Astronomy › Section O · Star birth and exoplanets › Topic O.5

What exoplanets teach us about planet formation

Before 1995, astronomers had exactly one planetary system to learn from, and they assumed others would look like it. Thousands of exoplanets later, our solar system looks like one arrangement among many, and the theory of how planets form has had to grow up.

One example is not enough

With only the solar system to go on, astronomers expected other systems to be similar: small rocky planets close in, giant planets farther out, all on nearly circular orbits. Such systems exist, but the census holds many surprises: giant planets orbiting in days, orbits as stretched as comets', tight families of planets packed inside the distance of Mercury, and whole classes of planet the solar system lacks. The biggest lesson is about science itself: a theory built on a single example can mistake the unusual for the normal.

The most common planets

Kepler's survey showed that the most common planets found are between Earth and Neptune in size, a range the solar system skips entirely. Those up to about 1.5 to 2 Earth radii are called super-Earths; those from about 2 to 4 Earth radii are called sub-Neptunes or mini-Neptunes. Between them lies a gap, the radius valley, reported in 2017: fewer planets have sizes near 1.8 Earth radii. A leading explanation is that some young planets lost their thin gas envelopes to their stars' radiation, but the cause is still debated. Correcting for planets Kepler missed suggests that Sun-like stars host, on average, about one such planet in orbits shorter than a year or so.

Worked example: what is a planet made of?

When both methods from "Searching for planets beyond the solar system" work on one planet, the transit gives its radius and radial velocity its mass. In Earth units, with Earth's density 5.51 g/cm³:

\rho = 5.51 \times \frac{M/M_\oplus}{(R/R_\oplus)^3}\ \mathrm{g/cm^3}

1. Planet A: 5 Earth masses, 1.6 Earth radii. \(\rho = 5.51 \times \frac{5}{4.10} = 6.7\) g/cm³. 2. That is denser than Earth: rock and iron, squeezed harder by stronger gravity. 3. Planet B: 8 Earth masses, 2.8 Earth radii. \(\rho = 5.51 \times \frac{8}{22.0} = 2.0\) g/cm³. 4. Far too light for bare rock, so it must have a thick envelope of hydrogen and helium, or a great deal of water.

Masses, radii and puffy giants

Plotting mass against radius for hundreds of planets, and comparing with computed curves for pure iron, rock, water and hydrogen, sorts them roughly into types. Most planets smaller than about 1.5 Earth radii lie near the rock-and-iron curves, like Earth and Venus; larger ones need gas. For giants a surprise appears: beyond a few Jupiter masses, adding mass hardly increases the radius, because stronger gravity compresses the planet. Many hot Jupiters are larger than models of cool gas giants allow. Heating from their nearby stars probably puffs them up, though the details are still being worked out.

Families of planets

As of 4 November 2026, the NASA Exoplanet Archive lists about 1,080 systems with more than one known planet. Most are compact, with several planets packed inside what would be Mercury's orbit. Kepler-90 has eight known planets, matching the solar system's count. TRAPPIST-1, a red dwarf about 40 light-years away, has seven roughly Earth-sized planets, all within about a sixth of Mercury's distance from the Sun. In tightly packed systems the planets tug on one another, so transits arrive minutes or more early or late; these timing variations give the planets' masses. Some planets even orbit both stars of a close binary.

How to make a hot Jupiter

A hot Jupiter cannot easily form where it is now. So close to the star, solids vaporise and there is too little material to build a core, while the core-accretion model in "Evidence of planets forming around other stars" needs a cold region several AU out. (One astronomical unit, AU, is the mean Earth-Sun distance, about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m.) Most astronomers therefore think hot Jupiters formed farther out and moved in. One route is migration through the disc: a young planet trades angular momentum with the surrounding gas and spirals inwards. Another is a gravitational shove from other planets onto a stretched orbit that dips close to the star, after which tides raised by the star shrink and round it.

Violent histories, including ours

Combining transits with spectra shows that some giant planets orbit at steep angles to their star's equator, and a few even go round backwards. Smooth migration through a disc would not do that; close encounters between planets, or a passing star, could. The solar system may have been shaped the same way. Many models suggest Uranus and Neptune formed closer to the Sun and were scattered outwards, and some propose that Jupiter wandered inwards and back again early on, though that is debated. Planet formation now looks less like clockwork and more like a crowded dance floor.

Planets from the young galaxy

Rocky planets need elements heavier than helium, which stars made gradually over the galaxy's history. Giant planets are noticeably more common around stars richer in heavy elements, as core accretion predicts, since a richer disc builds solid cores faster. Yet small planets formed early: the star Kepler-444, about 11 billion years old, has five planets smaller than Venus, all orbiting closer than Mercury. It formed when the Milky Way was only a couple of billion years old, so enough heavy elements for small rocky planets were already available.

Worked example: where is the habitable zone?

The habitable zone is the range of distances where a planet with a suitable atmosphere could keep liquid water on its surface. Earth gets one unit of sunlight at 1 AU; a planet gets the same from a star of luminosity \(L\) at

d = \sqrt{\frac{L}{L_\odot}}\ \mathrm{AU}

where \(L_\odot \approx 3.83 \times 10^{26}\) W is the Sun's luminosity. 1. TRAPPIST-1 has \(L \approx 0.00055\ L_\odot\), so \(d = \sqrt{0.00055} = 0.023\) AU. 2. Its planet e orbits at 0.029 AU and receives \(\frac{0.00055}{0.029^2} = 0.65\) of Earth's sunlight. 3. Interpret: e lies within the zone usually computed for that star. Around dim red dwarfs the zone is tiny and very close in.

Habitable is not inhabited

A planet in the habitable zone might have liquid water; it is not known to. Much depends on its atmosphere. Red dwarfs often flare violently, which may strip close-in planets of their air. Since 2023, James Webb Space Telescope measurements suggest TRAPPIST-1 b and c lack thick, carbon-dioxide-rich atmospheres; whether the outer planets have air is still being tested. Claims of a possible sign of life, dimethyl sulphide, on the sub-Neptune K2-18 b have been widely disputed and are not accepted as evidence of life. No life has been detected beyond Earth. Proxima Centauri, the nearest star, has a planet of at least about Earth's mass in its habitable zone.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, a habitable-zone planet is not known to have water or life; that needs an atmosphere and much more evidence. Second, similar mass does not mean similar make-up: density decides whether a planet is rocky or wrapped in gas. Third, hot Jupiters probably did not form where we see them. Fourth, the most common known planets are not Earth or Jupiter copies but sizes in between.

Key takeaways

The most common known planets are super-Earths and sub-Neptunes, split by a radius valley near 1.8 Earth radii. Density, from transit radius and Doppler mass, separates rocky worlds from gas-wrapped ones. About 1,080 multi-planet systems are known as of November 2026, many compact. Hot Jupiters and tilted orbits point to migration and scattering, and the solar system's own giants probably moved. Kepler-444 shows rocky planets formed early. The habitable zone lies at about \(\sqrt{L/L_\odot}\) AU, but being there does not mean water or life, and no life has been found beyond Earth.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Super-Earth

Planet up to about 1.5 to 2 Earth radii, usually rocky

None in the solar system.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A planet has 4 Earth masses and 2 Earth radii. Using Earth's density of 5.51 g/cm³, what is its density?

Question 2 of 5

Which planets did Kepler find to be the most common?

Question 3 of 5

Why do most astronomers think hot Jupiters formed farther from their stars and then moved inwards?

Question 4 of 5

A star has a luminosity of 0.25 L☉. At what distance would a planet receive the same sunlight as Earth?

Question 5 of 5

A rocky planet orbits within its star's habitable zone. What can we conclude?

← Previous topicNext topic →