Astronomy › Section P · Stars from adolescence to old age › Topic P.4

Further evolution of stars

A red giant is not the end of the story. Its core ignites helium, builds carbon and oxygen, and swells the star into a giant a second time, while the outer layers drift away to form some of the loveliest objects in the sky.

Where the red giant left off

In "From the main sequence to red giants", a star ran out of core hydrogen, its helium core began contracting and heating, and hydrogen fused in a shell around it while the envelope swelled. What happens next depends on the star's mass. This topic follows stars born with up to about twice the Sun's mass, which includes the Sun and most stars. Because such stars lose much of their mass as they age, they are labelled by their initial mass. Heavier stars are the subject of "Evolution of more massive stars".

Helium fusion: the triple-alpha process

The contracting helium core keeps heating until it reaches about 100 million K. Only then can helium nuclei, each with two protons, collide hard enough to overcome their electrical repulsion. Two helium nuclei can stick, but they form beryllium-8, which falls apart almost instantly. Only if a third helium nucleus arrives in that brief moment does a stable carbon-12 nucleus form. Because a helium nucleus is also called an alpha particle, this is the triple-alpha process. Some of the new carbon captures yet another helium nucleus to become oxygen-16. The carbon in your body was made in stars, largely this way.

Worked example: how much energy does helium give?

Three helium-4 atoms have a combined mass of 12.007809 u (3 × 4.002603 u), where u is the atomic mass unit, and one carbon-12 atom has 12.000000 u; the electrons balance on both sides. 1. Mass lost:

\Delta m = 12.007809 - 12.000000 = 0.007809\ \mathrm{u}

2. Energy, using 1 u = 931.5 MeV: \(0.007809 \times 931.5 = 7.27\) MeV per carbon nucleus. 3. Fraction of mass converted: \(\frac{0.007809}{12.007809} = 0.065\%\). 4. Compare: hydrogen fusion converts about 0.7%, roughly ten times more. 5. Interpret: a kilogram of helium yields only about a tenth as much energy as a kilogram of hydrogen, and the star is now far more luminous, so this stage cannot last long.

The helium flash

In stars of roughly 0.8 to 2 solar masses, the helium core is squeezed so tightly before ignition that it becomes degenerate: its pressure comes from electrons packed as closely as quantum physics allows, and it barely responds to temperature. The topic "The death of low-mass stars" explains this state. Ordinary gas expands and cools when heated, steadying fusion; a degenerate core lacks that safety valve. Once helium ignites, the heat speeds up fusion, which makes more heat, and the whole core ignites in a runaway called the helium flash. Its energy is absorbed inside, so the surface shows no outburst. Heavier stars ignite helium gradually.

A calmer interlude

After the flash the core expands, stops being degenerate and settles into steady helium fusion, while hydrogen keeps fusing in a shell outside it. The star readjusts: it becomes smaller, its surface heats up and its luminosity falls. Its point on the H-R diagram moves down and to the left of the red-giant region. In old clusters these helium-fusing stars form the horizontal branch, a band at roughly constant luminosity; in younger, more metal-rich groups they bunch into a red clump. For a Sun-like star models put this stage at about 100 million years, only about 1% of its main-sequence life, because helium yields so little energy.

Giant again

When the core's helium is used up, the star is left with a core of carbon and oxygen, and the old pattern repeats. With no fusion at the centre, the core contracts and heats. Helium fuses in a shell around it, and hydrogen in another shell farther out, so the star has an onion-like structure: a carbon-oxygen core, a helium-fusing shell, a helium layer, a hydrogen-fusing shell and a vast envelope. Energy pouring from the two shells swells the star again, and it climbs back up and to the right on the H-R diagram, becoming larger and brighter than before. A star like the Sun can never squeeze its core to the roughly 600 million K needed to fuse carbon, so this is its last fusion stage.

Mass loss and new elements

A giant's surface lies so far from its centre that gravity there is weak. The Sun's escape speed is about 618 km/s today; for a 0.8-solar-mass giant 150 times the Sun's radius, it is only about 45 km/s. Pulsations and radiation pushing on newly formed dust grains drive strong winds. A Sun-like star may lose a quarter of its mass before helium ignites and more afterwards. The wind carries fresh elements too: in late giants, convection dredges up carbon, along with heavier elements such as barium made by slow neutron capture, enriching the gas described in "The life cycle of cosmic material".

Planetary nebulae

Eventually the star sheds nearly all of its envelope, exposing the hot core. That core shrinks and heats to 100,000 K or more, and its intense ultraviolet light ionises the gas thrown off earlier, which glows like a neon sign. The result is a planetary nebula. The name, from William Herschel in the 1780s, is misleading: some looked like the discs of planets in small telescopes, but they have nothing to do with planets. Many have elaborate shapes, possibly sculpted by companion stars. The Ring Nebula in Lyra, a few thousand light-years away, is a famous example. The exposed core becomes a white dwarf.

Worked example: how long does a planetary nebula last?

A planetary nebula is 1 light-year across and its shell expands at 20 km/s. Roughly how long ago was it ejected? 1. The shell's radius is half the diameter: 0.5 ly, or \(0.5 \times 9.46 \times 10^{15} = 4.73 \times 10^{15}\) m, since one light-year is about \(9.46 \times 10^{15}\) m. 2. Time at constant speed: \(t = \frac{4.73 \times 10^{15}}{2.0 \times 10^{4}} = 2.4 \times 10^{11}\) s. 3. Convert, with a year of \(3.16 \times 10^7\) s: about 7,500 years. 4. Interpret: within some tens of thousands of years the shell fades from view, a blink in a star's life, yet thousands are seen, so most stars must pass through this stage.

The Sun's future and Earth's fate

The Sun brightens slowly, by roughly 10% per billion years. Within roughly 1 to 2 billion years, by widely varying estimates, Earth will grow hot enough to lose its oceans to a runaway greenhouse effect. In about 5 billion years the Sun will leave the main sequence and swell into a red giant perhaps around 1 AU in radius, where 1 AU, about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m, is the Earth-Sun distance. Whether it swallows Earth is uncertain: as the Sun loses mass its pull weakens and the planets' orbits widen, while tides drag Earth inwards. Mercury and Venus will almost certainly be engulfed.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, helium does not fuse in pairs: the triple-alpha process needs three nuclei, because two make unstable beryllium-8. Second, the helium flash is not a visible explosion; its energy stays inside the star. Third, after the flash the star gets smaller and hotter, not larger. Fourth, planetary nebulae have nothing to do with planets.

Key takeaways

At about 100 million K, the triple-alpha process fuses three helium nuclei into carbon, converting about 0.065% of the mass, roughly a tenth of hydrogen's yield. In stars of about 0.8 to 2 solar masses, helium ignites in a runaway helium flash inside a degenerate core. The star then shrinks, heats and fuses helium steadily for about 100 million years, before its carbon-oxygen core contracts and two fusing shells make it a giant again. Weak surface gravity drives heavy mass loss and carries new elements out. The exposed core lights a planetary nebula, then becomes a white dwarf.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Initial mass

A star's mass at birth, used to label it because stars lose mass as they age

This topic: up to about 2 M☉.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why does helium fusion in stars need three helium nuclei rather than two?

Question 2 of 5

Three helium-4 atoms have 12.007809 u of mass and one carbon-12 atom has 12.000000 u. About what fraction of the mass becomes energy?

Question 3 of 5

After the helium flash, how does a Sun-like star's point move on the H-R diagram?

Question 4 of 5

A planetary nebula is 0.6 light-years across and expands at 25 km/s. Roughly how long ago was its shell ejected?

Question 5 of 5

Why will the Sun never fuse the carbon in its core?

← Previous topicNext topic →