Astronomy › Section R · Black holes and curved spacetime › Topic R.2
Tests of relativity and time in gravity
A beautiful theory still has to survive measurement. General relativity has passed every test for over a century, from Mercury's orbit and starlight at an eclipse to the clocks inside the GPS satellites that guide your phone.
Putting Einstein to the test
The topic "General relativity: spacetime and gravity" showed that Einstein's theory agrees almost exactly with Newton's wherever gravity is weak. That makes testing it hard: in the solar system the differences are tiny, so the tests need either very precise measurements or the strongest gravity available, which near Earth means the Sun. Einstein himself proposed three tests: the motion of Mercury, the bending of starlight and the effect of gravity on time and light. All three have been passed, together with many others devised since, and every one has agreed with general relativity rather than Newton.
Mercury's turning orbit
Mercury's elliptical orbit does not stay fixed: its perihelion, the point closest to the Sun, slowly shifts around the Sun. Most of this shift is caused by the pulls of the other planets, which Newton's law predicts well, about 532 arcseconds per century (an arcsecond, written ″, is 1/3600 of a degree). But the observed shift is about 575″ per century. Urbain Le Verrier noticed the mismatch in 1859 and suspected an unseen planet inside Mercury's orbit, nicknamed Vulcan, which was never found. In 1915 Einstein showed that the Sun's curvature of spacetime adds exactly the missing 43″ per century, with no new planet needed.
Worked example: how slow is 43″ per century?
Mercury orbits the Sun every 88.0 days. How much does relativity alone turn its perihelion in one orbit, and how long would that effect take to turn the orbit all the way round? 1. Orbits per century: \(\frac{36{,}525\ \text{days}}{88.0\ \text{days}} = 415\). 2. Shift per orbit: \(\frac{43''}{415} = 0.10''\). 3. A full turn is \(360 \times 3600 = 1{,}296{,}000''\). 4. Time needed: \(\frac{1{,}296{,}000}{43} \approx 30{,}000\) centuries, or about 3 million years. 5. Check: an effect this small needed centuries of careful timing to notice, which matches its history.
Bending starlight
General relativity predicts that light grazing the Sun's edge is deflected by about 1.75″, twice the value a Newtonian argument gives. Stars near the Sun can be seen only during a total solar eclipse, so in 1919 British expeditions organised by Frank Dyson and Arthur Eddington photographed stars during the eclipse of 29 May, from Príncipe off West Africa and Sobral in Brazil. Comparing the photographs with ones taken when the Sun was elsewhere showed stars shifted outwards by about the predicted amount, within errors of roughly 20%. The result made Einstein world-famous. Modern radio measurements agree with relativity to better than 0.1%, and the bending of light by galaxies, gravitational lensing, is now a powerful astronomical tool.
Worked example: the 1.75″ deflection
For light grazing a body of mass \(M\) and radius \(R\), general relativity gives a deflection angle in radians of
Find it for the Sun, with \(M = 1.99 \times 10^{30}\) kg, \(R = 6.96 \times 10^{8}\) m, \(G = 6.67 \times 10^{-11}\ \mathrm{N\,m^2\,kg^{-2}}\) and \(c = 3.00 \times 10^{8}\) m/s. 1. Numerator: \(4GM = 5.31 \times 10^{20}\). 2. Denominator: \(Rc^2 = 6.26 \times 10^{25}\). 3. Divide: \(\theta = 8.48 \times 10^{-6}\) radians. 4. Convert, using 1 radian = 206,265″: \(\theta = 1.75''\). 5. Check: that is about the width of a coin seen from 3 km, small but measurable.
Gravity slows time
General relativity predicts that clocks deeper in a gravitational field tick more slowly than clocks higher up, an effect called gravitational time dilation. Near Earth's surface a clock raised by a height \(h\) gains time at a fractional rate of about \(\frac{gh}{c^2}\). In 1959-1960 Robert Pound and Glen Rebka detected this using gamma rays sent up and down a 22.5 m tower at Harvard. In 1976 the Gravity Probe A rocket carried an atomic clock to 10,000 km and confirmed the prediction to within about one part in ten thousand. Today's best atomic clocks show the difference when one is raised by much less than a metre.
Gravitational redshift and delayed signals
A light wave is itself a kind of clock, with crests arriving at a steady rate. Light climbing out of strong gravity reaches a distant observer with a lower frequency, and since its speed stays \(c\), its wavelength is longer. This is a gravitational redshift. It has been measured in the spectrum of the white dwarf Sirius B, where it equals the shift a speed of about 80 km/s would cause. Curved spacetime also delays signals passing near the Sun. Radio signals from the Viking landers on Mars in 1976, and from the Cassini spacecraft in 2002, arrived late by the predicted amount, Cassini's matching it to a few parts in 100,000.
Worked example: relativity and GPS
GPS satellites orbit at radius \(r = 2.66 \times 10^{7}\) m, about 20,200 km up, at 3.87 km/s. Earth's radius is \(R = 6.37 \times 10^{6}\) m and, from \(G\) and Earth's mass of \(5.97 \times 10^{24}\) kg, \(GM = 3.98 \times 10^{14}\ \mathrm{m^3/s^2}\). A day is 86,400 s. 1. Weaker gravity makes the satellite clocks run fast by
2. Special relativity says moving clocks run slow, by \(\frac{v^2}{2c^2} \times 86{,}400 = 7.2\ \mu\)s per day. 3. Net: \(45.6 - 7.2 = 38.4\ \mu\)s per day fast. 4. Error: light travels \(3.00 \times 10^{8} \times 38.4 \times 10^{-6} = 11.5\) km in that time, so positions would drift by kilometres each day. GPS clocks are therefore adjusted before launch.
A pulsar laboratory
In 1974 Russell Hulse and Joseph Taylor discovered a pulsar orbiting another neutron star every 7.75 hours. Its precise pulses work like a clock carried around a strong-gravity orbit. General relativity predicts that such a pair must lose energy by giving off gravitational waves, so their orbit should shrink. Decades of timing showed the orbit shrinking at exactly the predicted rate, the first, indirect evidence that gravitational waves exist, and Hulse and Taylor shared the 1993 Nobel Prize in Physics. The double pulsar, found in 2003, has since tested the theory even more precisely. The topic "Gravitational-wave astronomy" takes the story further.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking GPS needs only one correction: gravity speeds the satellite clocks up and their motion slows them down, and the net is about 38 μs per day. Second, saying time slows in a strong field "for the person there": a clock deep in gravity feels normal to its owner; the slowing appears when clocks are compared. Third, quoting 0.87″ for light bending at the Sun: that is the Newtonian half value. Fourth, believing the Vulcan planet explains Mercury: none exists. Fifth, thinking gravitational redshift means light slows down: its speed stays c while its frequency drops.
Key takeaways
General relativity explains the extra 43″ per century in the turning of Mercury's orbit. It predicts that starlight grazing the Sun bends by 1.75″, confirmed at the 1919 eclipse and now to better than 0.1%. Clocks run slower deeper in gravity, at a rate of about gh/c² near Earth, as shown by Pound and Rebka and by Gravity Probe A. Light leaving strong gravity is redshifted, and signals passing the Sun are delayed. GPS clocks gain about 38 μs per day net and must be corrected. The shrinking orbit of the Hulse-Taylor binary pulsar matched the prediction for gravitational waves.
Flashcards
Flashcard
1/3600 of a degree
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Newtonian gravity, including the other planets, accounts for about 532″ per century of Mercury's perihelion shift, but about 575″ is observed. How did general relativity resolve this?
Question 2 of 5
Using θ = 4GM/(Rc²), how does the light deflection at the surface of a star compare with the Sun's if the star has the same mass but half the radius?
Question 3 of 5
A clock is carried 900 m up a mountain. Using gh/c² with g = 9.81 m/s² and c = 3.00 × 10⁸ m/s, about how much time does it gain per day (86,400 s)?
Question 4 of 5
Why do GPS satellite clocks run fast overall compared with clocks on the ground?
Question 5 of 5
What is a gravitational redshift?
