Astronomy › Section B · Observing the sky › Topic B.4

The birth of modern astronomy

Between 1543 and the 1630s, Earth lost its place at the centre of the universe. Copernicus offered a Sun-centred model, and Galileo, armed with a telescope and a new way of studying motion, found evidence the old view could not explain.

Knowledge carried across centuries

While Western Europe produced little new astronomy in the early Middle Ages, scholars in the Islamic world translated Greek works into Arabic, built observatories and improved the measurements. Jewish and Christian scholars in Spain and elsewhere helped translate these works into Latin from the 1100s onwards, and Europe rediscovered Ptolemy's Almagest. The debt shows in the sky's vocabulary: star names such as Aldebaran, Betelgeuse and Deneb come from Arabic, as do the words zenith and azimuth. By the 1400s, European astronomers were again checking Ptolemy's predictions against the sky and finding errors.

Copernicus and the Sun-centred model

Nicolaus Copernicus (1473-1543), a Polish church canon trained in law and medicine, worked on astronomy for decades. His book On the Revolutions of the Heavenly Spheres appeared in 1543, the year he died. In his heliocentric, or Sun-centred, model, Earth is one of six planets orbiting the Sun, and only the Moon orbits Earth. Earth also spins once a day, which explains the daily turning of the sky. The yearly drift of the Sun along the ecliptic becomes a reflection of Earth's own orbit.

What the new model explained

Copernicus put the planets in their correct order from the Sun: Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn. Planets closer to the Sun move faster. Retrograde loops now needed no large epicycles: when faster Earth passes a slower outer planet, the planet appears to slip backwards against the stars, just as a car you overtake seems to move backwards against distant hills. The model also gave each planet's distance from the Sun relative to Earth's. Copernicus put Saturn about 9 times farther out than Earth, close to the modern 9.5 AU.

Worked example: a planet's true period

From Earth we can time a planet's synodic period, the time between successive retrogrades. In a Sun-centred model this converts to its sidereal period \(P\), the true time to orbit the Sun. For an outer planet, with Earth's period \(E\) and synodic period \(S\):

\frac{1}{P} = \frac{1}{E} - \frac{1}{S}

Mars has \(S = 780\) days and \(E = 365.25\) days. 1. \(\frac{1}{365.25} = 0.0027379\) and \(\frac{1}{780} = 0.0012821\). 2. Subtract: \(\frac{1}{P} = 0.0014558\) per day. 3. Invert: \(P = 687\) days, about 1.88 years. 4. Check: Mars lies farther out than Earth, so it should take longer than a year.

Why it was not accepted at once

Copernicus kept the old belief that heavenly motions must be perfect circles at steady speed. Real orbits are not quite circles, so he still needed small extra circles, and his predictions were not much better than Ptolemy's. There were serious objections, too. If Earth moved, why did no one feel it, and why did objects not fly off? And why was no stellar parallax seen? He answered the first by noting that motion on a smoothly moving boat is not felt. The second he answered only by supposing the stars were immensely far away, which was correct but could not yet be shown.

From Tycho to Kepler

Two later astronomers turned the debate into precise science. The Danish nobleman Tycho Brahe, in the late 1500s, made the most accurate naked-eye measurements of planetary positions ever recorded. He favoured a hybrid model, with the planets circling the Sun while the Sun circled a fixed Earth. His assistant Johannes Kepler used Tycho's Mars data to show that planets move in ellipses, not circles, which finally made a Sun-centred model more accurate than any rival. That story, and Kepler's three laws, are the subject of "The laws of planetary motion".

Galileo and the science of motion

Galileo Galilei (1564-1642), professor of mathematics at Pisa and Padua, helped found experimental physics. Most people, following Aristotle, thought rest was the natural state of objects. By rolling balls down smooth ramps, Galileo argued that a moving object would keep moving at a steady speed in a straight line if friction and other forces were removed, an early form of the idea of inertia. He also showed that falling bodies speed up at a steady rate, regardless of their weight once air resistance is negligible. Inertia also answered the old objection: on a moving Earth, objects simply share its motion.

Galileo turns a telescope on the sky

Telescopes appeared in the Netherlands in 1608, when the spectacle maker Hans Lippershey applied for a patent. Galileo heard of the invention, built his own in 1609 and improved it to about 20 times magnification. In 1610 he published The Starry Messenger. The Moon had mountains and craters, so it was a world, not a perfect sphere. The Milky Way dissolved into countless faint stars. Most striking, four moons circled Jupiter, with periods from under 2 days to about 17 days. Here was proof that not everything orbits Earth, and that a moving planet can keep its moons.

Worked example: reading the phases of Venus

In late 1610 Galileo watched Venus change shape. 1. Observation: Venus showed a full range of phases, from a large thin crescent to a small, nearly full disc. 2. Ptolemy's model: Venus always lies between Earth and the Sun, so from Earth we would see mostly its unlit side and only crescent or new phases. 3. Sun-centred model: Venus orbits the Sun inside Earth's orbit, so when it is on the far side of the Sun it shows nearly full, and looks small because it is far away. 4. Conclusion: the observations fit Venus orbiting the Sun and rule out Ptolemy's arrangement. 5. Caution: Tycho's hybrid model also had Venus circling the Sun, so this test alone could not decide between Copernicus and Tycho.

Conflict with the Church

Galileo argued openly for Copernicus, often in Italian rather than scholarly Latin. In 1616 the Catholic Church declared the Sun-centred view false and contrary to scripture, and Galileo was warned not to defend it. His Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems of 1632 was seen as doing exactly that. In 1633 the Inquisition convicted him of "vehement suspicion of heresy"; he recanted and spent his last years under house arrest. The Dialogue stayed on the Church's list of banned books until the 1830s, and in 1992 Pope John Paul II formally acknowledged that the Church had erred.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking Copernicus's model was immediately more accurate; with circular orbits it was not, until Kepler introduced ellipses. Second, saying Copernicus removed every epicycle; he still used small circles. Third, believing Galileo invented the telescope; he built and improved one after hearing of the Dutch invention. Fourth, claiming the phases of Venus proved Earth moves; they ruled out Ptolemy's arrangement but also fitted Tycho's model. Fifth, assuming stellar parallax was measured in Galileo's time; that came only in 1838.

Key takeaways

Islamic-world scholars preserved and improved Greek astronomy, which Europe recovered through Latin translations. Copernicus's 1543 heliocentric model ordered the planets, explained retrograde motion as Earth overtaking outer planets, and gave relative distances, but kept circular orbits. Synodic periods convert to true orbital periods: 1/P = 1/E − 1/S for an outer planet. Tycho measured precisely and Kepler found ellipses. Galileo pioneered the study of motion and, from 1609, used the telescope to find lunar mountains, Jupiter's moons and the full phases of Venus. He was tried in 1633.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Arabic star names

Aldebaran, Betelgeuse, Deneb; also the words zenith and azimuth

Legacy of astronomy in the Islamic world.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Jupiter's synodic period is 399 days. Using 1/P = 1/E − 1/S with E = 365.25 days, what is its sidereal period?

Question 2 of 5

Why were the phases of Venus seen by Galileo strong evidence against Ptolemy's model?

Question 3 of 5

Why did Copernicus's model, at first, predict planetary positions little better than Ptolemy's?

Question 4 of 5

What did Galileo's discovery of four moons orbiting Jupiter show?

Question 5 of 5

Which objection to a moving Earth could neither Copernicus nor Galileo answer with direct evidence?

← Previous topicNext topic →