Astronomy › Section R · Black holes and curved spacetime › Topic R.3

Black holes

If a collapsing core is too heavy even for degenerate neutrons, nothing can stop it. It shrinks inside a boundary from which not even light escapes, leaving a black hole: the simplest, strangest object general relativity predicts.

When nothing can stop the collapse

The topic "Massive stars: an explosive finish" showed that degenerate neutrons can support a collapsed core of at most a little over 2 solar masses, perhaps up to about 3 (one solar mass, \(M_\odot\), is about \(1.99 \times 10^{30}\) kg). A heavier core keeps collapsing, and no known force can halt it. To see what results, start with escape speed, met in "Orbits in the solar system and spacecraft motion":

v_{\text{esc}} = \sqrt{\frac{2GM}{R}}

Squeeze a fixed mass into a smaller radius and the escape speed rises. The Sun's is about 618 km/s; squeezed to 20 km across it would be over half the speed of light.

Dark stars and black holes

The idea is older than relativity. In 1783 the English clergyman and natural philosopher John Michell reasoned with Newton's gravity that a star compact enough would have an escape speed greater than the speed of light, so its light could not leave; in 1796 Pierre-Simon Laplace made a similar argument. Such objects stayed a curiosity until general relativity. In 1916 Karl Schwarzschild, serving in the German army in the First World War, found the first exact solution of Einstein's equations, describing spacetime around a non-spinning mass, shortly before he died. The name black hole was popularised by the physicist John Wheeler from 1967.

Worked example: the Schwarzschild radius

Set the escape speed equal to the speed of light, \(c = 3.00 \times 10^{8}\) m/s, and solve for the radius. 1. \(c = \sqrt{\frac{2GM}{R}}\), so \(c^2 = \frac{2GM}{R}\). 2. Rearrange:

R_S = \frac{2GM}{c^2}

General relativity gives exactly this formula for the radius of a non-spinning black hole's horizon. 3. For the Sun:

R_S = \frac{2 \times 6.67 \times 10^{-11} \times 1.99 \times 10^{30}}{(3.00 \times 10^{8})^2} = 2.95 \times 10^{3}\ \mathrm{m}

about 3 km. 4. Because \(R_S\) is proportional to \(M\), a 10-solar-mass black hole has \(R_S \approx 29.5\) km, and Earth would have to be squeezed to about 9 mm, the size of a marble. 5. Check: about 3 km per solar mass, a handy rule.

The event horizon

In relativity, gravity does not pull light; mass curves spacetime and light follows the straightest available paths. As a collapsing star shrinks, the curvature near it grows. When the star is 1.5 times its Schwarzschild radius, light can only just circle it. Shrink it a little further and even light aimed straight outwards bends back. Once the star is inside its Schwarzschild radius, every path, in every direction, leads inwards. The surface at that radius is the event horizon: events inside it can never affect anything outside. It is not a solid surface; it is a point of no return, and for a non-spinning black hole its size depends only on the mass inside it.

Worked example: a giant black hole

The Milky Way's central black hole, discussed in the next topic, has about 4.3 million solar masses. What is its Schwarzschild radius, and what is its average density inside the horizon? 1. Using about 2.95 km per solar mass: \(R_S = 4.3 \times 10^{6} \times 2.95 = 1.27 \times 10^{7}\) km, about 0.085 astronomical units (an AU is the Earth-Sun distance, about \(1.496 \times 10^{8}\) km). 2. Mass: \(M = 4.3 \times 10^{6} \times 1.99 \times 10^{30} = 8.56 \times 10^{36}\) kg. 3. Density: \(\frac{M}{\frac{4}{3}\pi R_S^3} = 1.0 \times 10^{6}\ \mathrm{kg/m^3}\), about a thousand times water. 4. Since \(R_S \propto M\), density falls as \(\frac{1}{M^2}\); for 6.5 billion solar masses it is only about \(0.44\ \mathrm{kg/m^3}\), less than air. A black hole need not be dense, only compact.

Not a cosmic vacuum cleaner

Black holes do not roam about sucking things in. Far from a black hole, its gravity is exactly that of any other object with the same mass. If the Sun were somehow replaced by a black hole of one solar mass, Earth would keep the same orbit, though it would freeze in the dark. Only within a few Schwarzschild radii does gravity differ strongly from Newton's predictions. A spacecraft passing a one-solar-mass black hole at the distance of the Sun's radius, about 236,000 times its horizon radius, would follow an ordinary Newtonian path.

Time near a black hole

Gravitational time dilation, introduced in "Tests of relativity and time in gravity", becomes extreme near a horizon. For a clock held at rest at distance \(r\) from a non-spinning black hole, a distant observer sees it tick slow by a factor of \(\frac{1}{\sqrt{1 - R_S/r}}\). At \(r = 2R_S\) the factor is 1.41; at \(r = 1.01R_S\) it is about 10, so ten years would pass far away for every year near the hole. Watching someone fall in, a distant observer sees their signals arrive ever further apart and ever more redshifted, until they seem to freeze and fade at the horizon. The falling person notices nothing special and crosses the horizon in a short time by their own clock.

Spaghettification

Close to a black hole, gravity changes steeply with distance. A falling astronaut's feet, nearer the hole, are pulled harder than her head, so she is stretched lengthways and squeezed sideways, a process nicknamed spaghettification. For a black hole of a few solar masses these tidal forces would kill her well outside the event horizon. For a supermassive black hole of millions or billions of solar masses, the stretching near the horizon is far gentler, and she could cross it alive, only to meet lethal tides much deeper inside.

Simple outside, mysterious inside

However complicated the star that formed it, a black hole settles down to be described by just three numbers: its mass, its spin and its electric charge, which is close to zero in practice. Physicists summarise this as "black holes have no hair". Spinning black holes, which most real ones are, drag the spacetime around them. Inside, general relativity predicts that the matter collapses to a singularity of infinite density, but that is where the theory breaks down; a theory joining gravity with quantum physics is still needed. In 1974 Stephen Hawking showed that quantum effects should make black holes emit faint radiation and slowly evaporate, far too weakly to detect for stellar-mass ones.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking a black hole's gravity reaches out further than that of the star it came from: at the same distance it is the same. Second, picturing the event horizon as a solid surface: it is a boundary in spacetime. Third, assuming all black holes are fantastically dense: average density inside the horizon falls as 1/M². Fourth, thinking a distant observer sees things fall in: they appear to freeze and fade at the horizon. Fifth, treating the singularity as well understood: it marks where general relativity stops working.

Key takeaways

A collapsed core heavier than roughly 2 to 3 solar masses becomes a black hole. Setting the escape speed equal to c gives the Schwarzschild radius, R_S = 2GM/c², about 3 km per solar mass, which general relativity confirms. The event horizon at that radius is a point of no return whose size, without spin, depends only on mass. Far away, a black hole's gravity is that of any equal mass. Near the horizon, time slows by 1/√(1 − R_S/r) as seen from afar, and tides stretch infalling objects. Black holes are described by mass, spin and charge alone; their central singularity marks the limit of present physics.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Black hole

A region from which nothing, not even light, can escape

Left by cores above about 2 to 3 M☉.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Using about 2.95 km per solar mass, what is the Schwarzschild radius of a 20-solar-mass black hole?

Question 2 of 5

If the Sun were replaced by a black hole of exactly one solar mass, what would happen to Earth's orbit?

Question 3 of 5

A clock hovers at r = 4R_S from a black hole. By what factor does a distant observer see it run slow?

Question 4 of 5

A distant observer watches a probe fall towards a black hole. What do they see?

Question 5 of 5

Why does the average density inside the event horizon fall for more massive black holes?

← Previous topicNext topic →