Astronomy › Section R · Black holes and curved spacetime › Topic R.4
Evidence for black holes
A black hole gives off no light of its own, yet astronomers have weighed dozens, watched stars race around one at the centre of our galaxy and even photographed the shadows of two. The trick is to study what a black hole does to its surroundings.
How to find something black
A stellar-mass black hole is only tens of kilometres across and emits nothing, so it cannot be seen directly. But its gravity still acts on everything nearby. Astronomers therefore look for its effects: a star orbiting an invisible partner, gas heated to millions of kelvin as it spirals inwards, starlight bent as it passes, or ripples in spacetime when black holes merge. One rule makes all of this work. Since gravity far from a black hole is the same as for any equal mass, as "Black holes" explained, ordinary orbit laws can weigh it.
The recipe for a stellar black hole
First, find a binary in which the Doppler shifts of one star's spectral lines show it orbiting a companion that cannot be seen. Second, use Kepler's third law with the orbit's size and period to find the unseen object's mass. If it is clearly above about 3 solar masses (one solar mass, \(M_\odot\), is about \(1.99 \times 10^{30}\) kg), it is too heavy to be a white dwarf or a neutron star. Third, check that it is compact, often from X-rays: gas pulled from the companion forms an accretion disc, a swirling flattened disc in which friction heats the inner gas to millions of kelvin, so it flickers in X-rays. These X-rays can be seen only by telescopes in space.
Worked example: weighing an unseen companion
A 20-solar-mass star orbits an invisible companion every 6.0 days, and the stars are 0.20 astronomical units apart (one AU, the Earth-Sun distance, is about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m). Is the companion a black hole? 1. Newton's form of Kepler's third law, in AU, years and solar masses: \(M_{\text{total}} = \frac{a^3}{P^2}\). 2. Period in years: \(P = \frac{6.0}{365.25} = 0.0164\) yr. 3. Total mass, in solar masses:
4. Companion: \(29.6 - 20 = 9.6\) solar masses, far above the neutron-star limit. 5. If it is also compact and dark, it is a black hole. In practice the orbit's tilt to our line of sight must be measured too, which is often the hardest step.
Cygnus X-1 and its relatives
The first strong case was Cygnus X-1, an X-ray source found in the 1960s and identified in the early 1970s with a hot blue supergiant orbiting an unseen companion every 5.6 days. Its X-rays flicker in a few thousandths of a second, so the source must be smaller than a few hundred kilometres. The companion is now estimated at about 21 solar masses, about 7,000 light-years away. A few dozen black holes in X-ray binaries have since had their masses measured, mostly between about 5 and 20 solar masses.
Quiet black holes
Not every black hole is feeding. The European Space Agency's Gaia spacecraft measures stellar positions so precisely that it can see a star wobble around an invisible partner. From 2022 its data revealed Gaia BH1, about 10 solar masses and about 1,600 light-years away, the nearest black hole known. In 2024 came Gaia BH3, about 33 solar masses and about 1,900 light-years away, the most massive stellar black hole yet found in the Milky Way. In 2022 astronomers also reported a lone black hole of about 7 solar masses drifting through space, detected because its gravity briefly magnified the light of a star behind it.
The black hole at the centre of the Milky Way
At the centre of our galaxy lies a compact radio source called Sagittarius A*. For about three decades, teams led by Reinhard Genzel and Andrea Ghez tracked stars orbiting it, using infrared light that passes through the galaxy's dust. One star, S2, completes an orbit every 16 years and swings within about 120 AU of the centre. The orbits show a mass of about 4.3 million solar masses packed into a region smaller than our solar system, leaving no explanation except a supermassive black hole. Genzel and Ghez shared the 2020 Nobel Prize in Physics with Roger Penrose, who had shown that general relativity makes black hole formation unavoidable.
Worked example: weighing Sagittarius A*
The star S2 orbits Sagittarius A* with a semi-major axis of about 1,040 AU and a period of 16.05 years. What mass does this imply? 1. S2's own mass is tiny by comparison, so \(M \approx \frac{a^3}{P^2}\) in solar masses. 2. Cube the semi-major axis: \(1040^3 = 1.12 \times 10^{9}\). 3. Square the period: \(16.05^2 = 258\). 4. Divide: \(M \approx \frac{1.12 \times 10^{9}}{258} = 4.37 \times 10^{6}\) solar masses. 5. Check: this is close to the published value of about 4.3 million; the small gap comes from rounding and from uncertainty in the distance to the centre, which sets the AU value of the orbit. In 2018, S2's light was also seen to be gravitationally redshifted at its closest approach, by the amount general relativity predicts.
Pictures of black hole shadows
The Event Horizon Telescope links radio dishes across the world into one Earth-sized telescope, sharp enough to see detail near a horizon. In April 2019 it released the first image of a black hole: a bright ring of hot gas around a dark centre, the shadow of the 6.5-billion-solar-mass black hole M87* in the galaxy M87, about 55 million light-years away. In May 2022 it released an image of Sagittarius A*. Both rings had the sizes general relativity predicts for their masses. Later results, including images in polarised light and repeat observations from other years, show the M87* ring persisting, as it should for a real shadow.
A whole range of masses
Black holes now seem to span a huge range. Stellar ones are a few to a few tens of solar masses. Supermassive ones, found at the centres of most large galaxies, run from about a million to, by some estimates, tens of billions of solar masses. Between them, intermediate-mass black holes of hundreds to many thousands of solar masses have long been hard to pin down, though evidence is growing, such as fast-moving stars at the centre of the globular cluster Omega Centauri reported in 2024. The James Webb Space Telescope has found actively growing black holes when the universe was well under a billion years old, and how they grew so fast is debated.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking an invisible companion must be a black hole: it could be a faint star or a neutron star, so the mass and compactness must be checked. Second, believing the X-rays come from inside the black hole: they come from hot gas outside the horizon. Third, forgetting that Kepler's law gives the total mass of both bodies. Fourth, thinking the Event Horizon Telescope photographed the hole itself: it imaged the glowing ring around its shadow. Fifth, assuming every black hole sits in an X-ray binary: many, like Gaia BH3, are quiet.
Key takeaways
Black holes are found from their effects. In binaries, Kepler's third law gives an unseen object's mass; above about 3 solar masses and compact, it is a black hole, as in Cygnus X-1, about 21 solar masses. Accretion discs heat gas to millions of kelvin, producing X-rays. Gaia found quiet black holes, including Gaia BH3, about 33 solar masses, in 2024. Stars orbiting Sagittarius A* show about 4.3 million solar masses, earning the 2020 Nobel Prize. The Event Horizon Telescope imaged the shadows of M87* in 2019 and Sagittarius A* in 2022.
Flashcards
Flashcard
By their gravity and their effects on gas and light
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A star orbits an unseen companion every 0.10 years, and their separation is 0.30 AU. What is the total mass of the pair?
Question 2 of 5
Why are the X-rays from Cygnus X-1 taken as evidence of a compact object?
Question 3 of 5
What did the Event Horizon Telescope image in 2019?
Question 4 of 5
An invisible object in a binary has 1.6 solar masses and gives off X-rays. What is it most likely to be?
Question 5 of 5
How was the mass of Sagittarius A* measured?
