Astronomy › Section O · Star birth and exoplanets › Topic O.2

The H-R diagram and stellar evolution

No astronomer lives long enough to watch a star grow up, but models can. Plotted on the H-R diagram, those models trace the path a newborn star follows as it contracts, heats up and finally settles onto the main sequence.

Following a life we cannot watch

Even the fastest stages of a star's life last thousands of years, and most last millions or billions. So astronomers follow stars with calculations. They build a model of a star, use physics to work out how it will change a short time later, and repeat, step after step. At each step the model gives a luminosity and a surface temperature, which can be plotted on the H-R diagram described in "The H-R diagram": luminosity upwards, temperature increasing to the left. The line joining these points is the star's evolutionary track. When astronomers say a star "moves" on the diagram, they mean its luminosity and temperature change, not that it travels through space.

What goes into a model star

A model star obeys a few physical rules at every layer. Gravity must be balanced by pressure. Energy must flow outwards, by radiation or by convection, the churning of hot gas. And the energy has to come from somewhere: from contraction in a young star, from nuclear fusion later. Two inputs largely decide the outcome: the star's mass and its chemical composition, with mass mattering most. Give a model those two and it predicts the star's luminosity, size and surface temperature at every stage.

Luminosity, radius and temperature

Luminosity, the total power a star emits, depends on both its size and its surface temperature. In units of the Sun's values, as in "Diameters of stars", it is

\frac{L}{L_\odot} = \left(\frac{R}{R_\odot}\right)^2 \left(\frac{T}{T_\odot}\right)^4

where \(L_\odot \approx 3.83 \times 10^{26}\) W is the solar luminosity, \(R_\odot \approx 6.96 \times 10^{8}\) m is the solar radius and \(T_\odot \approx 5{,}770\) K is the Sun's surface temperature. A star can therefore brighten by growing, by heating up or both. This one relation explains the shape of every early track: a shrinking star fades unless its surface heats up fast enough to make up for the smaller area.

Stage one: rapid contraction

At first the collapsing gas is thin enough to be transparent to its own infrared radiation, so the heat of contraction streams straight out into space and the gas falls inwards almost unopposed. This free fall ends once the gas is dense and opaque enough to trap that heat. The young star is then huge, cool and churning with convection from centre to surface, and such a star keeps its surface at a few thousand kelvin as it shrinks. Its radius falls quickly, so its luminosity drops with its shrinking area. On the H-R diagram, the track runs nearly straight down on the right-hand, cool side.

Worked example: a shrinking protostar

A protostar with a surface temperature of 4,000 K contracts from 5 to 2 solar radii while its temperature stays the same. How does its luminosity change? 1. Temperature factor: \(\left(\frac{4000}{5770}\right)^4 = 0.231\). 2. Before: \(L = 5^2 \times 0.231 = 5.77\ L_\odot\). 3. After: \(L = 2^2 \times 0.231 = 0.92\ L_\odot\). 4. Ratio: \(\frac{5.77}{0.92} = 6.25\), which is simply \(\left(\frac{5}{2}\right)^2\), because only the area changed. 5. Interpret: at constant temperature, luminosity scales with radius squared, so the track drops straight down the diagram, as the models predict.

Stage two: slow contraction and heating

As the interior grows steadily hotter, energy in a star like the Sun starts to flow out from the centre by radiation instead of convection, and the contraction slows. For such stars the luminosity now stays roughly constant while the surface heats up, so the track turns and runs to the left across the diagram. Meanwhile the young star's wind clears away the surrounding dust. Low-mass stars can emerge into view during the earlier downward stage, but massive stars stay hidden until they are almost fully formed. All of this energy still comes from gravity: the star is turning the energy of its own infall into heat and light, as Kelvin and Helmholtz once proposed for the Sun.

Arriving on the main sequence

When the core reaches about 10 to 12 million K, hydrogen nuclei fuse into helium fast enough to replace the energy the star radiates. Contraction stops, gravity and pressure balance, and the star's changes slow dramatically. It has arrived on the main sequence and can be said to be born, because it now makes its own energy. Where it lands depends on its mass. Massive stars arrive at the upper left, hot and luminous; low-mass stars arrive at the lower right, cool and dim. The line of arrival points for stars of one composition is the zero-age main sequence, which the topic "From the main sequence to red giants" picks up.

The ends of the main sequence

The main sequence has a bottom and a top. Below about 0.075 to 0.08 solar masses, roughly 80 times Jupiter's mass, an object never gets hot enough inside to sustain hydrogen fusion; it becomes a brown dwarf, which simply cools and fades. Just above that limit sit the red dwarfs, up to about half a solar mass: cool, dim and the most common stars in the galaxy. Proxima Centauri, our closest stellar neighbour, is one. At the top, stars of roughly 100 to 200 solar masses pour out so much radiation that it halts further infall, so stars much bigger than this are not expected to form.

Massive stars hurry

The times on computed tracks are uncertain, but the pattern is clear. A star many times the Sun's mass reaches the main sequence within about a million years or less. A Sun-like star takes a few tens of millions of years. The lowest-mass stars take hundreds of millions of years. This is the first example of a rule that runs through the rest of this course: the more massive a star, the faster it passes through every stage of its life.

Worked example: is this star still forming?

A star in a young cluster has a surface temperature of 4,000 K and a luminosity of 3 \(L_\odot\). Main-sequence stars this cool emit only about 0.1 \(L_\odot\). Is it still contracting? 1. Rearrange the luminosity relation for radius:

\frac{R}{R_\odot} = \frac{\sqrt{L/L_\odot}}{(T/T_\odot)^2}

2. Substitute: \(\frac{\sqrt{3}}{(0.693)^2} = 3.6\) solar radii. 3. Compare: a main-sequence star at 4,000 K is smaller than the Sun, so this star is several times too big and about 30 times too luminous. 4. Conclusion: it sits well above the main sequence, so it is a pre-main-sequence star, still shrinking. Matching its position to computed tracks then gives its mass and a rough age.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, a track on the H-R diagram is not a path through space; it records changing luminosity and temperature. Second, temperature increases to the left, so a star heating up moves left, not right. Third, a contracting protostar is not powered by fusion; its energy comes from gravity until it reaches the main sequence. Fourth, a protostar can grow fainter while it heats up, because its shrinking surface area can outweigh its rising temperature. Fifth, brown dwarfs are not dead stars: they never became stars at all.

Key takeaways

Evolutionary tracks are sequences of computed models plotted on the H-R diagram; mass and composition decide them. Luminosity follows \(L \propto R^2 T^4\). Once it traps its heat, a protostar first contracts quickly at a cool, nearly constant surface temperature, so its track falls almost straight down; then it contracts slowly and moves left as its surface heats. Hydrogen fusion at about 10 to 12 million K marks arrival on the zero-age main sequence, with massive stars at the upper left. The main sequence runs from about 0.08 to roughly 100 to 200 solar masses; below it lie brown dwarfs. Massive stars form fastest.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Evolutionary track

The path of a star's changing luminosity and temperature on the H-R diagram

Computed from a sequence of models.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

When astronomers say a star "moves" across the H-R diagram, what is actually changing?

Question 2 of 5

A protostar shrinks from 6 to 3 solar radii while its surface temperature stays at 3,500 K. What happens to its luminosity?

Question 3 of 5

A star has a luminosity of 4 L☉ and a surface temperature of 2,885 K, half the Sun's. What is its radius?

Question 4 of 5

What marks the moment a protostar becomes a main-sequence star?

Question 5 of 5

Which of these objects can never become a main-sequence star?

← Previous topicNext topic →