Intro to Business › Section I · Motivating employees › Topic I.2

Maslow's hierarchy of needs

Maslow's hierarchy is probably the best-known idea in management, and it gives managers a useful checklist of what people seek from work. It is also one of the most misquoted: the rigid pyramid most people picture is not what the evidence supports.

From output to needs

The Hawthorne studies, covered in the previous topic, suggested that social needs shape effort at work. The psychologist Abraham Maslow (1908-1970) offered a general theory of what those needs are. In "A Theory of Human Motivation" (1943) and later in Motivation and Personality (1954), he argued that people act to satisfy unmet needs, that the needs fall into a few broad groups, and that the groups have an order of priority. A need that is largely satisfied stops driving behaviour, and the next group becomes the stronger motive. For managers the appeal was obvious: if you know which needs an employee is trying to meet, you know which rewards are likely to work.

The five levels

Maslow's levels, from the most basic upwards, are: physiological needs, such as food, water, sleep and shelter; safety needs, such as physical security, stability and freedom from fear; love and belonging, also called social needs, such as friendship, acceptance and being part of a group; esteem needs, both self-respect and the respect, recognition and status given by others; and self-actualisation, the need to fulfil one's potential and become what one is capable of being. He grouped the first four as deficiency needs, which push people to fill a gap, and the fifth as a growth need, which pulls people towards development. Late in life he also described self-transcendence, serving purposes beyond the self.

The hierarchy at work

Each level has a workplace counterpart. A wage that covers living costs, and reasonable hours and breaks, meet physiological needs. Job security, safe equipment, health insurance and fair, predictable rules meet safety needs. Teams, friendly co-workers and inclusive social events meet belonging needs. Recognition, job titles, praise from managers and promotion meet esteem needs. Challenging assignments, training, creative freedom and the chance to master a craft meet self-actualisation needs. The practical message is that pay matters most when it is inadequate. Once people feel secure, a manager who offers only more money is addressing a need that has already lost much of its pull.

Worked example: a warehouse with high turnover

A distribution centre, call it Brightway, pays above the local average, yet a third of new hires leave within six months. Exit interviews mention rotating shifts announced at short notice, workers being moved between teams every week, and no feedback except complaints. Diagnose it with Maslow. 1. Physiological: the pay is good, so this level is met. 2. Safety: shifts changed at short notice make income and life unpredictable, so stability is not met. 3. Belonging: constant team changes stop friendships forming. 4. Esteem: no recognition at all. 5. Prediction: a pay rise targets a met need and is unlikely to help much. 6. Better levers: schedules posted weeks ahead, stable teams and regular recognition. 7. Check: each lever matches an unmet level.

What Maslow actually claimed

The famous pyramid was drawn by later writers, not by Maslow, and it suggests more rigidity than he intended. In his 1943 paper he wrote that most people have every level only partly satisfied at once, and he illustrated this with rough percentages that fall as the levels rise, not with a staircase. He also allowed for exceptions, such as people who pursue creative work while their basic needs are unmet. The hierarchy describes which needs usually press hardest, not a ladder that must be climbed one rung at a time. Much of the criticism aimed at Maslow is really aimed at the textbook pyramid.

Where the evidence is weak

Even the softer version has limited support. A 1976 review by Mahmoud Wahba and Lawrence Bridwell found little evidence for Maslow's five distinct groups or for the order in which they become important. Self-actualisation is vague and hard to measure, and Maslow based his account of it on a small group of people he selected himself. In 2011 Louis Tay and Ed Diener analysed survey data from 123 countries: the needs Maslow named were broadly universal and each was linked to wellbeing, but people gained from social and respect needs even when basic needs were not fully met. The needs are real; the strict order is not supported, as the Psychology course's topic Motivation also concludes.

Culture and the order of needs

Maslow wrote as an American, and critics argue that placing individual self-actualisation at the top reflects an individualist culture. In societies that stress group harmony, belonging may outrank personal achievement. Research on national cultures, such as Geert Hofstede's, found that in countries with strong uncertainty avoidance, employees tend to value job security more highly than interesting or challenging work. A multinational that rolls out one recognition scheme everywhere may therefore find that it lands well in one country and poorly in another. Managers can still use Maslow's list of needs, but they should not assume the same ranking holds for every workforce.

Alderfer's ERG theory

Clayton Alderfer (1969) reworked Maslow's ideas into three groups: existence (physiological and material needs), relatedness (relationships with others) and growth (development and self-fulfilment). ERG theory makes two changes that fit the evidence better. Several needs can be active at the same time. And it adds frustration-regression: when a higher need is blocked, a person may fall back and demand more of a lower one. Maslow's theory says little about moving back down. ERG theory helps explain a familiar pattern: employees who see no route to promotion often press harder for pay rises.

Worked example: when a promotion freeze meets a pay claim

A software firm freezes promotions for two years. Soon its engineers, who rarely mentioned pay before, push for salary increases. Explain it. 1. Before the freeze, existence needs were met and growth needs, served by promotions, were the main motive. 2. The freeze blocks growth. 3. Strict Maslow predicts that growth would stay the main motive, with nothing pushing people back down. 4. ERG predicts frustration-regression: blocked growth turns energy back towards existence needs, so demands for pay rise. 5. The observed behaviour fits ERG better. 6. Implication: offering new growth routes, such as technical projects or training, may ease the pay pressure more cheaply than raises alone.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, crediting the pyramid to Maslow; later writers drew it. Second, treating the levels as a strict ladder; people pursue several needs at once, and the 2011 study across 123 countries found no strict order. Third, assuming pay serves only the bottom level; pay can also signal status and esteem. Fourth, calling self-actualisation a measured scientific finding rather than a loosely defined ideal. Fifth, assuming the same ranking holds in every culture. Sixth, forgetting that a blocked higher need can push people back down, which ERG theory describes and Maslow's theory does not.

Key takeaways

Maslow (1943) proposed five groups of needs: physiological, safety, love and belonging, esteem and self-actualisation, with lower needs usually pressing hardest and a satisfied need losing its pull. At work they map onto pay, security, teams, recognition and growth. The pyramid came from later writers, and research, including a 1976 review and a 2011 study of 123 countries, supports the needs but not their strict order. Cultures rank needs differently. Alderfer's ERG theory (1969) allows several needs at once and frustration-regression.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Abraham Maslow

Psychologist (1908-1970) who proposed a hierarchy of needs in 1943

Expanded in Motivation and Personality, 1954.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A well-paid team has stable jobs and good friendships at work but complains that no one ever notices their achievements. Which of Maslow's needs is most clearly unmet?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement about the pyramid diagram of Maslow's hierarchy is accurate?

Question 3 of 5

What did Tay and Diener's 2011 study of survey data from 123 countries find?

Question 4 of 5

After a promotion freeze, employees who rarely mentioned pay start demanding raises. Which idea best explains this?

Question 5 of 5

A manager raises pay for staff who already earn well, hoping to boost motivation, but nothing changes. What does Maslow's theory suggest?

← Previous topicNext topic →