Astronomy › Section K · The Sun › Topic K.6
The solar interior: theory and observation
No telescope can see into the Sun, yet astronomers can describe its core in detail. Physics tells them what the interior must be like, and two clever probes, the Sun's own vibrations and the neutrinos from its core, test that picture.
Seeing what cannot be seen
Sunlight leaves from the photosphere, so the interior is hidden. Astronomers therefore build a solar model: a computer calculation that applies the laws of physics, layer by layer, to a ball of gas with the Sun's measured mass, radius, luminosity, composition and age. It predicts the temperature, pressure, density and energy production at every depth. Two kinds of observation then check the model directly: helioseismology, which reads the Sun's vibrations, and neutrino detectors, which catch particles made in the core itself.
Balanced against its own weight
The Sun's gas is a plasma that behaves like an ideal gas: its pressure rises with both density and temperature. Gravity pulls every layer inward, and the pressure of the hotter, denser gas beneath pushes it outward. Because the Sun is neither shrinking nor swelling, these two balance at every depth, a state called hydrostatic equilibrium. The balance is self-correcting: if the core's pressure dropped, the Sun would contract slightly, heating the gas until the pressure recovered. Working inward with this balance, models find the centre must be at about 15 million K to support the weight above it.
Why the Sun is not cooling down
Heat always flows from hotter places to cooler ones, and energy streams out of the Sun at every moment. So the temperature must fall from the centre outward through the interior. (The hot corona is an exception powered by magnetic fields, not by heat flowing up from below.) If nothing replaced the energy lost, the Sun would cool and contract. Since it has shone steadily for billions of years, the escaping energy must be replenished at the centre at the same rate. The models show that fusion of hydrogen in the core supplies exactly that, and that nearly all of it happens within about the inner quarter of the radius.
Moving energy outward
Energy can travel by conduction (collisions between neighbouring particles), convection (rising and sinking currents of fluid) or radiation (photons). Conduction is negligible in the Sun. Out to about 70% of the radius, energy travels as radiation, but the gas is so opaque that a photon goes only a tiny distance, of order a millimetre to a centimetre, before being absorbed and re-emitted in a random direction. This random walk is painfully slow. In the outer 30%, the gas is cooler and more opaque still, and convection takes over: hot blobs rise, release energy and sink, ending in the granules seen at the surface.
Worked example: photons versus neutrinos
Energy made in the core takes, by model estimates, roughly 100,000 to a million years to random-walk out. A neutrino barely interacts, so it flies straight out at nearly the speed of light. 1. Neutrino escape time: \(t = \frac{R}{c} = \frac{6.96 \times 10^8\ \mathrm{m}}{3.00 \times 10^8\ \mathrm{m/s}} \approx 2.32\) s. 2. Lower photon estimate in seconds: \(10^5 \times 3.156 \times 10^7 \approx 3.16 \times 10^{12}\) s. 3. Ratio: \(\frac{3.16 \times 10^{12}}{2.32} \approx 1.4 \times 10^{12}\). 4. Add the trip to Earth: \(\frac{1.496 \times 10^{11}}{3.00 \times 10^8} \approx 499\) s, so core neutrinos arrive about 8.4 minutes after they form. Neutrinos report on the core today; sunlight reports on it as it was long ago.
The standard solar model
Putting the physics together gives the standard solar model. At the centre the temperature is about 15 million K and the density is about 150 times that of water. The core, out to about a quarter of the radius, produces almost all the energy. Because fusion has run there for about 4.6 billion years, the gas at the very centre is now roughly a third hydrogen by mass, against about 73% at the surface. Beyond the core comes the radiative zone, then, from about 70% of the radius to the photosphere, the convection zone, roughly 200,000 km deep.
Helioseismology: the Sun rings like a bell
Patches of the Sun's surface, thousands of kilometres across, rise and fall by roughly 10 to 20 km, with speeds of a few hundred metres per second, repeating about every 5 minutes. Doppler shifts reveal these motions, and they are caused by sound waves bouncing around inside the Sun, much as earthquake waves reveal Earth's interior. Analysing millions of such vibrations shows that the convection zone starts at about 71% of the radius, that differential rotation continues through it, and that the radiative interior turns almost like a solid body, all in close agreement with the standard model. Sound waves can even reveal active regions on the Sun's far side.
Worked example: how many solar neutrinos?
Each run of the proton-proton chain releases about 26.7 MeV, or \(4.28 \times 10^{-12}\) J, and makes 2 neutrinos. Assuming all of L☉ comes from this chain, how many neutrinos cross each square metre at Earth every second? 1. Chains per second: \(\frac{3.83 \times 10^{26}}{4.28 \times 10^{-12}} \approx 8.95 \times 10^{37}\). 2. Neutrinos per second: \(2 \times 8.95 \times 10^{37} \approx 1.79 \times 10^{38}\). 3. They spread over a sphere of radius 1 AU: \(4\pi (1.496 \times 10^{11})^2 \approx 2.81 \times 10^{23}\) m². 4. Flux: \(\frac{1.79 \times 10^{38}}{2.81 \times 10^{23}} \approx 6.4 \times 10^{14}\) per m² per second. 5. Check: per square centimetre, about the size of a fingernail, that is about 64 billion each second, day and night, since they pass straight through Earth.
The solar neutrino problem
Catching even a few neutrinos needs a huge target deep underground, shielded from cosmic rays. From the late 1960s, Raymond Davis Jr. ran a tank holding about 380,000 litres of a chlorine-rich cleaning fluid 1.5 km down the Homestake gold mine in South Dakota. Now and then a neutrino turned a chlorine atom into radioactive argon, which his team extracted and counted, a few atoms a week. For decades they found only about a third of the predicted number, so either the solar model or neutrino physics had to be wrong. Davis shared the 2002 Nobel Prize in Physics with Masatoshi Koshiba.
Solved: neutrinos change type
Neutrinos come in three types, and fusion makes only electron neutrinos, the type the early detectors could see. In 1998 Japan's Super-Kamiokande detector found that neutrinos made in Earth's atmosphere change type in flight, which is possible only if neutrinos have mass. In 2001-2002 the Sudbury Neutrino Observatory in Canada, with about 1000 tonnes of heavy water 2 km underground, counted all three types: the total matched the solar model, but only about a third arrived as electron neutrinos. Takaaki Kajita and Arthur McDonald shared the 2015 Nobel Prize for showing neutrino oscillation. Italy's Borexino detector later measured neutrinos from the first proton-proton step (2014) and from the CNO cycle (2020).
Common mistakes to avoid
First, believing sunlight's energy left the core moments ago: it took roughly 100,000 years or more. Second, thinking the solar neutrino problem showed the Sun's model was wrong: the model was right, and neutrinos change type. Third, placing convection at the centre of the Sun: in the Sun it fills the outer 30% of the radius. Fourth, forgetting that helioseismology uses sound waves, not light, to probe the interior.
Key takeaways
Solar models treat the Sun as plasma in hydrostatic equilibrium, with pressure balancing gravity at every depth and a centre near 15 million K. Energy flows out by radiation to about 70% of the radius, then by convection, taking roughly 100,000 years or more. Helioseismology's 5-minute oscillations map the interior and confirm the model. About 6.4 × 10¹⁴ solar neutrinos cross each square metre at Earth every second; Davis's shortfall was explained by neutrino oscillation, which shows neutrinos have mass.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Calculation of conditions at every depth from the laws of physics
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
What does hydrostatic equilibrium mean for the Sun?
Question 2 of 5
Why does energy made in the Sun's core take roughly 100,000 years or more to reach the surface?
Question 3 of 5
Which finding comes from helioseismology?
Question 4 of 5
Davis's Homestake experiment detected only about a third of the predicted solar neutrinos. What was the explanation?
Question 5 of 5
A neutrino is made at the centre of the Sun. About how long after its creation does it reach Earth?
