Astronomy › Section J · Small bodies and the origin of the solar system › Topic J.5
Formation of the solar system
Comets, asteroids and meteorites are the leftover pieces of a 4.6-billion-year-old building project. Put together with the planets themselves, they let us reconstruct, step by step, how a spinning cloud of gas and dust became the Sun and its family.
Clues a theory must explain
The topic "Origin of the solar system" introduced the solar nebula, the cloud from which the Sun and planets formed; here we test it against this section's evidence. Any successful theory has to pass three kinds of test, called constraints because they limit which explanations can survive. Motion constraints describe how the bodies move. Chemical constraints describe what they are made of and where. Age constraints describe when they formed. A good account must explain the exceptions as well as the regular patterns.
Motions, chemistry and ages
All eight planets orbit the Sun in the same direction, close to one plane, the same direction in which the Sun spins; most planets also rotate that way. The exceptions include Venus, which spins backwards, and Uranus, tipped on its side. Chemically, Jupiter and Saturn are mostly hydrogen and helium, like the Sun, while the solid bodies change with distance: metal-rich Mercury, rocky Earth and Mars, carbon-rich asteroids, then icy moons, Kuiper belt objects and comets. As for ages, the oldest meteorite grains are about 4.567 billion years old, and Moon rocks reach about 4.4 billion years, so the planets formed within the first few tens of millions of years.
The angular momentum puzzle
"Origin of the solar system" showed how the nebula, mostly hydrogen and helium with about 2% heavier elements, spun faster as it collapsed and flattened into a disc, so the planets inherited one direction and one plane. Angular momentum, the amount of rotation, sets a sharper test. For a body of mass \(m\) moving at speed \(v\) on a circle of radius \(r\), it is \(L = mvr\). A simple collapse would leave the young Sun spinning very fast and holding most of the system's angular momentum. Instead the Sun, with about 99.8% of the mass, turns only about once a month, and the planets carry most of the spin. Models suggest that magnetic fields and outflows braked the young Sun and moved angular momentum outwards.
Worked example: where did the spin go?
Compare Jupiter's orbital angular momentum with the Sun's spin angular momentum, about \(1.9 \times 10^{41}\) kg m²/s. Jupiter has mass \(1.90 \times 10^{27}\) kg and moves at 13.1 km/s at \(r = 7.78 \times 10^{11}\) m. 1. Treat the orbit as a circle: \(L = mvr\). 2. Substitute in SI units:
3. Ratio: \(1.94 \times 10^{43} \div 1.9 \times 10^{41} \approx 100\). 4. Interpret: Jupiter has about 0.1% of the Sun's mass but about 100 times its angular momentum, so a theory must explain how the young Sun lost its spin.
Condensation and the frost line
As the disc cooled, gases condensed into solid grains. Which solids formed depended on temperature, so on distance from the Sun. The first to condense, above about 1,300 K, were metals and rock-forming silicates, the only solids possible close to the Sun. Farther out, carbon-rich and water-bearing minerals joined them, as C-type asteroids in the outer belt show. Beyond the frost line, where the thin gas fell to about 150 K, water vapour froze into ice; as "Origin of the solar system" showed, it lay near 3 AU (one astronomical unit, the average Earth-Sun distance, is about \(1.496 \times 10^{11}\) m), shifting between about 2 and 5 AU as the disc evolved. Farther still, ices of methane and ammonia formed. Hydrogen and helium are about 98% of the nebula's mass but never freeze, so ice-rich regions had several times more solid material than rock-only regions.
Worked example: a short-lived heat source
Meteorites show that the young solar system held aluminium-26, a radioactive isotope with a half-life of about 0.72 million years, probably made in stars shortly before the Sun formed. Its decay heated planetesimals from inside. What fraction remained in a body that formed 3.0 million years after the first solids? 1. Number of half-lives: \(n = 3.0 \div 0.72 = 4.17\). 2. Fraction left: \(\left(\frac{1}{2}\right)^{4.17} = 0.056\), about 6%. 3. Compare: a body formed at the start had about 18 times as much of this heat source. 4. Interpret: planetesimals that formed within roughly the first million years could melt, like Vesta and the parents of iron meteorites, while later ones, such as the parents of chondrites, never melted. 5. Check: about four half-lives should leave about 1/16, or 6%.
Planetesimals and rocky planets
Grains stuck together into pebbles, and in ways still being researched these clumped into planetesimals, bodies about 1 km to a few hundred kilometres across. Once a planetesimal was big enough, its gravity pulled in its neighbours, a runaway growth called accretion. Within perhaps a million years, the inner disc held dozens of protoplanets roughly the size of the Moon or Mars. Collisions and radioactive decay released so much energy that they melted, letting iron sink to form cores, a process called differentiation. Over tens of millions of years, a few survivors swept up the rest and became Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars. Being small and hot, they kept little gas.
Building the giant planets
Beyond the frost line, plentiful ice let protoplanets grow faster and larger. The leading model, core accretion, says that once a solid core reached roughly 10 Earth masses, its gravity could capture the surrounding hydrogen and helium and grow rapidly into a giant. Jupiter and Saturn caught huge envelopes of gas, giving them a nearly Sun-like makeup. Uranus and Neptune, farther out where material was sparser, grew their cores more slowly and caught less gas before the young Sun's radiation and winds cleared the disc, within about 10 million years and often only a few. Some astronomers argue that giants can also form directly from a collapsing clump of the disc, an idea called disc instability.
Clearing up the leftovers
Many planetesimals were never built into planets. The giant planets' gravity threw icy ones outwards to form the Oort cloud or scattered them into the Kuiper belt, while those between Mars and Jupiter were stirred too much to merge, leaving the asteroid belt. Giant impacts shaped the inner worlds: one probably formed the Moon, and others may have stripped part of Mercury's mantle. Earth's water was probably delivered by water-rich bodies from farther out, likely asteroids more than comets, although the details remain debated.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking the frost line is a fixed modern boundary: it moved as the disc cooled. Second, saying planets orbit the same way because of the Sun's magnetic field or gravity alone; it is because they formed from one spinning disc. Third, expecting the Sun to hold most of the angular momentum because it holds most of the mass; the planets carry most of it. Fourth, treating every detail as settled: how pebbles become planetesimals, how fast giants formed and how much the planets migrated are still active research. Fifth, believing hydrogen and helium formed solid cores; they never froze, which is why ice mattered so much.
Key takeaways
A formation theory must explain motions, chemistry and ages, including exceptions. A collapsing nebula spun up and flattened into a disc, so the planets share one direction and plane, yet the slowly spinning Sun has far less angular momentum, \(L = mvr\), than Jupiter's orbit. Solids condensed by temperature: metals and rock everywhere, ice only beyond the frost line, near 3 AU but shifting between about 2 and 5 AU. Grains became planetesimals, early ones melted by aluminium-26, then protoplanets; rocky planets grew by accretion and giant impacts, while icy cores of about 10 Earth masses captured gas to make giants. Leftovers survive as asteroids, Kuiper belt objects and Oort cloud comets, and meteorites date the start to about 4.567 billion years ago.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Motion, chemical and age evidence a theory must explain
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Saturn has a mass of 5.68 × 10²⁶ kg and orbits at 9.68 km/s at a distance of 1.43 × 10¹² m. Using L = mvr, what is its orbital angular momentum?
Question 2 of 5
Aluminium-26 has a half-life of about 0.72 million years. What fraction of its original aluminium-26 did a planetesimal still hold if it formed 2.9 million years after the first solids, about four half-lives?
Question 3 of 5
Why did giant planets form in the outer solar system and small rocky planets in the inner part?
Question 4 of 5
Which observation is best explained by the planets forming in a single spinning disc?
Question 5 of 5
Why do Uranus and Neptune contain much less hydrogen and helium than Jupiter and Saturn?
