Astronomy › Section C · Orbits and gravity › Topic C.1

The laws of planetary motion

Around 1600, a meticulous observer and a stubborn mathematician turned the Sun-centred idea into a precise description of how planets move. Kepler's three laws still predict orbits today, from asteroids to planets around other stars.

Tycho Brahe's record of the sky

Tycho Brahe (1546-1601), a Danish nobleman, was the finest observer of the age before telescopes. His study of the bright new star of 1572 made his name, and the Danish king gave him the island of Hven for an observatory. For about 20 years he tracked where the Sun, Moon and planets stood among the stars, using giant sighting instruments, to within about 1 or 2 arcminutes, a small fraction of the Moon's width. He saw that the published planetary tables were often wrong but never produced a better theory. After losing royal support he moved to Prague in 1599 and hired a young mathematician to analyse his data.

Johannes Kepler and the problem of Mars

Johannes Kepler (1571-1630) was already a convinced Copernican when he joined Brahe in 1600. Brahe set him to work on Mars, and when Brahe died in 1601 Kepler inherited the whole record. Mars was the hard case: its path refused to fit any combination of circles, and Kepler's best circle-based model still missed Brahe's positions by about 8 arcminutes. Rather than blame the data, Kepler trusted Brahe's accuracy and abandoned circles. He published his first two laws in 1609, in The New Astronomy, and his third in 1619: precise data had overturned a two-thousand-year-old assumption.

What an ellipse is

An ellipse is a closed curve with two points inside it called foci (singular: focus). For every point on the curve, the distances to the two foci add up to the same total, so you can draw one with two pins, a loop of string and a pencil. Half the longest diameter is the semi-major axis \(a\), which sets the size and equals a planet's average distance from the Sun. The eccentricity \(e\) sets the shape: the distance between the foci divided by the longest diameter. A circle has \(e = 0\), because its foci merge at the centre; as \(e\) approaches 1, the ellipse becomes long and thin.

The first law: orbits are ellipses

Kepler's first law: every planet's orbit is an ellipse, and the Sun sits at one of its two foci, while nothing occupies the second. The closest point to the Sun is the perihelion and the farthest is the aphelion. Because each focus lies a distance \(ae\) from the centre,

r_{\text{peri}} = a(1 - e), \qquad r_{\text{aph}} = a(1 + e)

Planetary orbits are close to circles: Mercury's is the most eccentric at about 0.21, and the rest are below 0.1. Mars, at about 0.09, was just eccentric enough for Kepler to detect the ellipse in Brahe's data.

Worked example: how far Earth's distance swings

The astronomical unit (AU) is Earth's average distance from the Sun, about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m. So Earth's orbit has \(a = 1.000\) AU, and \(e\) is about 0.0167. 1. Perihelion: \(r = 1.000 \times (1 - 0.0167) = 0.983\) AU, about 147.1 million km. 2. Aphelion: \(r = 1.000 \times (1 + 0.0167) = 1.017\) AU, about 152.1 million km. 3. Compare: the aphelion distance is only about 3.4% larger than the perihelion distance. 4. Check: the two distances average to exactly \(a\). Earth reaches perihelion in early January, during northern winter, so this small swing in distance is not what causes the seasons.

The second law: equal areas in equal times

Kepler's second law: the line from the Sun to a planet sweeps out equal areas in equal times. Near perihelion the line is short, so to sweep the same area in a day the planet must cover a longer arc. Near aphelion it moves more slowly. Earth moves about 3% faster in early January than in early July. For a comet on a very elongated orbit the difference is dramatic: it crawls through the distant part of its orbit for decades, then whips around the Sun in a few months. Only in a perfectly circular orbit would the speed be constant.

The third law: periods and distances

Kepler's third law links orbit size to orbit time: the square of the period \(P\) is proportional to the cube of the semi-major axis \(a\). Around the Sun, with \(P\) in years and \(a\) in AU, the constant is 1:

P^2 = a^3

For Mars, \(a = 1.524\) AU gives \(P = \sqrt{1.524^3} = 1.88\) years, matching its observed period. Distant planets take longer for two reasons: they have farther to go, and they move more slowly. The period depends only on \(a\), not on the eccentricity, so a comet and a planet with the same semi-major axis share the same period.

Worked example: using the third law both ways

Problem A: an asteroid has \(a = 2.50\) AU. What is its period? 1. Cube the semi-major axis: \(2.50^3 = 15.6\). 2. This equals \(P^2\), so \(P = \sqrt{15.6} = 3.95\) years. Problem B: a distant icy body takes 42.0 years to orbit the Sun. How large is its orbit? 1. Square the period: \(42.0^2 = 1764\). 2. This equals \(a^3\), so \(a = \sqrt[3]{1764} = 12.1\) AU. 3. Check: \(12.1^3 \approx 1770\), close to 1764 given rounding. Both answers are sensible: the asteroid lies between Mars and Jupiter, and the icy body orbits beyond Saturn, at about 9.5 AU.

Worked example: Halley's Comet

Halley's Comet returns about every 75 years (the planets' tugs make it vary by a few years) and has an eccentricity of about 0.967. 1. Third law: \(a^3 = 75^2 = 5625\), so \(a = \sqrt[3]{5625} = 17.8\) AU. 2. Perihelion: \(a(1 - e) = 17.8 \times 0.033 = 0.59\) AU, inside the orbit of Venus. 3. Aphelion: \(a(1 + e) = 17.8 \times 1.967 = 35.0\) AU, beyond Neptune. 4. Second law: the line to the Sun is about 60 times longer at aphelion, so the comet moves about 60 times more slowly there. 5. Check: the two distances average to 17.8 AU.

What the laws do and do not explain

Kepler's laws are empirical: found by fitting observations, they describe how planets move without saying why. Kepler suspected a force from the Sun but had no theory of it; the explanation came about 70 years later, as Newton's great synthesis shows. The laws also hold for moons, artificial satellites and planets around other stars, which is why NASA named its planet-hunting Kepler space telescope (2009-2018) after him. One caution: the simple form \(P^2 = a^3\) holds only in years and AU and only for objects orbiting the Sun. Around another central body the constant changes, as Newton's universal law of gravitation explains.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, putting the Sun at the centre of the ellipse rather than at a focus. Second, treating \(P^2 = a^3\) as a direct proportion: doubling the distance multiplies the period by about 2.83, not 2. Third, using the law with kilometres and days, or for a moon orbiting a planet: the constant 1 applies only in years and AU, around the Sun. Fourth, assuming constant speed: a planet is fastest at perihelion. Fifth, confusing eccentricity with size: \(a\) sets the size and \(e\) the shape.

Key takeaways

Brahe's naked-eye data, accurate to about 1 or 2 arcminutes, let Kepler reject circles. First law: planets move on ellipses with the Sun at one focus; perihelion is a(1 − e) and aphelion a(1 + e) from the Sun. Eccentricity measures shape, from 0 for a circle towards 1; planetary orbits are nearly circular. Second law: equal areas in equal times, so planets move fastest at perihelion. Third law: P² = a³, with P in years and a in AU, around the Sun. The laws describe orbits; Newton explained them.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Tycho Brahe

Danish observer (1546-1601) whose 20 years of precise naked-eye positions Kepler used

Observatory on the island of Hven.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

An asteroid's orbit around the Sun is 4.00 AU in semi-major axis. How long does one orbit take?

Question 2 of 5

A comet's orbit has a semi-major axis of 2.00 AU and an eccentricity of 0.500. How far from the Sun is it at aphelion?

Question 3 of 5

According to Kepler's second law, where in its orbit does a planet move fastest?

Question 4 of 5

Why did Kepler abandon circular orbits for Mars?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement best describes Kepler's three laws?

← Previous topicNext topic →