Intro to Business › Section I · Motivating employees › Topic I.1
Early motivation theories and the Hawthorne studies
Before managers asked what people need from work, they asked how to get more output from each hour. The answers given by Frederick Taylor and by the researchers at the Hawthorne Works still shape how organisations think about pay, supervision and teams, even though some of the famous findings are weaker than the legend.
What motivation means at work
Motivation is the set of forces that start effort, point it in a direction and keep it going. At work, those forces usually come from a gap: between what a person has and what they need, or between where they are and where they want to be. Closing the gap brings a reward. Intrinsic rewards come from the work itself, such as pride in a job well done or the satisfaction of solving a hard problem. Extrinsic rewards come from outside, such as pay, bonuses, promotions and praise from a manager. Every theory in this section is, in the end, a claim about which gaps and rewards matter most.
Taylor and scientific management
Frederick W. Taylor (1856-1915), an engineer who worked at Midvale Steel in Philadelphia and later at Bethlehem Steel in Pennsylvania, believed every job had one best way of being done. He timed tasks with a stopwatch, broke them into separate motions and wrote instructions fixing the method, tools and time allowed. In The Principles of Scientific Management (1911) he argued that managers should replace rule of thumb with measured methods, select and train workers for each task, cooperate closely with them, and take over the planning that workers had once done for themselves. Pay was tied to output, often through a piece rate, because Taylor assumed money was the main motivator.
Worked example: setting a standard time
Taylor's descendants still use time study. Suppose an analyst times a packing task five times and records 2.3, 2.5, 2.4, 2.4 and 2.4 minutes. 1. Average observed time: \(12.0 \div 5 = 2.4\) minutes. 2. The worker seemed 10% faster than a normal pace, so apply a performance rating of 110%: normal time is \(2.4 \times 1.10 = 2.64\) minutes. 3. Add an allowance of 15% of normal time for rest, personal needs and delays: standard time is \(2.64 \times 1.15 = 3.036\) minutes. 4. In an 8-hour shift of 480 minutes, the standard is \(480 \div 3.036 \approx 158\) packs. 5. Check: the allowance raises the time per pack, so the target sits below the \(480 \div 2.4 = 200\) packs the fast observed pace would suggest.
What scientific management missed
Taylor's methods raised output in many plants and influenced the mass-production methods that followed, but they drew heavy criticism. Unions argued that the system sped up work, removed skill and judgement from workers and treated them as interchangeable parts. A 1911 strike at the Watertown Arsenal led to an investigation by a committee of the US House of Representatives. Historians have also questioned Taylor's own evidence: his famous story of a pig-iron loader nearly quadrupling his daily tonnage appears to have been embellished. Lillian and Frank Gilbreth extended motion study, but Lillian Gilbreth also studied fatigue and workers' wellbeing, a human side Taylor largely left out. The deepest flaw was the assumption that people work only for money.
The Hawthorne illumination tests
From about 1924 to 1927, engineers at Western Electric's Hawthorne Works, a large telephone-equipment plant near Chicago, tested whether brighter lighting raised output. The plan was pure Taylor: change one physical condition and measure the result. The reported results puzzled them. Output in test groups often rose whether the lights went up or down, and output in comparison groups whose lighting did not change rose too. The engineers concluded that lighting was only one of many influences on output and that their tests could not separate it from the others. Rather than closing the question, the puzzle opened a much bigger one about what else was going on.
Mayo and the human relations view
From about 1928, Elton Mayo and colleagues from Harvard, including Fritz Roethlisberger, joined the research. In the relay assembly test room (1927-1932), a small group of women assembling telephone relays worked under changing rest breaks, hours and pay schemes, and output generally rose. A large interviewing programme asked thousands of employees about their work. In the bank wiring observation room (1931-1932), researchers watched a group of men hold output to an informal norm, pressuring fast workers to slow down. Mayo's group concluded that attention, supervision and group belonging shaped output as much as pay or conditions. This launched the human relations movement, which put social needs at the centre of management.
Worked example: reading the Hawthorne evidence
Treat the studies as a cause-and-effect claim and test it. 1. The claim: workers produced more because they received attention and felt part of a special group. 2. Alternative causes in the relay room: two of the five original workers were replaced in 1928 for poor cooperation, a piece rate based on the small group's output was introduced, and rest breaks were added. 3. Reanalysis: in 1978 Richard Franke and James Kaul argued statistically that discipline, the economic depression and rest time explained most of the output changes. 4. The lighting data: in 2011 Steven Levitt and John List analysed surviving illumination records and found little support for the dramatic version of the story. 5. Verdict: the social factors were real, but the evidence for a simple attention effect is weak.
The Hawthorne effect and the legacy
The sociologist Henry Landsberger named the Hawthorne effect in 1958: a change in behaviour that happens because people know they are being studied. Researchers in psychology, medicine and education still design studies to guard against it, even though the original evidence is disputed, as the Psychology course's topic What is industrial-organizational psychology? also notes. The lasting business lesson is broader. The studies shifted attention from physical conditions to supervision, group norms and the meaning people find at work. The theories in the next topics, starting with Maslow's hierarchy of needs, grew from that shift. Taylor's influence did not vanish, either: modern delivery routing, call-centre scripts and warehouse picking targets still use measured methods and standard times.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, saying Taylor ignored productivity: he raised it; what he ignored was the human side of motivation. Second, telling the Hawthorne story as settled proof that attention alone raises output; reanalyses found other causes and weak lighting effects. Third, crediting Mayo with the illumination tests: Western Electric's engineers ran them, and Mayo's group arrived later. Fourth, forgetting the bank wiring room, which showed that groups can lower output as well as raise it. Fifth, treating intrinsic and extrinsic rewards as either-or: most jobs offer both. Sixth, applying a standard time without its allowance, which sets an impossible target.
Key takeaways
Motivation starts, directs and sustains effort, and it is driven by intrinsic and extrinsic rewards. Taylor's scientific management (1911) used time study, one best way and pay for output, but assumed money was the only motivator. The Hawthorne studies, from about 1924 to 1932, began as lighting tests and, through Mayo's group, turned attention to supervision, group norms and social needs. Later reanalyses, in 1978 and 2011, found the evidence for a simple attention effect weak. The Hawthorne effect, named in 1958, remains a standard caution in research design.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The forces that start, direct and sustain effort towards a goal
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
An analyst finds an average observed time of 4.0 minutes for a task, rates the worker at 90% of normal pace and adds a 10% allowance of normal time. What is the standard time?
Question 2 of 5
What was the central assumption behind Taylor's scientific management that later researchers rejected?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement best describes the current scholarly view of the Hawthorne studies?
Question 4 of 5
In the bank wiring observation room, what did researchers observe?
Question 5 of 5
A drug trial finds that patients improve partly because they know researchers are watching them closely. This is an example of:
