Astronomy › Section H · The Moon, Mercury, Venus, and Mars › Topic H.3

The origin of the Moon

Where did the Moon come from? It is one of the best-studied objects in the sky, yet its birth is still argued over. Seeing how scientists test competing ideas against the evidence is as valuable as the answer itself.

A puzzle with plenty of clues

In most of astronomy the problem is too little data. For the Moon it is the opposite: hundreds of kilograms of samples, seismic records, gravity maps and decades of orbital surveys. Any explanation of its origin has to fit all of that at once. The trouble is that the Moon is both strikingly like Earth and strikingly different from it. Before Apollo, three broad ideas competed. The samples ruled them out one by one, and a fourth idea, a giant collision, has led since the 1980s, though its details are far from settled.

What any theory must explain

Six clues come from earlier topics and from the samples. 1. Low density: about 3.35 g/cm³, with only a small iron core. 2. Few volatiles: the Moon is short of water and other easily evaporated substances, a sign of strong heating. 3. Matching isotopes: the mix of oxygen isotopes (atoms of the same element with different numbers of neutrons) in lunar rock is almost identical to Earth's, while meteorites from elsewhere differ. Several other elements match closely too. 4. A molten start: the highland crust formed from a magma ocean. 5. Size: the Moon is unusually large for its planet. 6. Spin: the Earth-Moon system holds a large amount of angular momentum, the spin of Earth plus the orbital motion of the Moon.

Worked example: how big is our Moon?

Compare each moon's mass with its planet's. 1. Moon and Earth: \(\frac{7.35 \times 10^{22}}{5.97 \times 10^{24}} = 0.0123\). 2. Titan and Saturn: \(\frac{1.35 \times 10^{23}}{5.68 \times 10^{26}} = 2.38 \times 10^{-4}\). 3. Ganymede and Jupiter: \(\frac{1.48 \times 10^{23}}{1.90 \times 10^{27}} = 7.80 \times 10^{-5}\). 4. Compare: our Moon is about 52 times larger, relative to its planet, than Titan is relative to Saturn. 5. Interpret: the giant planets' large moons are tiny compared with their hosts, as expected if they formed in discs around those planets. Our Moon is far too big for that story, which hints at an unusual origin. (Among dwarf planets, Pluto's moon Charon is even larger relative to Pluto, and it too is thought to come from a collision.)

Three older ideas

The fission hypothesis, proposed in the late nineteenth century by George Darwin, son of Charles Darwin, said a rapidly spinning young Earth flung off a blob of its mantle. The sister, or co-formation, hypothesis said the Moon assembled alongside Earth from the same cloud of rock, as the giant planets' moons seem to have formed. The capture hypothesis said the Moon was built in some other part of the solar system and only later caught by Earth's gravity. Each one explains some clues, which is why each had serious supporters before the Apollo samples arrived.

Why they fail

Capture is the hardest to defend. A body falling past Earth arrives fast enough to escape again unless something removes a lot of its energy, and a captured moon would most likely end up in a very elongated orbit. It also fails the isotope test, since a body from elsewhere should have a different oxygen mix. Fission fails on physics: calculations show Earth could never have spun fast enough to split, and a piece of Earth should not be so short of volatiles. Co-formation cannot explain why the Moon has so little iron, since it would have formed from the same mix of metal and rock as Earth.

The giant impact hypothesis

In the mid-1970s, two research teams, William Hartmann with Donald Davis, and Alastair Cameron with William Ward, independently proposed a collision. In today's standard version, about 4.5 billion years ago the young Earth was struck a glancing blow by a body roughly the size of Mars, about a tenth of Earth's mass, often called Theia. The impact melted and partly vaporised both bodies. The two iron cores largely merged into Earth, while a disc of hot debris, mostly from the rocky mantles, spread into orbit. The Moon then gathered from that disc, quickly by geological standards.

What the collision explains

The giant impact fits most of the clues at once. The debris came mainly from mantles, so the Moon is short of iron and has only a small core. The disc was extremely hot, so volatiles boiled away. A Moon assembled quickly from hot material would start with a magma ocean. A glancing blow from a large body naturally gives the system its high angular momentum and makes a large moon. And if Earth's mantle supplied much of the debris, or the debris mixed well with it, the Moon's rocks would resemble Earth's; whether the impact really did this is the main open question. Computer simulations since the 1980s show that such an impact is physically possible, and large collisions were common while the planets were forming.

Worked example: scoring the hypotheses

Check each idea against three key clues: low iron, few volatiles, Earth-like isotopes. 1. Capture: a body from elsewhere could be low in iron, but there is no reason for it to share Earth's isotopes. Fails on isotopes. 2. Co-formation: it would share Earth's isotopes but also its proportion of iron. Fails on iron. 3. Fission: Earth-like isotopes and mantle-like, low-iron rock fit, but the volatile loss and the impossible spin do not. Fails on volatiles and physics. 4. Giant impact: mantle debris explains low iron, intense heat explains lost volatiles, and material shared or mixed with Earth's mantle can explain the isotope match, though how is debated. 5. Conclusion: only the giant impact can pass all three, which is why it leads, but passing a test is not the same as being proved.

What is still debated

The isotope match is almost too good. In the standard model most of the disc comes from Theia, which should have had a somewhat different composition, yet lunar and terrestrial rocks are nearly identical in oxygen and several other isotopes. Researchers are testing variants: a faster, more energetic impact on a rapidly spinning Earth, an impact that left a vast cloud of mixed vapour in which the Moon condensed, a series of smaller impacts, or a Theia that formed close to Earth with a similar make-up. The exact timing, somewhere in roughly the first 150 million years of the solar system, is also disputed. Some researchers have even suggested that remnants of Theia survive deep in Earth's mantle, an idea still under test.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling the giant impact "proven": it is the leading hypothesis, but its details are actively debated. Second, thinking the Moon is simply a chunk of Earth: it is short of iron and volatiles, and some of its material may come from the impactor. Third, imagining a small rock hitting Earth: the impactor was planet-sized, roughly as massive as Mars. Fourth, assuming capture is easy: a passing body needs to lose a lot of energy to stay in orbit.

Key takeaways

A theory of the Moon's origin must explain its low iron, missing volatiles, Earth-like isotopes, molten start, large size relative to Earth and the system's high angular momentum. Fission, co-formation and capture each fail at least one test. The giant impact hypothesis, proposed in the mid-1970s, says a Mars-sized body struck the young Earth about 4.5 billion years ago and the Moon formed from mostly mantle debris. It fits most clues and leads today, but the near-perfect isotope match, the impact's details and its timing are still being worked out.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Fission hypothesis

A fast-spinning Earth threw off the Moon

Fails: Earth could not spin fast enough.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which piece of evidence most strongly rules out the capture hypothesis?

Question 2 of 5

How does the giant impact hypothesis explain the Moon's lack of iron?

Question 3 of 5

The mass ratio of the Moon to Earth is 0.0123, and that of Titan to Saturn is about 2.38 × 10⁻⁴. Roughly how many times larger is the Moon's ratio?

Question 4 of 5

Which statement best describes the scientific status of the giant impact hypothesis today?

Question 5 of 5

Why does the co-formation (sister) hypothesis fail?

← Previous topicNext topic →