Astronomy › Section R · Black holes and curved spacetime › Topic R.1

General relativity: spacetime and gravity

Newton described gravity as a force pulling across space. Einstein replaced that picture with a stranger and more accurate one: mass and energy curve space and time, and everything, light included, simply follows the curves.

Why Newton was not the last word

Newton's law of gravitation, met in "Newton's universal law of gravitation", predicts planetary orbits and spacecraft paths superbly. But it had two problems. First, it says gravity acts instantly across any distance, while Einstein's special theory of relativity of 1905 showed that no signal can travel faster than light, about \(3.00 \times 10^{8}\) m/s. Second, it gives no reason why every object falls with the same acceleration, whatever its mass. Einstein's answer, the general theory of relativity, was completed in late 1915 and published in full in 1916. For ordinary gravity it agrees with Newton almost exactly; where gravity is extremely strong, such as near neutron stars and black holes, only general relativity works.

The equivalence principle

Einstein's starting point was simple: a person falling freely does not feel their own weight. Imagine waking up inside a sealed, windowless laboratory and finding yourself floating. You might be drifting in deep space far from any star, or you might be falling freely towards a planet. Einstein proposed that no experiment inside a small enough laboratory could tell these situations apart. Likewise, standing in a rocket accelerating at 9.81 m/s² in deep space would feel exactly like standing on Earth. This is the equivalence principle: the effects of gravity and of acceleration are locally indistinguishable. Astronauts on the International Space Station float not because gravity is absent there, but because they and the station fall around Earth together.

Worked example: weight in a lift

A 60.0 kg student stands on bathroom scales in a lift, with \(g = 9.81\ \mathrm{m/s^2}\). What do the scales read when the lift is at rest, accelerating upwards at 2.00 m/s², accelerating downwards at 2.00 m/s², and falling freely? 1. At rest the scales push up with \(mg = 60.0 \times 9.81 = 589\) N. 2. Accelerating upwards, they must also supply the extra acceleration: \(m(g + a) = 60.0 \times 11.81 = 709\) N. 3. Accelerating downwards: \(m(g - a) = 60.0 \times 7.81 = 469\) N. 4. Free fall, \(a = g\): \(m(g - g) = 0\) N, so the student feels weightless. 5. Check: acceleration adds to or cancels the feeling of gravity, which is exactly the equivalence Einstein noticed.

Gravity must bend light

Now shine a laser across a rocket that is accelerating upwards in deep space. While the light crosses, the floor speeds up beneath it, so to the crew the beam curves slightly downwards, towards the floor. By the equivalence principle, the same must happen in a laboratory sitting at rest on a planet: gravity must bend light. That is puzzling in Newton's picture, because light has no mass for a force to act on. Einstein's resolution was that light does not need to be pulled. Instead, mass changes the shape of space and time, and light follows the straightest possible path through that shape, which, seen from outside, is curved.

Worked example: how far does light fall?

A laser beam crosses a 30.0 m laboratory on Earth's surface. Treating it, by the equivalence principle, like an object falling at \(g = 9.81\ \mathrm{m/s^2}\), how far does it drop? 1. Crossing time: \(t = \frac{d}{c} = \frac{30.0}{3.00 \times 10^{8}} = 1.00 \times 10^{-7}\) s. 2. Drop for something starting with no downward speed: \(h = \frac{1}{2}gt^2\). 3. Substitute:

h = 0.5 \times 9.81 \times (1.00 \times 10^{-7})^2 = 4.9 \times 10^{-14}\ \mathrm{m}

4. Compare: an atom is about \(10^{-10}\) m across, so the drop is thousands of times smaller than an atom. 5. Conclusion: light bending is real but tiny in Earth's gravity, which is why it took the much stronger gravity of the Sun, and great care, to measure it.

Spacetime

Any event, from a firework bursting to a supernova, is pinpointed by four numbers: three for its position in space and one for its time. Newton treated space and time as separate and fixed. Einstein's relativity showed that they are woven together into a single four-dimensional spacetime, and that measurements of distance and of time intervals depend on the observer's motion and on gravity. A spacetime diagram plots time against one direction of space; a car parked by the road traces a vertical line, and a car driving at steady speed traces a sloping straight line. The path of any object through spacetime is called its world line.

Mass curves spacetime

The core idea of general relativity is that mass and energy curve spacetime, and that this curvature is gravity. Objects with no forces acting on them follow the straightest possible paths through curved spacetime, and those paths are what we see as orbits and falls. The physicist John Wheeler summed it up: "Spacetime tells matter how to move; matter tells spacetime how to curve." A common picture is a stretched rubber sheet with a heavy ball on it, making a dip that steers rolling marbles. It helps, but it has limits: real curvature involves time as well as space, and the sheet itself only works because Earth's gravity pulls the ball down.

How strong is the curvature?

Curvature matters most where a lot of mass is packed into a small space. A handy measure is the dimensionless number \(\frac{GM}{Rc^2}\), where \(G = 6.67 \times 10^{-11}\ \mathrm{N\,m^2\,kg^{-2}}\), for a body of mass \(M\) and radius \(R\). When it is tiny, Newton's law is an excellent approximation; when it approaches about 0.5, the body is close to becoming a black hole. At Earth's surface it is about \(7 \times 10^{-10}\), at the Sun's surface about \(2 \times 10^{-6}\), and at a white dwarf's surface about \(10^{-4}\). At the surface of a 1.4-solar-mass neutron star of radius 12 km it is about 0.17, where general relativity becomes essential.

Two descriptions, one reality

Newton and Einstein give different explanations for the same observed motions. In Newton's picture, the Sun pulls Earth with a force, and Earth's path bends. In Einstein's picture, the Sun curves the spacetime around it, and Earth follows the straightest path available, which loops around the Sun once a year. For the solar system the two agree to within tiny fractions, so engineers still use Newton's law to fly spacecraft. The small differences, and the large ones near compact objects, are where experiment can decide between them, as the topic "Tests of relativity and time in gravity" shows: so far every test has favoured general relativity.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking astronauts in orbit float because there is no gravity: gravity at the space station's height is about 90% of its strength at the ground, and the astronauts are falling. Second, believing light bends only because it has some small mass: light has no mass; it follows curved spacetime. Third, treating the rubber sheet as the real theory: it is a two-dimensional analogy that leaves out time. Fourth, assuming general relativity proved Newton wrong for everyday life: Newton's law is the weak-gravity limit of Einstein's theory. Fifth, mixing the two theories: special relativity (1905) deals with motion; general relativity (1915-1916) with gravity.

Key takeaways

General relativity, completed by Einstein in 1915, is our best theory of gravity. Its foundation, the equivalence principle, says the effects of gravity and acceleration cannot be told apart in a small laboratory, so free fall feels weightless. It follows that gravity bends light. Space and time form one four-dimensional spacetime, and mass and energy curve it; objects follow the straightest paths through that curvature. The number GM/(Rc²) shows how strong the effects are: tiny for Earth and the Sun, large for neutron stars and black holes. In weak gravity Einstein's theory reproduces Newton's.

Flashcards

Flashcard

General relativity

Einstein's theory of gravity as curved spacetime

Completed 1915, published in full 1916.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A 55.0 kg person stands on scales in a lift accelerating upwards at 3.00 m/s². Using g = 9.81 m/s², what do the scales read?

Question 2 of 5

What does the equivalence principle state?

Question 3 of 5

In general relativity, why does a planet orbit the Sun?

Question 4 of 5

Astronauts on the International Space Station float. Why?

Question 5 of 5

For which object is GM/(Rc²) largest, so that general relativity matters most at its surface?

← Previous topicNext topic →