Astronomy › Section J · Small bodies and the origin of the solar system › Topic J.6

Other planetary systems and planetary evolution

Until the 1990s our solar system was the only planetary system we knew, so it was easy to assume it was typical. Thousands of planets around other stars have shown otherwise, and comparing worlds, here and elsewhere, shows how size, distance and chemistry steer each planet's later history.

Discs around young stars

If planets form in spinning discs, as "Formation of the solar system" described, we should see such discs around young stars today, and we do. The Hubble Space Telescope photographed dark, dusty discs seen edge-on in the Orion Nebula. In 2014 the Atacama Large Millimeter/submillimeter Array (ALMA) in Chile imaged the disc around HL Tauri, a star only about a million years old. It showed bright rings separated by dark gaps, widely interpreted as lanes cleared by young planets, which would mean planets start forming within the first million years. These discs are explored further in "Evidence of planets forming around other stars".

Finding planets indirectly

A planet is billions of times fainter than its star and lost in its glare, so most exoplanets, planets orbiting other stars, are found by their effect on the star. In the Doppler method, a planet's gravity makes its star wobble, and the star's spectral lines shift back and forth as it moves towards and away from us. In the transit method, a planet passing in front of its star blocks a little of its light at regular intervals; a Jupiter-sized planet dims a Sun-like star by about 1%, an Earth-sized one by under 0.01%, which is why big planets were found first. NASA's Kepler telescope used transits to monitor about 150,000 stars from 2009 to 2018, and TESS continues the search. As of 15 October 2026, the NASA Exoplanet Archive listed 6,451 confirmed exoplanets. The methods are covered in depth in "Searching for planets beyond the solar system".

Systems unlike ours

The first planet found around a Sun-like star, 51 Pegasi b, reported by Michel Mayor and Didier Queloz in 1995, was a shock: a planet with a minimum mass of about half Jupiter's circling its star every 4.2 days, far closer than Mercury is to the Sun. Such hot Jupiters turned out to orbit only about 1% of Sun-like stars, but they are easy to detect. Many exoplanets also have very elongated orbits, unlike the near-circles of our planets. The most common planets found are sizes our system lacks: super-Earths and sub-Neptunes, between Earth and Neptune in size. Correcting for the bias towards big, close planets, astronomers estimate that most stars have planets and that small planets are common.

Planets on the move

Hot Jupiters forced a rethink. A giant planet needs a large icy core, and ice cannot exist so close to a star, so these giants probably formed farther out and moved inwards, a process called migration. While the disc's gas remained, a planet could exchange angular momentum with it and spiral inwards; why some stopped short of the star is still debated. Later, close encounters between planets could fling one inwards or outwards and stretch orbits into long ellipses. The basic idea that planets form in discs has survived, but the solar system's tidy arrangement now looks like one outcome among many. "What exoplanets teach us about planet formation" takes this further.

Size decides how long a world stays active

Back home, once the giant impacts ended, each world followed its own path. Geological activity, such as volcanoes and moving crust, needs internal heat, left from formation or released by radioactive decay. A planet stores heat in its volume, which grows as \(R^3\), but loses it through its surface, which grows as \(R^2\). So the surface-to-volume ratio, \(3/R\), is larger for small worlds, and they cool faster, like a small baked potato. The Moon's major volcanism ended about 3 billion years ago, with small eruptions until about 2 billion years ago, while Earth's plates still move and Venus has been resurfaced within the last billion years. Tidal heating, as on Io, is the main exception.

Worked example: why the Moon went quiet first

Compare how fast the Moon and Mars lose heat relative to Earth, using radii of 1,737 km for the Moon, 3,390 km for Mars and 6,371 km for Earth. Since the ratio is \(3/R\), the factor 3 cancels in a comparison. 1. Moon against Earth: \(6{,}371 \div 1{,}737 = 3.67\), so the Moon has 3.67 times Earth's surface per unit volume. 2. Mars against Earth: \(6{,}371 \div 3{,}390 = 1.88\). 3. Interpret: for the same make-up, the Moon sheds its stored heat several times faster than Earth, and Mars about twice as fast. 4. Check against the record: the Moon's volcanism faded billions of years ago, Mars stayed volcanic far longer but is nearly quiet today, and Earth is still active.

Worked example: why Mars has the tallest volcano

Rock can bear only so much weight before a mountain sags under itself, so the tallest possible mountain is roughly inversely proportional to surface gravity: \(h_{\max} \propto 1/g\). On Earth, volcanoes reach about 10 km above their base. Mars has surface gravity about 0.38 times Earth's. 1. Set up the ratio: \(h_{\mathrm{Mars}} = h_{\mathrm{Earth}} \times \frac{g_{\mathrm{Earth}}}{g_{\mathrm{Mars}}}\). 2. Substitute: \(10\ \mathrm{km} \div 0.38 = 26\) km. 3. Compare: Olympus Mons stands about 22 km high, within this limit. 4. Second factor: Mars has no moving plates, so one volcano could sit over its hot source for hundreds of millions of years, while Earth's moving crust builds chains like Hawaii instead of one giant peak.

Three atmospheres from one start

The rocky planets gained atmospheres from gas released by volcanoes and from volatile-rich impactors, so Venus, Earth and Mars probably began with broadly similar gases. Sunlight split hydrogen-bearing molecules, and the light hydrogen escaped. Their paths then split, as "Why the rocky planets diverged" explains. Venus, closer to the Sun, suffered a runaway greenhouse effect and lost its water. Mars, small and cold, lost much of its air and its liquid water froze or vanished. Both now have atmospheres of roughly 95 to 97% carbon dioxide. On Earth, oceans dissolved carbon dioxide and locked it into carbonate rocks, and photosynthetic life filled the air with oxygen, leaving mostly nitrogen and oxygen.

Where could life exist?

The search for habitable places has focused on liquid water. Earth has surface oceans. Mars once had rivers and lakes and may hold water underground today. Europa and Enceladus have oceans beneath ice shells, and Enceladus vents water into space through cracks near its south pole. Saturn's moon Titan, the only moon with a thick atmosphere, mostly nitrogen, is far too cold for liquid water but has lakes of liquid methane and ethane. No life has been found beyond Earth. The same questions now extend to exoplanets, where astronomers look for rocky planets at distances from their stars where liquid water could exist on the surface.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming hot Jupiters formed where they are now; ice-poor inner regions could not build their cores, so they most likely migrated. Second, reading the known exoplanet list as a fair sample: big, close planets are easiest to find, so they are over-represented. Third, inverting the radius ratio when comparing surface-to-volume ratios: the smaller world has the larger ratio. Fourth, thinking a small world stays active as long as a large one; it cools faster because its surface-to-volume ratio is larger. Fifth, using a direct proportion for mountain height; lower gravity allows taller mountains.

Key takeaways

Discs and gapped rings around young stars such as HL Tauri support the disc theory of planet formation. Most exoplanets are found by the Doppler wobble or by transits, which favour big planets; as of October 2026 more than 6,400 are confirmed. Hot Jupiters, eccentric orbits and abundant super-Earths and sub-Neptunes show that planets migrate and that our system is one of many outcomes. At home, small worlds cool fastest because their surface-to-volume ratio, 3/R, is larger, low gravity allows tall volcanoes, and Venus, Earth and Mars turned similar starting atmospheres into very different ones.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Protoplanetary disc

Disc of gas and dust around a young star where planets form

Seen by Hubble in Orion and by ALMA.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Mercury's radius is 2,440 km and Earth's is 6,371 km. Using the surface-to-volume ratio 3/R, how does Mercury's ratio compare with Earth's?

Question 2 of 5

On Earth, volcanoes can rise about 10 km. Using h max ∝ 1/g, about how tall could they grow on a planet with half of Earth's surface gravity?

Question 3 of 5

Why do astronomers think hot Jupiters did not form where they orbit now?

Question 4 of 5

Two rocky worlds have the same composition, but one has twice the radius of the other. Which statement is correct?

Question 5 of 5

Why does Earth's atmosphere hold so little carbon dioxide compared with the atmosphere of Venus?

← Previous topicNext topic →