Astronomy › Section K · The Sun › Topic K.5
Sources of sunshine and mass-energy
The Sun has poured out energy at a ferocious rate for about 4.6 billion years. Burning and shrinking both fall far short of explaining that, and the true answer, fusing hydrogen into helium and turning a little mass into energy, took the physics of the twentieth century to find.
The puzzle of sunshine
Power is energy per second, measured in watts: 1 W = 1 J/s. The Sun's power output, its luminosity, is L☉ ≈ \(3.83 \times 10^{26}\) W, enough in one second to supply humanity's present energy use for several hundred thousand years. Rocks and meteorites show that the solar system is about 4.6 billion years old, and Earth has had liquid water for most of that time, so the Sun has shone at roughly this rate for billions of years. Energy is never created or destroyed, only converted from one form to another. So what store of energy is large enough?
Worked example: a Sun made of coal
Nineteenth-century scientists first considered chemical energy. Suppose the whole Sun were coal, which releases about \(3 \times 10^7\) J per kilogram when burned (ignoring the oxygen it would also need). How long could it shine? 1. Total energy: \(E = (1.99 \times 10^{30}\ \mathrm{kg})(3 \times 10^7\ \mathrm{J/kg}) \approx 5.97 \times 10^{37}\) J. 2. Time: \(t = \frac{E}{L} = \frac{5.97 \times 10^{37}}{3.83 \times 10^{26}} \approx 1.56 \times 10^{11}\) s. 3. In years: \(\frac{1.56 \times 10^{11}}{3.156 \times 10^7} \approx 4900\) years. 4. Conclusion: a chemical Sun would burn out in about 5000 years, nearly a million times too soon. Besides, nothing solid survives at the Sun's temperatures.
Gravity: a better but still too short answer
Meteorites falling into the Sun were also rejected: the infall needed would add mass fast enough to change Earth's orbit measurably. In the mid-1800s, Hermann von Helmholtz and William Thomson (Lord Kelvin) proposed that the Sun shines by slowly contracting. As gas falls inward, gravitational energy becomes heat. An order-of-magnitude estimate of that store is \(\frac{GM^2}{R} \approx 3.8 \times 10^{41}\) J, which at the present luminosity lasts only a few tens of millions of years. Geologists and, later, radioactive dating showed that Earth is far older. Contraction does power newborn stars for a while, as "Star formation" describes, but it cannot run the Sun today.
Mass is a form of energy
The solution came from Albert Einstein's special relativity of 1905, which showed that mass and energy are equivalent:
Here \(c = 3.00 \times 10^8\) m/s is the speed of light. Nothing needs to move at that speed; \(c^2\) is simply the conversion factor between kilograms and joules, and it is huge. Converting 1 kg of mass entirely into energy would give \(1 \times (3.00 \times 10^8)^2 = 9.00 \times 10^{16}\) J. The formula says how much energy corresponds to a given mass; it does not say how to release it. That needed nuclear physics.
Worked example: how much mass does the Sun lose each second?
What mass must vanish every second to supply the Sun's luminosity? 1. Rearrange: \(m = \frac{E}{c^2}\), with E the energy emitted in one second, \(3.83 \times 10^{26}\) J. 2. Substitute: \(m = \frac{3.83 \times 10^{26}}{(3.00 \times 10^8)^2} = \frac{3.83 \times 10^{26}}{9.00 \times 10^{16}}\). 3. Result: \(m \approx 4.26 \times 10^9\) kg, about 4.3 million tonnes every second. 4. Check the scale: over 4.6 billion years, about \(1.45 \times 10^{17}\) s, that is about \(6 \times 10^{26}\) kg, only about 0.03% of the Sun's mass. The Sun can afford it.
The particles involved
Atoms contain protons (positive), neutrons (neutral) and electrons (negative); see "The structure of the atom". Every particle has an antiparticle of opposite charge. The positron is the electron's antiparticle, and when the two meet they annihilate into gamma-ray photons. The neutrino, proposed by Wolfgang Pauli in 1930 to account for energy missing from radioactive decays, was first detected in 1956. Neutrinos have no charge and barely interact with matter, passing almost freely through the whole Sun. They come in three types and have a tiny mass, far smaller than an electron's.
Binding energy and fusion
Inside a nucleus, protons and neutrons are held together by the strong nuclear force, which is far stronger than the electric repulsion between protons but acts only over distances about the size of a nucleus. When particles bind into a nucleus, energy is released, so the nucleus has slightly less mass than its separate parts. Binding is strongest for nuclei near iron. So joining light nuclei into heavier ones, fusion, releases energy, as does splitting very heavy nuclei into lighter ones, fission. Stars are mostly hydrogen, so fusion is their fuel.
Getting protons close enough
Two protons repel each other electrically, and they must come almost into contact before the strong force can take over. Only extreme heat makes them move fast enough, which is why fusion is confined to the core, where the temperature is about 15 million K. Even there, a typical proton's energy is not enough to overcome the repulsion completely; quantum tunnelling lets a lucky few slip through. Fusion is so improbable that an average proton in the core waits billions of years before it fuses, which is exactly why the Sun burns slowly and steadily rather than exploding.
The proton-proton chain
In the Sun, most energy comes from the proton-proton chain. The superscript gives the number of protons plus neutrons:
The first two steps must each happen twice to make the two helium-3 nuclei. Net result: four hydrogen nuclei become one helium-4 nucleus, two positrons, two neutrinos and gamma rays. In stars more than about 1.3 times the Sun's mass, the CNO cycle, using carbon, nitrogen and oxygen nuclei as catalysts, takes over; in the Sun it supplies only about 1% of the energy.
Worked example: energy from hydrogen fusion
Atomic masses: hydrogen 1.007825 u, helium-4 4.002603 u, where 1 u ≈ \(1.66 \times 10^{-27}\) kg. 1. Mass in: \(4 \times 1.007825 = 4.031300\) u. 2. Mass lost: \(4.031300 - 4.002603 = 0.028697\) u. 3. Fraction lost: \(\frac{0.028697}{4.031300} \approx 0.00712\), or 0.712%. 4. Energy per kilogram of hydrogen fused: \(0.00712 \times 9.00 \times 10^{16} \approx 6.41 \times 10^{14}\) J. 5. Hydrogen fused per second: \(\frac{3.83 \times 10^{26}}{6.41 \times 10^{14}} \approx 5.98 \times 10^{11}\) kg, about 600 million tonnes. 6. Check: 0.712% of that is \(4.26 \times 10^9\) kg, matching the mass loss found earlier. If about a tenth of the Sun's mass can fuse, it lasts about 10 billion years.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying the Sun converts 600 million tonnes of mass into energy each second: that is the hydrogen fused; only about 0.7% of it, about 4.3 million tonnes, becomes energy. Second, thinking E = mc² means mass must travel at light speed. Third, calling the Sun a burning fire: chemical burning would last only thousands of years. Fourth, forgetting that the first two steps of the proton-proton chain each happen twice. Fifth, assuming fusion happens throughout the Sun: it is confined to the hot core.
Key takeaways
The Sun's luminosity of 3.83 × 10²⁶ W over about 4.6 billion years rules out chemical burning (about 5000 years) and gravitational contraction (tens of millions of years). By E = mc², the Sun turns about 4.3 million tonnes of mass into energy each second. Hot protons in the core, helped by quantum tunnelling, fuse in the proton-proton chain: four hydrogen nuclei make one helium-4 nucleus, two positrons and two neutrinos, and 0.712% of the mass is released as energy. About 600 million tonnes of hydrogen fuse each second, enough for a lifetime of about 10 billion years.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A watt is one joule of energy per second
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Using L☉ = 3.83 × 10²⁶ W and c = 3.00 × 10⁸ m/s, how much mass does the Sun convert into energy each second?
Question 2 of 5
Why did Kelvin and Helmholtz's idea that the Sun shines by contracting fail?
Question 3 of 5
In the proton-proton chain, what does the net reaction produce from four hydrogen nuclei?
Question 4 of 5
A star fuses 2.00 × 10¹² kg of hydrogen into helium each second, converting 0.712% of that mass into energy. What is its luminosity?
Question 5 of 5
Why is fusion in the Sun confined to its core?
