Intro to Business › Section I · Motivating employees › Topic I.5
Contemporary views: expectancy, equity, and goals
The need theories ask what people want. The theories in this topic ask how people decide how hard to try: whether effort will pay off, whether they are being treated fairly, and what exactly they are aiming at. They are better supported by evidence than the earlier theories, and each comes with a practical tool.
From needs to thinking
Maslow, McGregor and Herzberg, covered in the previous three topics, describe the content of motivation: the needs and factors that matter. Process theories describe how people turn those needs into choices about effort. A salesperson may badly want a bonus, yet try little if she believes the target is impossible or the bonus is handed out unfairly. Three process theories dominate modern research: Victor Vroom's expectancy theory (1964), J. Stacy Adams's equity theory (1963 and 1965) and Edwin Locke's goal-setting theory (from 1968, later developed with Gary Latham). Each treats employees as people who weigh up their situation, not simply as bundles of needs.
Expectancy theory
Vroom argued that motivation depends on three beliefs. Expectancy is the belief that effort will lead to good performance, from 0 (no chance) to 1 (certain). Instrumentality is the belief that good performance will lead to an outcome, such as a bonus or promotion, also from 0 to 1. Valence is how much the person values that outcome, from \(-1\) (strongly unwanted) to \(+1\) (strongly wanted). Motivation is often written as their product:
Because the beliefs multiply, a zero anywhere makes motivation zero. A generous bonus does nothing if people think the target is out of reach, and an easy target does nothing if no one values the reward.
Worked example: diagnosing low effort
Kai, a support engineer, estimates that extra effort gives him a 0.8 chance of hitting the quarterly resolution target. He thinks there is only a 0.5 chance that hitting it will actually earn the promised bonus, because last year's bonuses were cancelled. He values the bonus highly, at 0.9. 1. Motivation: \(0.8 \times 0.5 \times 0.9 = 0.36\). 2. The weakest link is instrumentality, 0.5. 3. Suppose management pays every bonus on time for a year and Kai's instrumentality rises to 0.9. 4. New motivation: \(0.8 \times 0.9 \times 0.9 = 0.648\), almost double. 5. Check: no change to the target or the bonus was needed; restoring trust in the performance-outcome link did the work.
Equity theory
Adams argued that people judge fairness by comparing ratios. Each person sets their outcomes, such as pay, benefits and recognition, against their inputs, such as hours, effort, skill and experience, and compares that ratio with a referent: a co-worker, someone in another firm, or their own past job.
Equal ratios feel fair. A lower ratio feels like under-reward and creates tension that people try to reduce: by cutting effort, asking for more, changing whom they compare with, reinterpreting the situation or leaving. A higher ratio, over-reward, can also create discomfort, but research finds that effect weaker and shorter-lived.
Worked example: is the pay gap unfair?
Sam earns 60,000 dollars a year for about 2,000 hours of work. He learns that Jo, in the same role, earns 66,000 dollars. 1. Sam's ratio: \(60{,}000 \div 2{,}000 = 30\) dollars per hour. 2. If Jo also works 2,000 hours, Jo's ratio is \(66{,}000 \div 2{,}000 = 33\). 3. Sam's ratio is lower, so equity theory predicts he will feel under-rewarded and may reduce effort or ask for a raise. 4. Now suppose Jo regularly works 2,200 hours, covering evening shifts: \(66{,}000 \div 2{,}200 = 30\). 5. The ratios are equal, so the gap is equitable on this measure. 6. Lesson: perceived inputs matter as much as pay, and explaining them can defuse a sense of unfairness.
Goal-setting theory
Locke and Latham's goal-setting theory is one of the best-supported ideas in organisational psychology. Specific goals lead to higher performance than vague ones such as "do your best". Difficult goals lead to higher performance than easy ones, provided the person accepts the goal and has the ability to reach it. Feedback on progress strengthens the effect, because it shows the gap between current and target performance. Goals work by directing attention, raising effort, increasing persistence and prompting people to find better strategies. Taking part in setting a goal can raise acceptance. The Psychology course's topic Motivation makes the same point about specific, challenging goals.
Reinforcement and fairness of process
Reinforcement theory, built on B. F. Skinner's work in the Psychology course's topic Operant conditioning, says behaviour is shaped by its consequences. Positive reinforcement adds something wanted, such as praise; negative reinforcement removes something unwanted, such as cancelling a dull duty after good work; both increase a behaviour. Punishment decreases it, and extinction, withdrawing reinforcement, makes it fade. Equity research has also widened into organisational justice. Distributive justice concerns whether outcomes are fair; procedural justice concerns whether the process that decided them was fair, consistent and open to appeal. People accept a disappointing outcome far more readily when the process was fair.
Where the evidence is mixed
These theories have more support than the need theories, but each has limits. In a 1996 meta-analysis, Wendelien Van Eerde and Henk Thierry found that expectancy, instrumentality and valence each predicted effort and performance, but the full multiplicative formula did not predict better than the parts, so the equation is best seen as a thinking aid. Equity research finds strong reactions to under-reward and weak ones to over-reward, and people choose different referents. Goal-setting has a dark side: a 2009 paper by Lisa Ordóñez and colleagues argued that narrow, pressured targets can encourage risk-taking, neglect of unmeasured work and even cheating. Most of the research comes from Western, mainly American, workplaces.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, adding expectancy, instrumentality and valence instead of multiplying them; one zero means no motivation. Second, mixing up the links: expectancy is effort to performance, instrumentality is performance to outcome. Third, comparing raw pay in equity theory instead of outcome-to-input ratios. Fourth, assuming people react as strongly to being overpaid as to being underpaid. Fifth, setting difficult goals that people do not accept or cannot reach. Sixth, confusing negative reinforcement, which increases a behaviour, with punishment, which decreases it.
Key takeaways
Process theories explain how people decide how hard to try. Vroom's expectancy theory: M = E × I × V, so every link must be strong. Adams's equity theory: people compare outcome-to-input ratios with a referent and react strongly to under-reward. Locke and Latham's goal-setting theory: specific, difficult, accepted goals with feedback raise performance, though narrow targets can backfire. Reinforcement shapes behaviour through consequences, and procedural justice makes outcomes easier to accept. The formulas are aids to diagnosis, not precise predictions.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Explain how people decide how much effort to give
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
An employee rates expectancy at 0.9, instrumentality at 0.8 and valence at 0.6. Using M = E × I × V, what is her motivation score, and what happens if expectancy falls to 0.3?
Question 2 of 5
A sales team believes it can hit its target and values the bonus, but suspects management will find a reason not to pay. Which belief in expectancy theory is weak?
Question 3 of 5
Lee earns 50,000 dollars for 2,000 hours a year. A colleague earns 55,000 dollars for 2,200 hours in the same role. According to equity theory, how should Lee judge this?
Question 4 of 5
Which goal is most likely to raise performance, according to goal-setting theory?
Question 5 of 5
A manager stops assigning a dull weekly report to anyone who meets their deadlines, and deadline-meeting increases. This is an example of:
