Astronomy › Section G · The solar system and Earth › Topic G.3

Dating planetary surfaces

How can anyone know that a patch of the Moon is older than a patch of Mars, or that a rock is 3.8 billion years old? Two clocks do the job: craters that pile up over time, and radioactive atoms that decay at a fixed rate.

Surface age is not planet age

Every solid world in the solar system formed about 4.6 billion years ago, but their surfaces can be far younger. Lava flows bury old ground, and on Earth water, ice and wind wear it away and moving crust recycles it. So when astronomers date a surface, they are measuring how long ago that surface last solidified or was wiped clean, not when the planet was born. An ancient surface means a long-quiet world; a young one means recent activity.

Counting craters

Impacts from space strike every solid surface. For the last three billion years or so the impact rate has been roughly steady, so on a surface that nothing has disturbed, the number of craters grows in proportion to the time it has been exposed. More craters per unit area means an older surface. This gives relative ages immediately: on the Moon, the bright, crowded highlands are older than the smooth, dark lava plains called maria. To turn crater counts into ages in years, the count must be calibrated against rocks whose ages have been measured in a laboratory.

A clean slate, not a clock that never stops

A crater count measures the time since the last reset. Think of a new car park: on its first day the tarmac is spotless, and oil stains build up year by year. Count the stains and you can tell how long ago it was resurfaced, but not when the town was founded. Likewise, a lava flood or a nearby giant impact can erase older craters and restart the count. Two regions of one world with very different crater densities therefore record different resurfacing times, which lets geologists work out the order of events across a planet's surface.

Worked example: two regions of one moon

Suppose that on an airless moon, craters wider than 1 km form at a steady 4 per 1,000 km² per billion years. Region A has 10 such craters per 1,000 km², and region B has 2. 1. Age is count divided by rate. 2. Region A: \(10 \div 4 = 2.5\) billion years. 3. Region B: \(2 \div 4 = 0.5\) billion years. 4. Interpret: B was resurfaced, perhaps by lava, about 2 billion years after A last was. The steady-rate assumption is the weak point: before about 3.8 billion years ago the impact rate was much higher, so very old surfaces need a calibrated curve, not a straight line.

Radioactive decay

Some atomic nuclei are unstable and decay spontaneously into other nuclei, giving off particles and energy. The original isotope is called the parent and its product the daughter. No one can predict when a single nucleus will decay, just as no one can predict a single roll of a die. But in a huge number of nuclei, half will have decayed after a fixed time called the half-life, half of the rest after a second half-life, and so on. After \(n\) half-lives the fraction of parent left is \(\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^n\). For example, if one-eighth of the parent remains, three half-lives have passed.

Turning decay into an age

When a rock crystallises from melt, its minerals lock in parent atoms. If none of the daughter was present at the start and none has escaped since, every daughter atom now in the mineral came from a parent that decayed. The ratio of daughter to parent, \(D/P\), then grows steadily with time. A ratio of 1 means one half-life has passed, 3 means two, and 7 means three. In general the age is

t = T_{1/2} \log_2\left(1 + \frac{D}{P}\right)

where \(T_{1/2}\) is the half-life. Geologists check the closed-system assumption by dating one rock with two or more independent clocks.

The clocks geologists use

Useful parent isotopes have half-lives long enough to measure billions of years. The most widely used pairs include uranium-238 decaying to lead-206, with a half-life of 4.47 billion years; uranium-235 to lead-207, 0.704 billion years; potassium-40 to argon-40, 1.25 billion years; and rubidium-87 to strontium-87, about 49.6 billion years. The number in each name is the mass number, the count of protons plus neutrons, which identifies the isotope. Because uranium-238 and uranium-235 decay at different rates into different lead isotopes, a single mineral such as zircon carries two built-in clocks that check each other.

Worked example: a uranium–lead age

A zircon crystal contains 0.50 atoms of lead-206 for every atom of uranium-238. Assume it held no lead when it formed and has lost none. The half-life is 4.47 billion years. 1. The ratio is \(D/P = 0.50\). 2. Substitute: \(t = 4.47 \times \log_2(1.50)\). 3. \(\log_2(1.50) = 0.585\), so \(t = 4.47 \times 0.585 = 2.61\) billion years. 4. Check the size: a ratio of 1 would mean exactly one half-life, 4.47 billion years, and 0.50 is less than 1, so the age must be less than one half-life. 5. Check the fraction left: \(\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^{0.585} = 0.667\), so two-thirds of the uranium remains, matching one lead atom for every two uranium atoms.

What the dates have revealed

Before the Apollo missions, some scientists thought the Moon's surface might be young and geologically active. Laboratory dating of returned samples, from 1969 on, showed instead that the lunar lava plains mostly solidified about 3.1 to 3.9 billion years ago and the highlands are older still. China's Chang'e-5 mission returned basalt in 2020 that dates to only about 2 billion years, a valuable new point on the crater-count calibration curve. The oldest solids in meteorites are about 4.57 billion years old, which dates the solar system itself, and the oldest known Earth minerals, zircons from Western Australia, are about 4.4 billion years old.

Radioactivity as a heat source

Each decay releases a little energy as heat. One nucleus gives off almost nothing, but a planet contains enormous numbers of radioactive atoms, so the total is large, especially early on, when short-lived isotopes were still abundant. Today, the decay of uranium, thorium and potassium inside Earth supplies roughly half of the heat flowing out of the planet, although estimates vary. The rest is heat left over from Earth's formation. This internal heat is what keeps volcanoes and moving crust active, which in turn keeps renewing Earth's surface and resetting its crater clock.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating a crater age as the planet's age; it dates only the last resurfacing. Second, assuming more craters always means proportionally older: very old surfaces become saturated, with new craters erasing old ones, and early impact rates were higher. Third, thinking two half-lives leave nothing; they leave one-quarter. Fourth, reading the daughter-to-parent ratio as the fraction decayed: \(D/P = 1\) means half the parent is gone, not all of it. Fifth, forgetting the assumptions: no starting daughter and nothing lost or gained since.

Key takeaways

A surface age measures time since a surface last solidified or was wiped clean, not the planet's age. Crater density gives relative ages, since more craters means longer exposure, and laboratory-dated samples calibrate it into years. Radioactive parents decay into daughters with fixed half-lives; after n half-lives, (1/2)ⁿ of the parent remains, and the age is the half-life times log₂(1 + D/P). Uranium-238 (4.47 billion years) and uranium-235 (0.704 billion years) in zircon give cross-checked ages. Apollo samples showed an ancient Moon, meteorites date the solar system to about 4.57 billion years, and radioactive decay helps heat planets from within.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Surface age

Time since a surface last solidified or was wiped clean

Not the age of the planet.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A radioactive isotope has a half-life of 1.25 billion years. What fraction of the original parent remains after 3.75 billion years?

Question 2 of 5

Region X of a moon has 40 craters per 1,000 km² and region Y has 8. What is the best conclusion?

Question 3 of 5

A mineral has 3 atoms of lead-207 for every atom of uranium-235 (half-life 0.704 billion years). Assuming a closed system with no starting lead, how old is it?

Question 4 of 5

What does a crater-count age on part of Mars actually measure?

Question 5 of 5

Why is zircon especially useful for radiometric dating?

← Previous topicNext topic →