Astronomy › Section P · Stars from adolescence to old age › Topic P.5
Evolution of more massive stars
The Big Bang made almost nothing but hydrogen and helium, yet Earth is rich in oxygen, silicon and iron. Those elements were forged in massive stars, which live fast, swell into supergiants and fuse element after element until their cores fill with iron.
A problem of ingredients
The first few minutes of the universe produced hydrogen, helium and a trace of lithium, and essentially nothing heavier. Yet the world around us is full of carbon, oxygen, silicon, iron and much more. They were made where it is hot enough to fuse nuclei: inside stars and in the violent events that end some stars' lives. Low-mass stars stop at carbon and oxygen, as "Further evolution of stars" showed; going further takes stars of more than about 8 solar masses, where a solar mass, \(M_\odot\), is about \(1.99 \times 10^{30}\) kg. This topic follows them.
Living fast
Massive stars follow the same opening steps as the Sun, only far faster. Hydrogen fuses in the core, then in a shell; helium ignites, but gradually, with no flash, once a star has more than about 2 solar masses. Stars between about 2 and 8 solar masses stop after building a carbon-oxygen core, much like the Sun. Above that, massive stars shine at tens of thousands to millions of times the Sun's luminosity and blow away mass in powerful winds. Eta Carinae, more than 100 solar masses including a companion star, threw off roughly ten solar masses or more in a giant eruption seen in the 1840s and survived.
Worked example: how long does a 20-solar-mass star last?
Suppose a star of 20 solar masses fuses hydrogen equal to 10% of its mass on the main sequence, converting 0.7% of that mass into energy, and shines at 50,000 times the solar luminosity \(L_\odot = 3.83 \times 10^{26}\) W. 1. Fuel mass: \(0.1 \times 20 \times 1.99 \times 10^{30} = 3.98 \times 10^{30}\) kg. 2. Energy:
3. Luminosity: \(5 \times 10^4 \times 3.83 \times 10^{26} = 1.9 \times 10^{31}\) W. 4. Time: \(\frac{2.5 \times 10^{45}}{1.9 \times 10^{31}} = 1.3 \times 10^{14}\) s, about 4 million years. 5. Check: detailed models give roughly 8 to 10 million years, since such stars fuse a larger share of their hydrogen; either way, about a thousandth of the Sun's lifetime.
Supergiants on the H-R diagram
When a massive star leaves the main sequence it becomes a supergiant. Because its luminosity changes relatively little during its later stages, its track runs roughly horizontally across the top of the H-R diagram, and it may swing between hot blue supergiant and cool red supergiant, sometimes more than once. Strong winds can strip away the outer hydrogen entirely, exposing hot layers rich in helium, carbon or nitrogen; such stars are called Wolf-Rayet stars. In Orion, Rigel is a blue supergiant and Betelgeuse a red one.
Worked example: blue and red supergiants
Compare two supergiants that each shine at 100,000 solar luminosities, one at 12,000 K and one at 3,500 K. Use \(\frac{R}{R_\odot} = \frac{\sqrt{L/L_\odot}}{(T/T_\odot)^2}\) with \(T_\odot = 5{,}770\) K. 1. \(\sqrt{100{,}000} = 316\). 2. Blue:
3. Red:
4. Convert the red one, with \(R_\odot = 6.96 \times 10^8\) m and 1 AU \(= 1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m, the Earth-Sun distance: about 4.0 AU. 5. Interpret: at the same luminosity, cooling from blue to red means swelling about twelve times; placed where the Sun is, the red supergiant would reach well beyond Mars.
Fusing beyond carbon
In a star above about 8 solar masses, the weight of the overlying layers squeezes the carbon-oxygen core to around 600 million K, and carbon nuclei begin to fuse, making neon, sodium and magnesium. Each time a fuel runs out, the core contracts and heats until the next one ignites: neon at roughly 1.2 billion K, then oxygen at roughly 1.5 to 2 billion K, making silicon and sulphur, and finally silicon at around 3 billion K, building nuclei of the iron group, such as iron and nickel. Physicists can trace nuclear pathways that build nearly every element up to iron this way.
Each stage faster than the last
For a star of about 25 solar masses, models give roughly 7 million years of hydrogen fusion and well under a million years of helium fusion. Then the pace becomes frantic: carbon lasts some hundreds of years, neon and oxygen about a year or less each, and silicon only about a day. Two reasons combine. Each heavier fuel releases less energy per kilogram than the one before. And from carbon fusion onwards, the core produces huge numbers of neutrinos, ghostly particles that stream straight out of the star, carrying away energy that the core must replace by fusing even faster.
An onion with an iron heart
Near the end, a massive star is layered like an onion. At the centre is a core of iron-group elements. Around it, shells fuse silicon, oxygen, neon, carbon, helium and hydrogen, each lighter fuel farther out where the temperature is lower, all inside a huge envelope of hydrogen-rich gas. The iron core is a dead end. Nuclei near iron are the most tightly bound of all, so fusing iron into anything heavier absorbs energy instead of releasing it. With no energy source, the iron core grows heavier with every day of silicon fusion around it, setting up the collapse described in "Massive stars: an explosive finish".
The origin of the elements
This nucleosynthesis, the building of new nuclei, explains not just which elements exist but how common they are. It correctly predicts that oxygen, carbon and iron are plentiful and gold and uranium rare. Elements up to the iron group are made mostly by fusion in stars. Most elements heavier than iron are built instead by neutron capture: slowly, in giant stars, as mentioned in "Further evolution of stars", and rapidly in violent events, including supernovae and collisions of neutron stars, as later topics describe. Much of the oxygen you breathe was made inside massive stars.
Generations of stars
Because each generation of stars returns enriched gas to space, younger stars contain more heavy elements than older ones. In the Sun, about 1.3 to 1.5% of the mass is elements heavier than helium, and stars in open clusters are similar. Stars in globular clusters, which formed over 10 billion years ago, typically have only a tenth to a hundredth as much, and some ancient lone stars even less. Theory predicts the very first stars were made of hydrogen and helium alone and were very massive; none has yet been confirmed, and the James Webb Space Telescope is searching distant young galaxies for their light.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, fusion does not keep going past iron: fusing iron absorbs energy. Second, only stars above about 8 solar masses fuse carbon; stars of 2 to 8 solar masses stop at a carbon-oxygen core. Third, more fuel stages do not mean a longer life; each stage is shorter than the last. Fourth, a supergiant's later stages change its surface temperature much more than its luminosity, so its track runs sideways, not up.
Key takeaways
Massive stars live millions rather than billions of years and lose mass in strong winds. Above about 8 solar masses, cores reach about 600 million K and fuse carbon, then neon, oxygen and silicon, each at a higher temperature and for a shorter time, ending with silicon lasting about a day. The result is an onion of fusing shells around an iron-group core. Iron cannot release energy by fusion, so the core is doomed to collapse. Stars make the elements up to iron, and each generation enriches the next: globular-cluster stars have a tenth to a hundredth of the Sun's heavy elements.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Hydrogen, helium and a trace of lithium
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why does fusion in a massive star's core stop once iron has formed?
Question 2 of 5
Which of these stars will eventually fuse carbon in its core?
Question 3 of 5
A supergiant has a luminosity of 40,000 L☉ and a surface temperature of 2,885 K, half the Sun's. What is its radius?
Question 4 of 5
Why do the late fusion stages of a massive star, such as silicon fusion, last only days?
Question 5 of 5
Why do globular-cluster stars contain far fewer heavy elements than the Sun?
