C = 80 \times 500 = 40{,}000\) km. 4. Check: 1° of latitude should then be about \(\frac{40{,}000}{360} \approx 111\) km, which matches the modern value.

Hipparchus and precession

Hipparchus, working on Rhodes in the 100s BCE, is often called the greatest astronomer of antiquity. He compiled a star catalogue, probably of about 850 stars, giving each a position, and he is credited with ranking stars by brightness into magnitudes, a scheme still used in modified form. Comparing his positions with records made about 150 years earlier, he found that the stars had all shifted in the same way. He had discovered precession: Earth's axis slowly swings around in a cone, like the wobble of a spinning top, taking about 26,000 years per circuit. The pulls of the Sun and Moon on Earth's equatorial bulge drive it.

Worked example: how fast is precession?

1. One circuit of 360° takes about 25,800 years, so the rate is \(\frac{360^\circ}{25{,}800\text{ yr}} = 0.0140^\circ\) per year. 2. In arcseconds that is \(0.0140 \times 3600 = 50.2''\) per year, far too small to notice in a lifetime. 3. Over the roughly 150 years between the records Hipparchus compared, the shift is \(150 \times 0.0140 = 2.1^\circ\), about four times the full Moon's width and large enough for careful observers to detect. 4. Over millennia the pole moves among the stars: about 4,800 years ago it lay near the star Thuban, Polaris will be closest around the year 2100, and Vega will be near the pole roughly 12,000 years from now.

Ptolemy's model

Claudius Ptolemy, working in Alexandria around 150 CE, summarised Greek astronomy in the book now known by its Arabic name, Almagest. Its hardest problem was retrograde motion: every so often a planet such as Mars stops, drifts westward against the stars for weeks, then resumes its usual eastward path. We now know this happens when Earth overtakes the slower outer planet. Keeping Earth fixed and using only circles, Ptolemy placed each planet on a small circle, the epicycle, whose centre moved around a larger circle, the deferent. He added off-centre circles and a point called the equant to match the data.

A model that lasted

Ptolemy's geocentric, or Earth-centred, model could predict planetary positions for any date to within a few degrees or better, which is why it remained standard for about 1,400 years. Scholars in the Islamic world translated and tested it, measured key values more accurately and, in the work of astronomers such as Ibn al-Shatir in the 1300s, built new geometric devices that avoided the equant. Historians still debate whether Ptolemy meant his circles as a physical picture or as a calculating tool. Either way, it was a serious scientific model: built from data and judged by its predictions.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, believing people before Columbus thought Earth was flat; educated Europeans had known it was round since Greek times. Second, assuming the Greeks rejected a moving Earth out of pure prejudice; the missing stellar parallax was a genuine argument. Third, forgetting that Eratosthenes's accuracy depends on the uncertain length of the stadium. Fourth, confusing precession, a 26,000-year wobble of Earth's axis, with Earth's daily spin. Fifth, dismissing Ptolemy's model as foolish; it predicted planetary positions well for centuries.

Key takeaways

Egyptian, Babylonian, Chinese, Maya, Polynesian and ancient British astronomers tracked the sky for calendars, prediction and navigation. Aristotle argued for a round Earth from eclipse shadows and changing stars. Aristarchus proposed a Sun-centred system, rejected partly because no stellar parallax was seen; it was first measured in 1838. Eratosthenes found Earth's size from shadow angles and a known distance. Hipparchus catalogued stars and discovered the 26,000-year precession of Earth's axis. Ptolemy's geocentric model of epicycles and deferents reproduced retrograde motion and lasted about 1,400 years.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Sirius and the Nile

Egyptians watched for Sirius's first predawn rising near the flood season

They used a 365-day calendar.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Two towns 600 km apart north to south measure noon Sun angles that differ by 5.4°. What circumference do they find for Earth?

Question 2 of 5

Which observation did Aristotle use as evidence that Earth is a sphere?

Question 3 of 5

Why did most Greek scholars reject Aristarchus's idea that Earth orbits the Sun?

Question 4 of 5

What is precession?

Question 5 of 5

In Ptolemy's model, what was the main job of the epicycles?

← Previous topicNext topic →