Astronomy › Section G · The solar system and Earth › Topic G.2

Composition and structure of planets

We cannot dig into another planet, yet we know what most of them are made of and how their insides are layered. Mass, size, temperature and a few physical rules let us read the interiors of worlds we can only see from outside.

Two kinds of planet, two kinds of recipe

The previous topic sorted the planets into small rocky terrestrial worlds and large hydrogen-rich giants. The split is not just in size: the two groups are made of different ingredients. That suggests they formed under different conditions, an idea the topic "Origin of the solar system" takes up. Here we ask what each kind is made of, how that material is arranged inside, and why some worlds are still geologically active. The tools are density, temperature and the way heat escapes.

Inside the giant planets

Jupiter and Saturn have nearly the Sun's composition: by mass, roughly three-quarters hydrogen and one-quarter helium. Both are gases on Earth, so these planets are often called gas giants, but deep inside the crushing pressure turns hydrogen into a liquid, and deeper still into a metal-like liquid that conducts electricity. Heavier rock, metal and ice settled towards the centre to form cores, which we infer from each planet's gravity field because they are hidden beneath the clouds. NASA's Juno mission suggests Jupiter's core is not a sharp ball but a dilute region blending into the layers above; how it formed is still debated.

The ice giants and reduced chemistry

Uranus and Neptune also have cores of rock, metal and ice, but they gathered much less hydrogen and helium, so their gas envelopes are thin compared with their cores. Much of their mass is thought to be hot, dense fluid of water, ammonia and methane, the substances astronomers call ices even when they are not frozen. Throughout the outer solar system hydrogen dominates the chemistry, so oxygen is found mostly bound to hydrogen as water. Chemists call such a hydrogen-rich mix reduced. Water, usually as ice, is abundant everywhere beyond the asteroid belt.

The terrestrial planets

The terrestrial planets are made mainly of elements that are rare in the universe as a whole. Their most common rocks are silicates, minerals of silicon and oxygen, and their most common metal is iron. Earth and Venus each have about one-third of their mass in iron combined with nickel or sulfur and about two-thirds in silicates; Mars's core is a smaller share, about a quarter. Mercury has the largest share of metal, and the Moon the smallest. Because so much of their material is oxygen bound into minerals, their chemistry is called oxidised, the opposite of the giants' reduced chemistry.

Density as a clue

Average density is mass divided by volume. Treating a planet as a sphere of radius \(R\),

\rho = \frac{M}{\frac{4}{3}\pi R^3}

Water has a density of 1.00 g/cm³, or 1,000 kg/m³, so multiply g/cm³ by 1,000 to convert. Ice is a little under 1 g/cm³, silicate rock about 3, and iron nearly 8. A world's average density tells us roughly what mix it is made of. Earth's 5.5 g/cm³ is much denser than its surface rocks, so dense metal must be hidden inside, while Saturn's 0.69 g/cm³ is less than water.

Worked example: what is Titan made of?

Saturn's moon Titan has a mass of \(1.345 \times 10^{23}\) kg and a radius of 2,575 km. 1. Convert the radius: \(R = 2.575 \times 10^{6}\) m. 2. Volume: \(V = \frac{4}{3}\pi R^3 = 7.15 \times 10^{19}\) m³. 3. Density: \(\rho = M \div V = 1.345 \times 10^{23} \div 7.15 \times 10^{19} = 1{,}880\) kg/m³, or 1.88 g/cm³. 4. Interpret: this lies between ice, about 1 g/cm³, and rock, about 3 g/cm³, so Titan must be a mixture of ice and rock. 5. Check: the largest moons of the outer system, Ganymede, Callisto and Titan, are all thought to be roughly half ice and half rock and metal by mass, which fits.

Differentiation: sorting by density

In every terrestrial planet the densest metal sits in a central core and the lightest silicates form the crust. Gravity explains this only if the material could once flow, so these worlds must have been hot enough to melt, above roughly 1,300 K for rock. Differentiation is this sorting of a planet's interior into layers of different composition and density, with heavy material sinking and light material rising. When the planet cooled, the layers stayed in place. Large icy moons such as Ganymede differentiated too, into rocky cores under thick ice. Most small asteroids and comets never melted, so they keep the original, unsorted material of the young solar system.

Hidden oceans and tidal heating

Several large moons of the outer planets probably hide liquid water under their ice. Evidence is strongest for Jupiter's Europa and Ganymede and Saturn's Enceladus and Titan, from magnetic measurements, gravity data and, at Enceladus, jets of water spraying into space; the depths and saltiness of these oceans are still uncertain. Far from the Sun, the heat comes largely from tides. As a moon orbits, its neighbours' gravity flexes it, and the flexing warms its interior. In the extreme case of Jupiter's moon Io, tidal heating drives the most active volcanoes in the solar system.

Worked example: surface temperature and distance

Sunlight weakens with the square of distance, and a simple energy balance shows that, for worlds of equal reflectivity, temperature falls roughly as \(T \propto \frac{1}{\sqrt{d}}\). Without its greenhouse effect, Earth would sit at about 255 K. Estimate Mars at 1.524 AU, where 1 AU is the Earth to Sun distance, about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m. 1. Set up the ratio: \(T_{Mars} = 255\ \mathrm{K} \div \sqrt{1.524}\). 2. \(\sqrt{1.524} = 1.234\), so \(T_{Mars} \approx 207\) K, or about −67 °C. 3. Check: Mars's measured global average is roughly −60 to −65 °C, so the estimate works because Mars's thin air adds little warming. A thick atmosphere breaks the rule: Venus, at 0.72 AU, averages about 737 K, hotter than Mercury.

Why some worlds stay active

Volcanoes, mountain building and moving crust are powered by heat escaping from a planet's interior. Every planet was hot at birth, from collisions and radioactive decay, but small bodies cool fastest. A sphere's surface area per unit volume is \(3/R\), so the Moon, with about 1/3.7 of Earth's radius, has about 3.7 times as much surface per unit volume through which to lose heat. A baked potato behaves the same way: cut it small and it cools quickly. As predicted, the Moon and probably Mercury fell quiet billions of years ago, Mars is intermediate, and Earth and Venus remain the most active.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking gas giants are gas throughout; most of Jupiter's and Saturn's hydrogen is liquid. Second, judging a world's make-up from its surface: Earth's crust is about 3 g/cm³, but its average density of 5.5 g/cm³ reveals a metal core. Third, forgetting unit conversions: 1 g/cm³ is 1,000 kg/m³, not 1 kg/m³. Fourth, assuming closeness to the Sun alone sets temperature; Venus is hotter than Mercury because of its atmosphere. Fifth, assuming size alone decides activity; tidal heating keeps small Io and Enceladus active.

Key takeaways

Jupiter and Saturn are about three-quarters hydrogen and one-quarter helium by mass, mostly liquid inside, with dense cores; Uranus and Neptune have thinner envelopes over large cores and ices, and the outer system's chemistry is reduced. Terrestrial planets are silicates and iron with oxidised chemistry. Density, mass divided by volume, reveals what a world is made of. Differentiation layered planets that once melted. Temperature falls roughly as one over the square root of distance, unless an atmosphere traps heat. Large worlds stay geologically active longest, and tidal heating can keep some moons warm and even liquid inside.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Giant planet mix

About 3/4 hydrogen and 1/4 helium by mass

Jupiter and Saturn are close to the Sun's composition.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A moon has an average density of 1.9 g/cm³. What does this most likely tell you about it?

Question 2 of 5

Earth's surface rocks have densities of about 3 g/cm³, yet Earth's average density is 5.5 g/cm³. What does this imply?

Question 3 of 5

Using T ∝ 1/√d and 255 K at 1 AU, what is the estimated temperature of a body at 4.00 AU with no atmosphere?

Question 4 of 5

Why did the Moon become geologically inactive long before Earth?

Question 5 of 5

What is differentiation?

← Previous topicNext topic →