Intro to Business › Section A · Economic systems and business › Topic A.7
Competing in a free market
A wheat farmer, a local water company, a hair salon and an aircraft maker all compete, but in very different ways. How many rivals a firm has, how alike their products are and how hard it is to enter the market decide how much control the firm has over its price.
The right to compete
One of the defining features of a free-market system is that sellers have the right to compete with one another for customers. But competition looks very different from one industry to the next. Economists describe these differences as market structure: the number and size of the sellers in a market, together with how similar their products are and how easily new firms can enter. They identify four main structures: perfect competition, monopolistic competition, oligopoly and pure monopoly. The structure matters to managers because it sets how much power a firm has over its price, how much it must spend on advertising and how closely it must watch its rivals.
Perfect competition
Perfect competition has four features: a large number of small firms; products that are essentially identical; buyers and sellers with good information about prices and quality; and easy entry and exit. No single firm can influence the price, which is set by market supply and demand. Each firm is a price taker: if one farmer asked even a little more than the going price for an identical crop, buyers would simply go elsewhere. Perfect competition is an ideal that no real industry matches exactly, but markets for farm commodities such as wheat and corn come close, because a bushel from one farm is much like a bushel from another.
Worked example: life as a price taker
An invented wheat farm expects to harvest 50,000 bushels, and the market price is 6 dollars a bushel. 1. Revenue at the market price: \(50000 \times 6 = 300000\) dollars. 2. Suppose the farmer asks 6.20 dollars. Buyers can get identical wheat at 6 dollars from thousands of other farms, so they buy none from this one. 3. Suppose instead the farmer charges 5.80 dollars. Every bushel would sell, but so would every bushel at 6 dollars, so the cut just loses \(50000 \times 0.20 = 10000\) dollars. 4. Conclusion: the farm accepts the market price and decides only how much to grow. Its real decisions are about costs and output, not price.
Pure monopoly
At the other extreme is pure monopoly: a single firm makes all the industry's sales of a product with no close substitutes. The firm is the industry, and it has high control over its price. A monopoly can last only if barriers to entry keep rivals out. The main barriers are control of a key resource; legal barriers such as patents, which give an inventor exclusive rights for about 20 years, or government licences; economies of scale so large that one firm can serve the whole market more cheaply than several, called a natural monopoly; and network effects. Local water and electricity networks are natural monopolies, and they are usually regulated.
Monopolistic competition
Monopolistic competition combines many firms, products that are close substitutes but differ from one another, and relatively easy entry. Restaurants, hair salons, coffee shops and clothing brands are typical. Because each firm's product is a little different, through location, quality, style, service or brand, it has some control over its price: a loyal customer may pay a little more for a favourite café. But with many near-substitutes nearby, that control is limited. Firms therefore work hard at product differentiation and advertising to persuade customers that their version is special, whether the differences are significant or mostly a matter of image.
Oligopoly
An oligopoly is a market dominated by a handful of large sellers, usually because large capital requirements or other barriers limit the number of firms. Large commercial aircraft, dominated by Boeing and Airbus, and smartphone operating systems, dominated by Apple's iOS and Google's Android, are examples. The key feature is interdependence: each firm's moves on price, products or advertising affect its rivals, so oligopolists watch one another closely and respond quickly. Rivals sometimes face a temptation to coordinate prices or output instead of competing. That is collusion, and it is illegal under US antitrust laws, which date back to the Sherman Act of 1890.
Measuring how few the firms are
Economists put a number on market concentration in two ways. The four-firm concentration ratio adds up the market shares of the four largest firms. The Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) squares every firm's percentage share and adds them:
It ranges from close to zero, for many tiny firms, to 10,000 for a pure monopoly. US antitrust agencies use the HHI to judge mergers, and under the 2023 Merger Guidelines a market above 1,800 counts as highly concentrated. The Microeconomics course topic "Oligopoly, collusion, and cartels" uses the same measures.
Worked example: a concentrated market
Five invented firms share a market: 30%, 25%, 20%, 15% and 10%. 1. Four-firm ratio: \(30 + 25 + 20 + 15 = 90\%\), so four firms control almost the whole market. 2. HHI: \(900 + 625 + 400 + 225 + 100 = 2250\), above 1,800, so the market is highly concentrated. 3. The firms with 20% and 15% propose to merge. New shares: 30%, 25%, 35% and 10%. 4. New HHI: \(900 + 625 + 1225 + 100 = 2850\), a rise of 600. 5. Check: the rise always equals twice the product of the merging shares, \(2 \times 20 \times 15 = 600\). A rise that large in an already concentrated market would draw close scrutiny from regulators.
Structures change over time
Market structure is not fixed. US telephone service shows how it can shift. For decades AT&T held a near-monopoly on US telephone service. After an antitrust case, its local telephone operations were split off in 1984 into seven regional companies, while long-distance calling opened to rivals such as Sprint and MCI. The Telecommunications Act of 1996 then let local and long-distance companies enter each other's markets. Mergers since then have pulled parts of the industry back towards oligopoly, while new technologies, such as mobile and internet calling, created fresh competition. Patents expire, new firms enter, and mergers concentrate markets again.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, thinking perfect competition describes most real markets; it is an ideal that a few commodity markets only approach. Second, confusing monopolistic competition with monopoly: it has many firms and easy entry, and each has only a little price control through differentiation. Third, calling any large firm a monopoly; a pure monopoly is the only seller, with no close substitutes and barriers keeping rivals out. Fourth, assuming oligopolists may legally agree on prices; collusion is illegal. Fifth, adding market shares without squaring them when calculating the HHI.
Key takeaways
Market structure describes the number of sellers, how alike their products are and how easy entry is. Perfect competition has many small price-taking firms selling identical products with free entry. Monopolistic competition has many firms selling differentiated products, giving some price control. Oligopoly has a few interdependent firms behind high barriers, where collusion is illegal. Pure monopoly is a single seller protected by barriers such as key resources, patents, scale economies or network effects. Concentration is measured by the four-firm ratio and the HHI. Structures change as technology, laws and mergers reshape industries.
Flashcards
Flashcard
The number of sellers, how alike their products are, and ease of entry
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A market has thousands of small growers selling an identical crop, buyers know prices well, and anyone can start or stop farming easily. Which structure is this closest to?
Question 2 of 5
A drug company is the only seller of a new medicine because it holds a patent on it. What kind of barrier to entry protects it?
Question 3 of 5
Four firms have market shares of 40%, 30%, 20% and 10%. What is the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index?
Question 4 of 5
What is the distinctive feature of an oligopoly?
Question 5 of 5
Why do firms in monopolistic competition, such as clothing brands, spend heavily on advertising?
