Astronomy › Section B · Observing the sky › Topic B.3

Astrology and astronomy

Astrology and astronomy grew up together, and for centuries the same people practised both. They have long since parted: astronomy became a science, while astrology's claims have not survived scientific testing. Seeing why is a clear lesson in how science judges an idea.

Two subjects with one root

For most of history, watching the sky meant looking for meaning as well as pattern. Many cultures linked the Sun, Moon and planets with gods, and an eclipse or a new comet was read as a message about rulers, harvests or wars. Astrology is the belief that the positions of these bodies influence human affairs and personalities. Astronomy is the scientific study of the bodies themselves. The two were not separated for a very long time: even Johannes Kepler, one of the founders of modern astronomy, cast horoscopes for paying clients in the early 1600s.

How astrology began

Astrology grew from Babylonian omen-reading, in which court scholars interpreted events in the sky as warnings for the king and the kingdom. Horoscopes for individuals appeared later; the oldest known one, written in cuneiform, is dated to about 410 BCE. After Alexander the Great's conquests, Greek thinkers combined Babylonian sky-lore with their own geometry and philosophy and made astrology personal: a person's character and fortune were said to depend on the sky at the moment of birth. This is natal astrology. In the 100s CE, Ptolemy, whose astronomy appears in "Ancient astronomy", wrote the Tetrabiblos, which remains a basic text of Western astrology.

The horoscope and the signs

A horoscope is a chart of where the Sun, Moon and planets stood in the zodiac at a given moment, seen from a given place, usually a person's birth. Astrology divides the zodiac into 12 equal signs of 30° each, named after constellations the Sun passed through when the system was set up. It also divides the sky into "houses" based on the rotating sky at that moment. When people ask your "sign", they mean your sun sign: the sign the Sun was in on your birthday. Rules for interpreting the chart vary between schools, so two astrologers may read the same chart differently.

Signs and constellations no longer match

Because of precession, the slow wobble of Earth's axis, the point where the Sun crosses the celestial equator each March drifts westward against the stars, about 50 arcseconds a year. Most Western astrology fixed its signs to the seasons about 2,000 years ago and never moved them. The real constellations have since slipped by nearly a whole sign. The ecliptic also passes through 13 constellations, not 12: between late November and mid-December the Sun lies in Ophiuchus, which has no sign. And the constellations have unequal sizes, so the Sun spends anything from under a week to more than six weeks in each.

Worked example: how far have the signs slipped?

Precession shifts the stars relative to the signs by about 50.3 arcseconds per year. 1. Over 2,000 years the shift is \(2000 \times 50.3 = 100{,}600\) arcseconds. 2. Convert to degrees: \(\frac{100{,}600}{3600} = 27.9^\circ\). 3. Compare with one sign, 30°: the drift is almost a full sign. 4. Consequence: a person born on 1 April has the sun sign Aries, but on that date the Sun actually lies among the stars of Pisces. 5. Check: one full sign of drift takes about \(\frac{30 \times 3600}{50.3} \approx 2150\) years, consistent with a system set up about 2,000 years ago.

Is there a force that could do it?

Science first asks whether a proposed effect has a possible cause. The known forces that act over large distances are gravity and electromagnetism, and both weaken rapidly with distance. The planets are so far away that their pull on a newborn baby is tiny compared with everyday objects nearby, and none of them emits anything that could shape a personality. Astrologers therefore have to suppose an unknown influence that does not weaken with distance and has never been detected. That does not by itself prove astrology false, but it means its claims must stand or fall on direct tests.

Worked example: Mars or the doctor?

Compare the gravitational pull on a 3.5 kg newborn from Mars and from a 70 kg doctor, using \(F = \frac{Gm_1m_2}{r^2}\) with \(G = 6.67 \times 10^{-11}\ \mathrm{N\,m^2\,kg^{-2}}\) and treating each body as a point. 1. Doctor, 0.50 m away:

F = \frac{(6.67 \times 10^{-11})(3.5)(70)}{(0.50)^2} = 6.5 \times 10^{-8}\ \mathrm{N}

2. Mars, \(6.42 \times 10^{23}\) kg, at its closest, about \(5.6 \times 10^{10}\) m:

F = \frac{(6.67 \times 10^{-11})(3.5)(6.42 \times 10^{23})}{(5.6 \times 10^{10})^2} = 4.8 \times 10^{-8}\ \mathrm{N}

3. Compare: the doctor pulls about 1.4 times harder, and about 70 times harder when Mars is at its farthest. The gravity law itself is taught in "Newton's universal law of gravitation".

Testing astrology directly

Astrology makes claims that can be tested, and it has been tested many times. Studies of thousands of people have looked for links between sun signs and occupation, personality scores or marriage, and found none beyond chance. A well-known double-blind test by the physicist Shawn Carlson, published in the journal Nature in 1985, asked astrologers to match people's birth charts to their personality profiles, choosing from three profiles each. They picked the right one about one time in three, exactly what guessing would give. Astrologers had agreed the test was fair before it began.

Why horoscopes can feel accurate

If astrology fails controlled tests, why do readings often feel right? In 1949 the psychologist Bertram Forer gave students what he said were personal profiles; in fact all received the same vague statements, such as having unused potential. On average they rated the accuracy about 4.3 out of 5. People readily accept general, flattering descriptions as personal, now called the Forer or Barnum effect. We also remember the hits and forget the misses. A good astrologer may be a warm, perceptive listener, which can genuinely help someone, but that comes from the conversation, not the planets.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing the two words: astronomy is the science, astrology the belief system. Second, assuming your sun sign names the constellation behind the Sun on your birthday; precession has moved it by nearly a sign. Third, saying the zodiac has exactly 12 constellations; the ecliptic crosses 13, including Ophiuchus. Fourth, thinking astrology is unscientific simply because it is old or involves planets; the problem is that its claims fail controlled tests. Fifth, mocking people who enjoy horoscopes; the aim is to understand the evidence, not to belittle anyone.

Key takeaways

Astrology claims that the Sun, Moon and planets shape human lives; astronomy studies those bodies scientifically. Astrology began in Babylonian omen-reading, became personal in the Greek world and was codified in Ptolemy's Tetrabiblos. A horoscope charts the sky at birth on 12 signs of 30°. Precession, about 50 arcseconds per year, has moved the constellations nearly a full sign from the signs, and the ecliptic crosses 13 constellations. No known force could produce astrological effects, and controlled tests such as Carlson's show no predictive power, so astrology is classed as a pseudoscience.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Astrology

The belief that positions of the Sun, Moon and planets influence human affairs

Not a science; its claims fail tests.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A 70 kg doctor stands 0.50 m from a 3.5 kg newborn while Mars is at its closest, 5.6 × 10¹⁰ m away. Which pulls harder on the baby?

Question 2 of 5

Why are astrological signs now out of step with the constellations they were named after?

Question 3 of 5

How many constellations does the Sun pass through along the ecliptic during a year?

Question 4 of 5

In Carlson's 1985 double-blind test, how did astrologers do at matching birth charts to personality profiles?

Question 5 of 5

What best explains why astronomers classify astrology as a pseudoscience?

← Previous topicNext topic →