Intro to Business › Section G · Organizational structure › Topic G.5

Organizational design considerations

There is no single best structure. Whether an organisation should be tightly controlled or loose and flexible depends on its strategy, its size, its technology and how stable its environment is. This topic explains the mechanistic and organic models and the factors that favour each.

No one best way

Early management writers, Fayol among them, hoped to find principles that would suit every organisation. Research from the 1950s and 1960s challenged that hope. Studies of real firms found that structures that worked brilliantly in one setting failed in another. This led to contingency theory: the view that the best structure depends on, or is contingent on, the organisation's circumstances. The practical question for a manager is therefore not "what is the ideal structure?" but "what structure fits our goals and situation?" To answer it, managers usually start from two contrasting models, mechanistic and organic, and then consider the factors that push a firm towards one or the other.

Burns and Stalker's two models

In The Management of Innovation (1961), the British researchers Tom Burns and G. M. Stalker described their study of Scottish and English firms, many of them trying to move into the fast-changing electronics industry. They found two broad patterns of management, which they called mechanistic and organic. Firms in stable markets often did well with the mechanistic pattern, while firms facing rapid change needed the organic one; those that kept a rigid structure in a fast-changing market struggled. Burns and Stalker treated the two as ends of a spectrum, not as boxes, and most real organisations sit somewhere in between, leaning one way or the other.

The mechanistic organisation

A mechanistic organisation has a relatively high degree of job specialisation, rigid departmentalisation, many layers of management (especially middle management), narrow spans of control, centralised decision-making and a long chain of command. Work follows rules, procedures and clearly defined jobs, and communication runs mainly up and down the hierarchy. The combination produces a tall structure. Large government agencies and many hospitals tend towards this model, where consistency, safety and accountability matter greatly. Its strengths are efficiency, predictability and control in routine work. Its weakness is slowness: when conditions change, decisions must climb many levels and rules written for yesterday's problems may not fit.

The organic organisation

An organic organisation has the opposite profile: relatively low job specialisation, loose departmentalisation, few levels of management, wide spans of control, decentralised decision-making and a short chain of command. Jobs are defined loosely and change as tasks change, people communicate sideways as well as up and down, and expertise often counts for more than rank. The combination produces a flat structure. Start-ups, design studios, research laboratories and many technology firms lean organic. Its strengths are flexibility, speed and innovation. Its weaknesses are less predictability, blurred responsibilities and the risk that coordination breaks down as the organisation grows.

Tall and flat compared

Line up the six features to compare the two models directly. Job specialisation: high in mechanistic, low in organic. Departmentalisation: rigid versus loose. Levels of management: many (tall) versus few (flat). Span of control: narrow versus wide. Decision-making: centralised versus decentralised. Chain of command: long versus short. The features hang together for a reason. Narrow spans require more levels, which lengthens the chain of command; centralised decisions need many managers to pass information up and instructions down. Conversely, wide spans only work if managers delegate, which means decentralising. Changing one feature, such as widening spans, usually pulls the others with it.

Worked example: profiling a firm

Rate two firms on the six features from 1 (fully mechanistic) to 5 (fully organic). A tax-processing agency scores specialisation 2, departmentalisation 1, levels 2, span 1, decision-making 2 and chain of command 1. A video-game studio scores 4, 5, 4, 5, 4 and 4. 1. Agency average: \((2 + 1 + 2 + 1 + 2 + 1) \div 6 = 1.5\), strongly mechanistic. 2. Studio average: \((4 + 5 + 4 + 5 + 4 + 4) \div 6 \approx 4.3\), strongly organic. 3. Interpretation: both can be well designed. The agency handles millions of routine, legally defined cases where errors are costly; the studio must invent new products quickly. 4. The scale is a teaching device, not a standard measure.

Strategy and structure

A structure should help the firm achieve its goals, and goals come from strategy. The business historian Alfred Chandler, in Strategy and Structure (1962), argued from studies of large US companies that structure follows strategy: when firms changed strategy, for instance by adding new product lines, they eventually had to change structure too. A strategy built on innovation needs the flexibility and free flow of information of an organic design. A strategy built on low cost needs the efficiency and close cost discipline that a mechanistic design offers. Firms trying to cut costs and innovate at the same time face real tension and often run different units in different ways.

Size, environment and technology

Size matters. Small firms tend to be organic partly because they can be: with 30 people, everyone knows the whole business and informal coordination works. As firms grow, they usually add rules, procedures and specialised jobs, becoming more mechanistic, although some large firms deliberately keep organic practices. Environment matters most in Burns and Stalker's account: stable, simple, predictable environments reward mechanistic efficiency, while complex, fast-changing ones demand organic flexibility. Technology also matters. Joan Woodward's studies of English manufacturers, published in 1965, linked effective structure to the type of production, from small batches to mass production to continuous processes such as chemical plants.

Worked example: advising two founders

Two founders ask which way to lean. 1. Maya runs a company that bottles mineral water: one product, steady demand, slowly changing regulations and thin profit margins. Strategy: low cost. Environment: stable. Recommendation: lean mechanistic, with standard procedures, specialised jobs and central control of costs and quality. 2. Tomás runs a firm building custom software for clients whose needs change weekly. Strategy: innovation and responsiveness. Environment: dynamic. Recommendation: lean organic, with small cross-functional teams, wide spans and decisions made close to the client. 3. Check size: both firms have under 80 staff, so Maya's firm will still be more informal than a large bottler, and should add structure only as it grows.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, thinking organic means unstructured or leaderless; it is a deliberate design with loose job boundaries and decentralised decisions. Second, assuming organic is always better because it sounds modern; for stable, routine, safety-critical work, mechanistic designs can be the right fit. Third, mixing up the features: narrow spans and centralised decisions belong to the mechanistic model, wide spans and decentralisation to the organic. Fourth, treating the models as boxes rather than ends of a spectrum. Fifth, ignoring strategy: Chandler's point is that a change of strategy usually calls for a change of structure.

Key takeaways

Contingency theory holds that the best structure depends on circumstances. Burns and Stalker (1961) described mechanistic organisations, with high specialisation, rigid departments, many levels, narrow spans, centralised decisions and a long chain of command, producing a tall structure, and organic organisations with the opposite features, producing a flat structure. Mechanistic designs suit stable environments, low-cost strategies and routine work; organic designs suit dynamic environments and innovation. Chandler (1962) argued that structure follows strategy; size and technology, studied by Joan Woodward (1965), also shape the right design. Most firms sit between the two extremes.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Contingency theory

The best structure depends on the organisation's circumstances

No one best way.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which set of features describes a mechanistic organisation?

Question 2 of 5

A company competes by launching new products every few months in a fast-changing market. Which design fits best?

Question 3 of 5

What did Alfred Chandler argue in Strategy and Structure (1962)?

Question 4 of 5

A firm rates its six structural features as 2, 3, 2, 2, 3 and 3 on a 1 (mechanistic) to 5 (organic) scale. What is its average, and which way does it lean?

Question 5 of 5

Which statement about the mechanistic and organic models is correct?

← Previous topicNext topic →