Astronomy › Section P · Stars from adolescence to old age › Topic P.2
Star clusters
No one can watch a single star age, but a star cluster gives us hundreds or millions of stars born together. Because they share a birthday, a cluster is a ready-made experiment in how mass shapes a star's life.
Nature's laboratories
A star cluster is a group of stars held together, at least for a while, by their mutual gravity. Its stars formed from the same cloud at nearly the same time, so they share an age and a chemical composition. They are also all at almost the same distance from us. The one big difference between them is mass, and mass sets how fast a star evolves. So a single cluster shows stars of many masses frozen at one age, and clusters of different ages show what happens as time passes. Astronomers recognise three main kinds: globular clusters, open clusters and associations.
Same distance, fair comparison
Shared distance makes clusters easy to compare. For stars scattered across the sky, a star might look bright because it is luminous or simply because it is close. Inside one cluster that ambiguity disappears. If one member looks 100 times brighter than another, it really is about 100 times more luminous, since both are the same distance away and their light is dimmed equally by any dust in between. Plotting brightness against colour for cluster members therefore gives the shape of an H-R diagram directly, even before the cluster's distance is known. That shortcut is why clusters were among the first tests of stellar evolution theory.
Globular clusters
Globular clusters are dense, nearly spherical swarms of tens of thousands to a few million stars, roughly 50 to 450 light-years across. (A light-year, ly, is the distance light travels in a year, about \(9.46 \times 10^{15}\) m.) About 150 to 170 are known in the Milky Way. They lie in the spherical halo around the galaxy's disc and in its central bulge, often tens of thousands of light-years from the disc. All are very old, more than 10 billion years, and their stars are poor in elements heavier than helium. The largest, Omega Centauri, about 17,000 light-years away, holds several million stars; some astronomers think it is the core of a small galaxy the Milky Way swallowed.
Life in a crowd
Near the centre of a globular cluster, stars are packed far more tightly than around the Sun. A planet there would see many stars far brighter than any in our night sky, with the nearest ones light-weeks or light-months away, though still points of light. Close encounters between stars are frequent by stellar standards, and they can swap partners in binary systems or even cause collisions. The brightest members of a globular cluster are red and orange giants, not blue stars, a clue to their great age that the next topic, "Checking stellar evolution against clusters", explains.
Worked example: how crowded is a globular cluster?
Suppose 100,000 stars fill a sphere of radius 10 ly at a cluster's centre. How far apart are neighbouring stars? 1. Volume: \(V = \frac{4}{3}\pi r^3 = \frac{4}{3}\pi (10)^3 = 4{,}190\) cubic light-years. 2. Number density: \(n = \frac{100{,}000}{4{,}190} = 24\) stars per cubic light-year. 3. Each star has about \(\frac{1}{n}\) of a cubic light-year to itself, so a typical spacing is \(n^{-1/3} = 24^{-1/3} = 0.35\) ly. 4. Compare: the Sun's nearest neighbour, Proxima Centauri, is 4.2 ly away, 12 times farther. 5. Interpret: being 12 times closer in each direction means about \(12^3 \approx 1{,}700\) times as many stars in the same volume.
Open clusters
Open clusters lie in the disc of the galaxy, mostly near the spiral arms. Membership runs from dozens of stars up to several thousand, spread loosely over less than about 30 light-years. The galaxy holds thousands, but dust in the disc hides most of the distant ones. Their ages range from a few million years to several billion. The Pleiades, in Taurus, about 440 light-years away and roughly 100 million years old, shows six or seven stars to the unaided eye and hundreds in a telescope. The Hyades, also in Taurus, is the nearest open cluster, about 150 light-years away and several hundred million years old.
Worked example: why open clusters fall apart
Compare escape speeds for an open cluster of 500 solar masses within 10 ly and a globular cluster of 500,000 solar masses within 50 ly. Use \(v_{esc} = \sqrt{\frac{2GM}{R}}\) with \(G = 6.67 \times 10^{-11}\) N m² kg⁻² and a solar mass \(M_\odot = 1.99 \times 10^{30}\) kg. 1. Open cluster: \(M = 9.95 \times 10^{32}\) kg and \(R = 9.46 \times 10^{16}\) m give \(v_{esc} \approx 1.2\) km/s. 2. Globular cluster: \(M = 9.95 \times 10^{35}\) kg and \(R = 4.73 \times 10^{17}\) m give about 17 km/s. 3. Interpret: stars in open clusters move about at speeds near 1 km/s, so a gentle nudge from a neighbour or a passing gas cloud lets them escape. 4. Conclusion: most open clusters dissolve within a few hundred million years, while globular clusters survive for billions.
Associations
An association is a loose, sprawling group of very young stars, typically 100 to 500 light-years across. Its most conspicuous members are a few dozen hot, luminous O and B stars, accompanied by hundreds to thousands of fainter low-mass stars. O stars shine for only a few million years, so finding them means star formation happened very recently, usually within the last 10 million years. Associations are therefore found next to the gas and dust they formed from; many of the bright stars of Orion belong to one. They are too spread out to be held together by gravity, so they drift apart quickly. Many astronomers think the Sun was born in a group that dispersed long ago.
Clusters at a glance
The colour of the brightest members sums up the differences. In associations they are blue, because massive O and B stars are still alive. In open clusters they can be blue in young ones or red and orange giants in older ones. In globular clusters they are always red or orange giants, because every massive blue star died long ago. Location tells a similar story: associations sit among gas in spiral arms, open clusters in the disc, and globular clusters in the halo and bulge, where star formation stopped billions of years ago. Composition follows suit, with globular-cluster stars much poorer in heavy elements.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, cluster stars do not differ in age: they formed together and differ mainly in mass. Second, open clusters are not simply small globular clusters; they are younger, richer in heavy elements, found in the disc and much less tightly bound. Third, associations are not held together by gravity and drift apart within millions of years. Fourth, the brightest stars in a globular cluster are red giants, not hot blue stars. Fifth, even in a crowded cluster core, stars are still light-weeks to light-months apart and look like points of light.
Key takeaways
Cluster stars share an age, composition and distance, so they differ mainly in mass, making clusters natural tests of stellar evolution; their relative brightnesses are true luminosity ratios. Globular clusters hold tens of thousands to millions of old, heavy-element-poor stars in the halo and bulge, with about 150 to 170 in the Milky Way and spacings near the centre of roughly a third of a light-year. Open clusters hold dozens to thousands of stars in the disc and mostly dissolve within a few hundred million years because their escape speeds are only about 1 km/s. Associations are loose, young groups of O and B stars near their birth clouds.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A group of stars born together and bound, at least for a time, by gravity
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Why are star clusters so useful for testing theories of stellar evolution?
Question 2 of 5
A loose group of a few dozen hot O and B stars, spread over about 200 light-years, still sits beside a cloud of gas and dust. What kind of group is it?
Question 3 of 5
A small cluster has 1,000 solar masses within a radius of 5 light-years. Using v = √(2GM/R), about what is its escape speed?
Question 4 of 5
Where in the Milky Way are globular clusters found?
Question 5 of 5
In a cluster core there are 8 stars per cubic light-year. About how far apart are neighbouring stars?
