Astronomy › Section L · Analysing starlight and the stellar census › Topic L.3

Spectra of stars and brown dwarfs

Spread a star's light into a spectrum and it is crossed by dark lines, like a barcode. The pattern of those lines sorts stars into the classes O, B, A, F, G, K and M, and beyond them into the cool brown dwarfs that never quite became stars.

Barcodes in starlight

In 1814 the German optician Joseph von Fraunhofer saw hundreds of dark lines crossing the Sun's spectrum. In the 1860s William Huggins, working with the chemist William Allen Miller, matched lines in the spectra of bright stars to elements measured in the laboratory, showing that stars are made of the same elements as Earth. Later, with Margaret Huggins, he pioneered photographing stellar spectra. Each line is absorption by a particular atom, ion or molecule, as 'Formation of spectral lines' explained, so a spectrum records conditions in a star's outer layers.

Temperature, not composition

Stellar spectra differ enormously: some show mainly hydrogen or helium lines, others hundreds of metal lines or broad molecular bands. Astronomers first assumed that stars were made of different mixtures of elements, but that was wrong. In 1920 Meghnad Saha worked out how the ionisation of atoms depends on temperature, and in 1925 Cecilia Payne applied his theory to stellar spectra. She showed that most stars have similar compositions and that their spectra differ chiefly because their surface temperatures differ. Temperature decides which atoms are ionised and which energy levels are occupied, and so which lines appear.

Why hydrogen lines peak near 10,000 K

Hydrogen's visible lines, the Balmer lines, are absorbed only by atoms whose electron already sits in the second energy level ('The structure of the atom' describes these levels). In stars much hotter than about 20,000 K most hydrogen is ionised: with no electron, the atom cannot absorb at all. In cool stars, below about 5,000 K, almost every electron is in the lowest level, and lifting it needs ultraviolet photons, which cool stars emit few of. Only near 10,000 K are many atoms both neutral and excited, so the Balmer lines are strongest there. Every element and ion has its own best temperature in the same way.

The spectral sequence O B A F G K M

At Harvard College Observatory in the 1880s and 1890s, under Edward Pickering, Williamina Fleming sorted thousands of stars into lettered classes by the strength of their hydrogen lines. Annie Jump Cannon then dropped most of the letters and, around 1901, put the rest in order of temperature: O, B, A, F, G, K, M, from hottest to coolest, each split into subclasses 0 to 9. Cannon classified hundreds of thousands of stars, many for the Henry Draper Catalogue. A common mnemonic for the order is 'Oh Be A Fine Girl (or Guy), Kiss Me'.

What each class shows

Approximate surface temperatures and key features: O stars, above about 30,000 K, show lines of ionised helium and only weak hydrogen. B stars, 10,000 to 30,000 K, show neutral helium and stronger hydrogen. A stars, 7,500 to 10,000 K, have the strongest hydrogen lines. F stars, 6,000 to 7,500 K, have weaker hydrogen and growing lines of ionised calcium and other metals. G stars, 5,200 to 6,000 K, show strong ionised calcium and many metal lines. K stars, 3,700 to 5,200 K, are dominated by neutral metals. M stars, about 2,400 to 3,700 K, show strong molecular bands, especially titanium oxide.

Subclasses, the Sun and 'metals'

Within each class, subclass 0 is the hottest and 9 the coolest, so a B9 star is only a little hotter than an A0 star. The Sun is a G2 star. One more piece of jargon: astronomers call every element heavier than helium a 'metal', including oxygen, carbon and nitrogen, which are not metals to a chemist. A 'metal-rich' star simply has a larger share of elements beyond helium.

Worked example: classifying three spectra

Spectrum 1 has very weak hydrogen lines and clear lines of ionised helium. Spectrum 2 has very weak hydrogen lines, strong titanium oxide bands and many neutral metal lines. Spectrum 3 has very strong hydrogen lines and few others. 1. Weak hydrogen alone is ambiguous: it means either very hot or quite cool. 2. Ionised helium needs extreme heat, so spectrum 1 is an O star. 3. Molecules such as titanium oxide survive only in cool atmospheres, so spectrum 2 is an M star. 4. The strongest hydrogen lines mark spectrum 3 as an A star, near 10,000 K. 5. Check: each verdict uses a second feature to resolve the hydrogen ambiguity.

Brown dwarfs: failed stars

A true star, at some stage of its life, gets its energy steadily from fusing ordinary hydrogen into helium in its core. Objects below about 0.075 solar masses, roughly 80 Jupiter masses (a Jupiter mass is about a thousandth of a solar mass), never get hot enough inside to do this. Those between about 13 and 80 Jupiter masses are called brown dwarfs. Above about 13 Jupiter masses an object can briefly fuse deuterium, a heavy form of hydrogen; this is the working, still debated, line between brown dwarfs and planets. The first brown dwarfs, Teide 1 and Gliese 229B, were confirmed in 1995; thousands are now known.

Spectral classes L, T and Y

Classes L, T and Y extend the sequence. L, about 2,400 to 1,300 K, includes the coolest stars and the warmest brown dwarfs; titanium oxide bands fade because titanium is locked into dust grains, and lines of metal hydrides and of sodium and potassium appear. T, about 1,300 to 600 K, shows methane absorption, as in Jupiter's atmosphere. Y, below about 600 K, shows ammonia; the first Y dwarfs were identified in 2011 with NASA's WISE infrared survey. The coldest known, WISE 0855−0714, is about 285 K according to James Webb Space Telescope spectra, near the freezing point of water. Brown dwarfs cool with age, moving through these classes.

Worked example: why brown dwarfs need infrared eyes

Compare a T dwarf at 1,000 K with the Sun at 5,770 K. 1. Wien's law: \(\lambda_{\max} = \frac{2.90 \times 10^{-3}}{1000} = 2.9 \times 10^{-6}\) m, or 2.9 μm, deep in the infrared, against about 0.50 μm for the Sun. 2. Power per square metre scales as \(T^4\): \((1000/5770)^4 = 9.0 \times 10^{-4}\). 3. A brown dwarf is about Jupiter's size, a tenth of the Sun's radius, so its area is \(0.1^2 = 0.01\) of the Sun's. 4. Luminosity: \(0.01 \times 9.0 \times 10^{-4} \approx 9 \times 10^{-6}\) of the Sun's, mostly in infrared light. 5. Check: the peak is about six times the Sun's wavelength and the output about 100,000 times smaller, which is why sensitive infrared detectors were needed to find such objects.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, reading weak hydrogen lines as a lack of hydrogen: hydrogen dominates nearly all stars, and temperature weakens its visible lines. Second, thinking the classes run alphabetically: the order O, B, A, F, G, K, M is by falling temperature. Third, thinking subclass 9 is hotter than 0: it is the coolest. Fourth, calling every L-type object a brown dwarf: the L class contains both, and spectra alone cannot always tell them apart, so a mass is needed. Fifth, forgetting that astronomers' 'metals' include oxygen and carbon.

Key takeaways

Stellar spectra differ mainly because of surface temperature, not composition, as Saha's theory and Payne's 1925 analysis showed. Hydrogen's visible lines peak near 10,000 K, in A stars. The spectral classes from hottest to coolest are O, B, A, F, G, K, M, each with subclasses 0 (hottest) to 9; the Sun is G2. Brown dwarfs, about 13 to 80 Jupiter masses, never sustain ordinary hydrogen fusion. The cool classes L, T and Y are marked by metal hydrides and alkali metals, methane and ammonia respectively, and are best studied in the infrared.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Fraunhofer lines

Dark absorption lines in the Sun's spectrum, seen in 1814

The first stellar barcode.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Why are hydrogen's visible (Balmer) absorption lines weak in the spectra of the hottest stars?

Question 2 of 5

Which list gives the main spectral classes in order from hottest to coolest?

Question 3 of 5

A star's spectrum shows strong titanium oxide bands and many neutral metal lines, but only very weak hydrogen lines. What is its class?

Question 4 of 5

What distinguishes a brown dwarf from a true star?

Question 5 of 5

Which spectral feature marks the coolest class of brown dwarfs, the Y dwarfs?

← Previous topicNext topic →