Intro to Business › Section I · Motivating employees › Topic I.4

Herzberg's motivator-hygiene theory

Why can a pay rise stop people complaining without making them work any harder? Frederick Herzberg's answer was that the things that make people unhappy at work are not simply the reverse of the things that make them keen, and his two-factor theory still guides how many firms design jobs.

The question Herzberg asked

Frederick Herzberg (1923-2000), an American psychologist, wanted to know what people really want from work. In The Motivation to Work (1959), written with Bernard Mausner and Barbara Bloch Snyderman, he reported interviews with about 200 engineers and accountants in the Pittsburgh area. Each was asked to recall a time they had felt exceptionally good about their job and a time they had felt exceptionally bad, and to explain what had caused the feeling. This is the critical incident method. The answers fell into two surprisingly separate lists. The events behind good feelings were mostly about the work itself; the events behind bad feelings were mostly about the setting in which the work was done.

Motivators

Herzberg called the first list motivators, or satisfiers. They are intrinsic to the job: achievement, recognition for achievement, the work itself, responsibility, advancement and growth. When these are present, people tend to feel satisfied and to put in extra effort. When they are absent, people do not necessarily become unhappy; they simply do an adequate job rather than their best. Notice that every motivator concerns what a person does and becomes at work. That is why Herzberg linked them to the growth needs at the top of Maslow's hierarchy, covered two topics earlier.

Hygiene factors

The second list he called hygiene factors, or dissatisfiers, by analogy with public health: clean water prevents disease but does not make anyone fitter. Hygiene factors are extrinsic to the job: company policy and administration, supervision, relationships with supervisors and co-workers, working conditions, salary, status and job security. When they are poor, people become dissatisfied and may complain or leave. When they are good, dissatisfaction falls, but motivation does not rise. In the original data, salary was a partial exception: it appeared among good incidents as well as bad ones, though far more often among the bad.

Two scales, not one

The theory's most striking claim is that satisfaction and dissatisfaction are not opposite ends of one scale. The opposite of satisfaction is no satisfaction, and the opposite of dissatisfaction is no dissatisfaction. Picture two separate dials. Hygiene factors move only the dissatisfaction dial, from high down to zero. Motivators move only the satisfaction dial, from zero upwards. A manager who fixes every hygiene problem reaches a workplace where no one is unhappy, which is valuable, but not one where people are energised. To get there, the manager must work on the second dial: the content of the job.

Worked example: sorting a manager's plans

A hotel's front-desk team has low morale. The manager lists five ideas: replace broken chairs, raise pay to the market rate, let staff resolve guest complaints without asking a supervisor, introduce a monthly award for outstanding service, and offer a training path to assistant manager. Classify and predict. 1. Chairs: working conditions, a hygiene factor; it will reduce complaints. 2. Market pay: salary, a hygiene factor; it may cut turnover but is unlikely to raise effort. 3. Resolving complaints: responsibility, a motivator. 4. Award: recognition, a motivator. 5. Training path: advancement and growth, motivators. 6. Plan: fix the hygiene problems first, since they cause active unhappiness, then rely on the three motivators to raise effort.

Job enrichment

Herzberg's practical message, set out in a famous 1968 Harvard Business Review article, was that the way to motivate is to enrich the job. He was scornful of what he called KITA, short for a kick in the pants: pushing people with threats or dangling rewards, which produces movement but not motivation. Job enrichment, or vertical loading, adds the motivators to the job itself. Examples include giving a worker responsibility for a whole unit of work instead of one fragment, removing some controls while keeping accountability, letting people check their own work, and giving them direct feedback from customers. The topic From motivation theory to practice develops job enrichment further.

Where the evidence is contested

Herzberg's theory is popular with managers but has drawn strong criticism from researchers. First, the method may have created the result. When people tell stories, they tend to credit good outcomes to themselves and blame bad ones on others, so the critical incident method would naturally sort achievements into good stories and supervisors and policies into bad ones. Victor Vroom made this point in 1964. Second, studies using other methods often found that the same factor could both satisfy and dissatisfy. Third, Herzberg measured satisfaction, then drew conclusions about motivation and performance, which are related but different. Fourth, the original sample was narrow: white-collar professionals in one American region.

Worked example: testing the claim abroad

Suppose a researcher repeats Herzberg's study with workers in another country and finds that supervision and relationships with co-workers often appear in stories of feeling exceptionally good. Interpret it. 1. Herzberg's prediction: supervision and relationships are hygiene factors, so they should appear mainly in bad stories. 2. The finding contradicts that prediction. 3. Possible explanations: culture, since in some societies relationships at work are a core source of satisfaction; or occupation, since the new sample may do different work. 4. Real precedent: a 1973 study by G. H. Hines in New Zealand reported that supervision and interpersonal relationships contributed to satisfaction there. 5. Verdict: the two lists may not be universal, so managers should test which factors matter to their own staff.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, swapping the lists: achievement, recognition, responsibility and growth are motivators; pay, policy, supervision, conditions and security are hygiene factors. Second, concluding that hygiene factors do not matter; poor ones drive complaints and resignations. Third, assuming that removing dissatisfaction creates motivation; the two run on separate scales. Fourth, citing Herzberg as proof that pay never motivates; salary was a partial exception even in his data. Fifth, forgetting the method critique: self-serving storytelling may explain part of the split. Sixth, confusing job enrichment, which adds depth, with simply adding more tasks.

Key takeaways

Herzberg's 1959 study of about 200 engineers and accountants used the critical incident method. Motivators, such as achievement, recognition, the work itself, responsibility, advancement and growth, create satisfaction and effort. Hygiene factors, such as policy, supervision, relationships, conditions, salary, status and security, prevent dissatisfaction but do not motivate. Satisfaction and dissatisfaction are separate scales. Job enrichment adds motivators to the job. Critics question the method, the narrow sample, cross-cultural results and the leap from satisfaction to motivation.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Frederick Herzberg

Psychologist (1923-2000) who proposed the motivator-hygiene theory

The Motivation to Work, 1959.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

According to Herzberg, which change is most likely to raise employees' motivation rather than just reduce dissatisfaction?

Question 2 of 5

A firm fixes every complaint about pay, policy and conditions, yet employees still show little enthusiasm. How does Herzberg's theory explain this?

Question 3 of 5

What is the main methodological criticism of Herzberg's critical incident interviews?

Question 4 of 5

Which of these is a hygiene factor in Herzberg's theory?

Question 5 of 5

Why did Herzberg compare some job factors to hygiene?

← Previous topicNext topic →