Astronomy › Section P · Stars from adolescence to old age › Topic P.1
From the main sequence to red giants
Stars spend most of their lives quietly fusing hydrogen on the main sequence, but that calm cannot last. When the hydrogen in the core runs out, the core shrinks, the outer layers balloon, and the star becomes a red giant.
The long middle of a star's life
A star arrives on the zero-age main sequence when its core starts fusing hydrogen into helium, as described in "The H-R diagram and stellar evolution". It then stays on the main sequence for about 90% of its life. Hydrogen is so plentiful, and fusion so effective, that the star can hold gravity and pressure in balance for a very long time. Fusion turns only about 0.7% of the fused hydrogen's mass into energy, so the star's total mass hardly changes. What does change, slowly, is the make-up of its core: hydrogen is used up and helium, the "ash" of fusion, builds up in its place.
Changing on the main sequence
As helium builds up, the core contracts slightly and grows hotter and denser. Fusion is extremely sensitive to temperature: for the proton-proton chain that powers the Sun, the rate rises roughly as the fourth power of the core temperature. So a slightly hotter core fuses faster, and the star slowly brightens. The point representing it drifts upwards and away from the zero-age main sequence, which is why the main sequence on real diagrams is a band rather than a thin line. The Sun is an example: models suggest that when it formed, about 4.6 billion years ago, it shone about 30% less brightly than it does today.
Worked example: a sensitive furnace
If the fusion rate goes as \(T^4\), what does a 10% rise in core temperature do? And what temperature rise triples the rate? 1. The rate scales as \((1.10)^4 = 1.46\), so a 10% hotter core fuses about 46% faster. 2. To triple the rate, solve \(x^4 = 3\), so \(x = 3^{1/4} = 1.32\). 3. A 32% rise in core temperature is enough to triple the fusion rate. 4. Interpret: small changes in a star's core make large changes in its energy output. That sensitivity is the key to why massive stars, with their hotter cores, use up their fuel so much faster than the Sun.
Lifetime depends on fuel and spending
A star's main-sequence lifetime depends on how much fuel it has and how fast it uses it, like savings that last as long as income allows. Fuel scales with mass \(M\); the spending rate is the luminosity \(L\). The Sun's lifetime is about 10 billion years, so
where \(M_\odot\) is a solar mass and \(L_\odot\) the solar luminosity, \(3.83 \times 10^{26}\) W. Massive stars have more fuel but far more luminosity: for main-sequence stars, luminosity rises roughly as \(M^{3.5}\). Their cores must be hotter to support the weight above them, and hotter cores fuse ferociously fast.
Worked example: how long do they last?
Estimate main-sequence lifetimes for stars of 2 and 10 solar masses using \(L \propto M^{3.5}\). 1. Combine the two rules, with \(M\) in solar masses:
2. For 2 solar masses: \(2^{-2.5} = 0.177\), so \(t \approx 1.8\) billion years. 3. For 10 solar masses: \(10^{-2.5} = 0.00316\), so \(t \approx 32\) million years. 4. Check against detailed models: they give roughly 1 billion and 20 to 30 million years, so this simple rule overestimates, but it captures the trend. 5. Interpret: five times the mass means a lifetime roughly 50 times shorter. A star of a few tenths of a solar mass outlasts the present universe, about 13.8 billion years old.
When the core runs dry
Eventually the hydrogen in the hot central region is gone, leaving a core of helium. Helium cannot yet fuse: that needs a far higher temperature. With no nuclear source in the core, gravity takes over again. The core shrinks, and, as in a protostar, contraction releases heat. That heat flows outwards into the layer just outside the core, where hydrogen had spent the main sequence almost hot enough to fuse. Now it crosses the threshold, and hydrogen begins fusing in a shell around the inert helium core. Helium from the shell rains onto the core, which keeps growing, contracting and heating.
The star swells
A hydrogen-fusing shell around a hot, contracting core usually produces more energy than the original core fusion did, so the star's luminosity rises. The flood of energy pushes the outer layers outwards, and as gas expands it cools, just as gas from an opened pressurised can feels cold. The surface temperature falls to roughly 3,000 to 5,000 K and the star turns orange-red. It now has a split personality: a core shrinking towards high density and an envelope swelling to tens or hundreds of times its former size. Low- and medium-mass stars become red giants; massive stars become even larger red supergiants.
Worked example: how big is a red giant?
A red giant has a luminosity of 1,000 \(L_\odot\) and a surface temperature of 4,000 K. Find its radius, using the Sun's surface temperature of 5,770 K. 1. Rearrange \(L = R^2 T^4\) in solar units:
2. Substitute: \(\frac{\sqrt{1000}}{(0.693)^2} = \frac{31.6}{0.480} = 66\) solar radii. 3. Convert: with \(R_\odot = 6.96 \times 10^8\) m, that is \(4.6 \times 10^{10}\) m, or about 0.31 AU, where 1 AU \(\approx 1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m is the Earth-Sun distance. 4. Interpret: placed where the Sun is, this star would reach most of the way to Mercury's orbit at 0.39 AU.
On the H-R diagram, and a famous supergiant
Brighter and cooler means the star's point moves up and to the right, off the main sequence and into the giant region. Computed tracks show that massive stars make this journey in a few million years or less, while a Sun-like star takes a billion years or more. Betelgeuse, the orange-red shoulder of Orion, about 500 to 700 light-years away, shows the extreme. It has roughly 15 to 20 solar masses, is about ten million years old and is hundreds of times wider than the Sun; placed at the Sun's position it would reach beyond the orbit of Mars. Its striking dimming in 2019 to 2020 was caused largely by a cloud of dust it puffed out.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, more fuel does not mean a longer life: massive stars burn out far faster because luminosity rises much more steeply than mass. Second, when core hydrogen runs out, helium does not ignite at once; the core first contracts while hydrogen fuses in a shell around it. Third, a red giant's core is shrinking and heating, not expanding; only the envelope swells. Fourth, a red giant is not cooler inside: its surface is cooler, but its core is hotter than ever. Fifth, red giants look orange rather than deep red, because "red" here means cooler than the Sun.
Key takeaways
Stars spend about 90% of their lives on the main sequence, slowly turning core hydrogen into helium and brightening as their cores heat. The proton-proton fusion rate rises roughly as \(T^4\). Lifetime is about fuel over spending, \(t \approx 10\) billion years \(\times \frac{M}{L}\) in solar units, roughly \(M^{-2.5}\) since \(L \propto M^{3.5}\). When core hydrogen runs out, the helium core contracts and heats, a hydrogen-fusing shell switches on, and the envelope expands and cools. The star becomes more luminous and cooler, moving up and to the right on the H-R diagram as a red giant or, if massive, a red supergiant such as Betelgeuse.
Flashcards
Flashcard
About 90% of a star's life is spent fusing core hydrogen
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Using t ≈ 10 billion years × M⁻²·⁵ (M in solar masses), about how long does a 4-solar-mass star stay on the main sequence?
Question 2 of 5
Why do massive stars have shorter main-sequence lives than low-mass stars, even though they hold more fuel?
Question 3 of 5
What happens first when a star like the Sun uses up the hydrogen in its core?
Question 4 of 5
A red giant has a luminosity of 400 L☉ and a surface temperature of 2,885 K, half the Sun's. What is its radius?
Question 5 of 5
As a star leaves the main sequence to become a red giant, how does its point move on the H-R diagram?
