Astronomy › Section O · Star birth and exoplanets › Topic O.3

Evidence of planets forming around other stars

Finished planets are tiny and faint next to their stars, but the dusty discs they grow from are enormous and glow brightly in the infrared. Those discs, with their rings, gaps and even half-built planets, show planet formation happening right now.

Look for the raw material

A finished planet is hard to spot: it is faint and sits in the glare of a star millions to billions of times brighter. The material planets are made from is far easier to see. Before planets form, their solids are spread out as countless dust grains orbiting the young star. Each grain is warmed by the star and gives off infrared radiation, and together they cover a vast area. Once the grains clump into a few planets, most of that dust is locked away inside them. So the search for forming planets starts with a search for infrared light from dusty discs.

Worked example: dust versus a finished planet

Compare the glowing area of one Earth mass of dust grains with that of the Earth itself. Take grains of radius \(r = 10^{-6}\) m and density \(\rho = 3{,}000\) kg/m³. 1. Number of grains: total mass \(M\) divided by the mass of one grain, \(\frac{4}{3}\pi r^3 \rho\). 2. Each grain shows a cross-section \(\pi r^2\), so the total area simplifies to

A = \frac{3M}{4r\rho} = \frac{3(5.97 \times 10^{24})}{4(10^{-6})(3{,}000)} = 1.5 \times 10^{27}\ \mathrm{m^2}

3. Earth's disc has area \(\pi(6.37 \times 10^6)^2 = 1.3 \times 10^{14}\) m². 4. Ratio: about \(10^{13}\). 5. Conclusion: the same material glows trillions of times more brightly as dust than as a planet.

Discs are everywhere

Observations show that nearly all very young stars are surrounded by discs, as "Star formation" predicts. They range from about 10 to 1,000 AU across. (One astronomical unit, AU, is the mean Earth-Sun distance, about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m; Pluto's orbit is roughly 80 AU across.) Their masses are uncertain, because most of the gas is hard to detect, but estimates run from about 0.1% to 10% of the Sun's mass. Even the low end matches all the solar system's planets combined, about 0.13% of the Sun's mass. Discs show up as extra infrared light, as dark silhouettes against bright nebulae such as Orion's, and in direct images.

Worked example: reading a disc's temperature

As "Origin of the solar system" showed, a dark dust grain orbiting a Sun-like star reaches a temperature of roughly \(T \approx \frac{278\ \mathrm{K}}{\sqrt{d}}\), where \(d\) is its distance in AU. Where does dust at 1 AU and at 100 AU emit most strongly? 1. At 1 AU: \(T \approx 278\) K. Wien's law gives \(\lambda_{max} = \frac{2.90 \times 10^{-3}}{278} = 1.0 \times 10^{-5}\) m, or 10 micrometres, in the mid-infrared. 2. At 100 AU: \(T \approx \frac{278}{10} = 28\) K, so \(\lambda_{max} \approx 1.0 \times 10^{-4}\) m, or 100 micrometres. 3. Interpret: the inner disc shines in the mid-infrared, the cold outer disc at far-infrared and, for the largest grains, millimetre wavelengths. 4. That is why infrared telescopes map inner discs and radio arrays such as ALMA in Chile map outer ones.

Discs keep time

A young star's position on the H-R diagram, compared with computed tracks as in "The H-R diagram and stellar evolution", gives its age. Sorting discs by the ages of their stars reveals a sequence. Around stars younger than about 1 to 3 million years, the dust reaches all the way in to the star, and outwards for tens to hundreds of AU. Somewhat older stars often have discs with an empty inner hole, like a doughnut, possibly swept clear by a forming planet. By about 10 million years, almost all discs have lost their gas and inner dust, and roughly half are gone within a few million years. Planet building, especially of gas giants, must therefore be quick.

From dust to planetesimals

In the disc, dust grains collide and stick, growing into fluffy clumps and then pebbles. Growth then hits a hurdle. Bodies from roughly centimetres to metres across feel a strong headwind from the slightly slower-orbiting gas, lose orbital energy and can spiral into the star in as little as a few hundred years. To survive, they must quickly reach about a kilometre across, the size of a planetesimal, big enough that gas drag hardly matters. How they cross this gap is still debated; one promising idea is that dense swarms of pebbles collapse directly under their own gravity. Planetesimals then collide and merge into protoplanets.

Building giant planets

In the most widely accepted model, called core accretion, a giant planet starts as a solid core. Once the core reaches roughly 10 Earth masses, its gravity can capture hydrogen and helium from the disc, and it balloons rapidly into a gas giant. This must happen before the young star's wind and radiation clear away the gas, within about 10 million years at most. A second idea, that part of a massive disc collapses directly into a giant planet, may explain some giants found very far from their stars, but how often it happens is debated.

Rings, gaps and planets caught growing

In 2014, the ALMA radio array imaged the disc of HL Tau, a star less than about a million years old some 450 light-years away, and revealed a set of bright rings separated by dark gaps. Many discs have since shown similar rings, gaps and spirals. A growing planet can clear a lane along its orbit while its gravity keeps outer material from drifting in, much as small moons shape Saturn's rings. Other causes are possible too, so gaps alone do not prove planets. The young star PDS 70, about 370 light-years away, gives stronger evidence: two giant planets have been imaged inside the gap in its disc, still gathering gas.

Debris discs: what is left

Small dust does not last long: starlight pushes the finest grains out of the system and drags others inwards within thousands to millions of years. Yet many stars tens or hundreds of millions of years old still have dusty discs. This is second-generation dust, made as planetesimals and comets collide and shatter, so these are called debris discs. Beta Pictoris, about 63 light-years away and roughly 20 million years old, has an edge-on debris disc and two imaged giant planets. In 2023 the James Webb Space Telescope showed three nested dust belts around Fomalhaut, about 25 light-years away. Most debris discs fade by a few hundred million years, leaving belts like our Kuiper belt.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, the infrared glow of a disc does not come from planets; it comes from warm dust spread over a huge area. Second, a debris disc is not leftover birth dust; its grains are constantly replaced by collisions. Third, a ring or gap is strong but not conclusive evidence of a planet, since other processes can make similar patterns. Fourth, planet formation is not slow compared with the star's life: gas giants must form within a few million years, before the gas disappears. Fifth, young gas-rich discs such as HL Tau's and old, gas-poor debris discs such as Fomalhaut's are different stages, not the same thing.

Key takeaways

Dust in a disc radiates over an area about \(10^{13}\) times larger than the planet it could make, so forming systems are easiest to find in the infrared. Nearly all very young stars have discs 10 to 1,000 AU across; warm inner dust glows in the mid-infrared and cold outer dust at far-infrared and millimetre wavelengths. Discs develop inner holes and mostly vanish within about 10 million years, so planets form fast. Dust grows into kilometre-sized planetesimals, then protoplanets; a core of about 10 Earth masses can grow into a giant. ALMA's rings and gaps, PDS 70's growing planets and debris discs such as Fomalhaut's trace each stage.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Protoplanetary disc

Rotating disc of gas and dust around a young star, where planets form

Found around nearly all very young stars.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why do astronomers look for infrared light from discs, rather than for the planets themselves, to find planets forming?

Question 2 of 5

Using T ≈ 278 K ÷ √d, about what temperature does dark dust reach 25 AU from a Sun-like star?

Question 3 of 5

A 5-million-year-old star has a disc whose outer part is dusty but whose inner region is nearly empty. What is the most likely explanation?

Question 4 of 5

Why must giant planets form within about 10 million years of their star's birth?

Question 5 of 5

A 300-million-year-old star is still surrounded by a dusty disc. Why is the dust still there?

← Previous topicNext topic →