Astronomy › Section Q · The death of stars › Topic Q.1

The death of low-mass stars

Most stars, the Sun among them, do not explode. They end as white dwarfs: Earth-sized embers held up by a strange quantum pressure, cooling quietly for longer than the universe has yet existed.

Which stars die quietly?

Astronomers measure stellar masses in solar masses, where one solar mass, \(M_\odot\), is about \(1.99 \times 10^{30}\) kg. A star dies quietly if its mass, at the moment it runs out of nuclear fuel, is below about 1.4 solar masses. That covers most stars, for two reasons. Low-mass stars vastly outnumber massive ones. And stars lose a great deal of mass in strong winds as red giants and when they puff off a planetary nebula, as the topic "Further evolution of stars" described. Stars born with up to about 8 solar masses, possibly a little more, seem to shed enough to finish below the 1.4 line.

A core with no fuel left

Once its core helium has been fused into carbon and oxygen, a low-mass star is stuck. Its core shrinks and heats, but the star is not massive enough to squeeze the core to the roughly 600 million K needed to fuse carbon. The outer layers drift away, exposing the hot core, which at first can be over 100,000 K at its surface. With no fusion to supply pressure, the core keeps contracting under gravity until it reaches about a million times the density of water. Only then does a new kind of pressure stop the collapse.

Degenerate electrons

Inside a star the atoms are stripped of their electrons. Quantum physics sets a strict rule for electrons, the Pauli exclusion principle: no two can occupy the same state, meaning the same place with the same motion and spin. In a collapsing core the electrons are crowded so tightly that the low-energy states fill up, and squeezing further would force electrons into states already taken. They resist with enormous electron degeneracy pressure. Matter in this condition is called degenerate. Crucially, this pressure does not depend on temperature, so the object can cool for ever without shrinking. The nuclei are present too, but they are not crowded enough to become degenerate themselves.

White dwarfs

A stellar core supported by degenerate electrons is a white dwarf. A typical one holds about 0.6 solar masses in a ball about the size of Earth. The name comes from the first ones found, which were hot and white, but white dwarfs come in all temperatures as they cool. A famous example is Sirius B, the faint companion of Sirius, the brightest star in the night sky: it has about the mass of the Sun packed into a sphere smaller than Earth. Because white dwarfs are so small, they are faint even when hot, and they sit below and to the left of the main sequence on the H-R diagram.

Worked example: how dense is a white dwarf?

Estimate the average density of a white dwarf of 0.6 solar masses with Earth's radius, \(6.37 \times 10^{6}\) m. 1. Mass: \(M = 0.6 \times 1.99 \times 10^{30} = 1.19 \times 10^{30}\) kg. 2. Volume: \(V = \frac{4}{3}\pi R^3 = 1.08 \times 10^{21}\ \mathrm{m^3}\). 3. Density: \(\rho = \frac{M}{V} = 1.10 \times 10^{9}\ \mathrm{kg/m^3}\). 4. Compare: water is \(1000\ \mathrm{kg/m^3}\), so this is about 1.1 million times as dense. A 5 cm³ teaspoon of it would have a mass of about 5,500 kg, roughly an elephant. 5. Check: the Sun averages about \(1400\ \mathrm{kg/m^3}\); squeezing over half its mass into about a millionth of its volume should raise that nearly a millionfold, as found.

Heavier means smaller

In the early 1930s the young Indian physicist Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar worked out the structure of white dwarfs and found a surprise: the more massive a white dwarf is, the smaller it is. Extra mass squeezes the electrons harder, and they can only resist by moving faster, until they approach the speed of light. At about 1.4 solar masses the calculation gives a radius of zero, meaning no balance is possible. This maximum mass for a white dwarf is the Chandrasekhar limit. The leading astronomer Arthur Eddington publicly rejected the idea, but Chandrasekhar was right. He shared the 1983 Nobel Prize in Physics, and NASA's Chandra X-ray Observatory, launched in 1999, is named after him.

Worked example: how much mass did it lose?

A young cluster still has main-sequence stars of 5 solar masses, yet it also contains a white dwarf of 0.9 solar masses. What can we conclude? 1. The cluster's stars all formed at about the same time. 2. Massive stars evolve fastest, so only stars born heavier than 5 solar masses have had time to die. 3. The white dwarf's parent star therefore began with more than 5 solar masses. 4. It now has 0.9, so it lost at least \(5 - 0.9 = 4.1\) solar masses, over 80% of its starting mass. 5. Check: the white dwarf is below the 1.4 limit, as it must be. Surveys of such clusters suggest stars of up to about 8 solar masses end as white dwarfs.

Cooling into darkness

A white dwarf shines only by leaking stored heat. On the H-R diagram the exposed core first moves left, then slides down and to the right, growing cooler and fainter at a nearly constant radius. As it cools, its carbon and oxygen nuclei are predicted to lock into a crystal lattice. In 2019 data from the Gaia spacecraft showed a pile-up of white dwarfs at the temperatures where crystallisation should release extra heat and slow their cooling, strong evidence that it happens. A fully cooled remnant, a black dwarf, would be invisible. None should exist yet: cooling that far takes much longer than the universe's age of about 13.8 billion years.

The Sun's last stage

The Sun will follow exactly this path. Models suggest it will lose roughly half its mass during its red-giant stages, leaving a white dwarf of a little over half a solar mass, about the size of Earth. For a few tens of thousands of years its exposed core will light a planetary nebula; then the gas will disperse, and the white dwarf will cool for many billions of years. It will never explode, never become a neutron star and never become a black hole: it is far too light for any of those fates.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking a white dwarf still fuses hydrogen or helium: it shines only from stored heat. Second, applying the 1.4 limit to a star's birth mass: it applies to the mass left at the end, and stars born with up to about 8 solar masses can get below it. Third, assuming a heavier white dwarf is bigger: it is smaller. Fourth, thinking cooling makes a white dwarf shrink: degeneracy pressure does not depend on temperature. Fifth, believing black dwarfs have been observed: the universe is too young for any to exist.

Key takeaways

Stars ending below about 1.4 solar masses, including most stars born with up to about 8, become white dwarfs. With no fusion, the core contracts until degenerate electrons, obeying the Pauli exclusion principle, halt it. A white dwarf holds about 0.6 solar masses in an Earth-sized ball, about a million times as dense as water. More massive white dwarfs are smaller, and none can exceed the Chandrasekhar limit of about 1.4 solar masses. White dwarfs cool, crystallise and, after far longer than 13.8 billion years, will become black dwarfs. The Sun will end as a white dwarf.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Solar mass, M☉

About 1.99 × 10³⁰ kg

The standard unit for star masses.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which of these white dwarfs has the smallest radius?

Question 2 of 5

What stops a white dwarf from collapsing further under its own gravity?

Question 3 of 5

A young cluster holds main-sequence stars of 6 solar masses and a white dwarf of 1.0 solar mass. At least how much mass did the white dwarf's parent star lose?

Question 4 of 5

Why have no black dwarfs ever been observed?

Question 5 of 5

A star is born with 4 solar masses and ends its fuel-burning life with 0.8 solar masses. What will it become?

← Previous topicNext topic →