Intro to Business › Section A · Economic systems and business › Topic A.8
Competitive strategy and trends in the business environment
Knowing the market structure is only the start. Firms also have to decide how they will win: by being cheapest, by being different, or by serving a niche. And they must do it while the workforce, technology and the energy supply keep changing around them.
Analysing an industry: the five forces
In 1979 the Harvard economist Michael Porter set out a framework for judging how attractive an industry is. He identified five competitive forces: rivalry among existing competitors; the threat of new entrants; the threat of substitute products; the bargaining power of suppliers; and the bargaining power of buyers. Strong forces squeeze profits: rivals cut prices, newcomers take share, substitutes cap what customers will pay, and powerful suppliers or buyers grab more of the value. Barriers to entry, such as brand loyalty, patents or huge start-up costs, are what keep the threat of new entrants low.
Worked example: five forces for a meal-kit start-up
An invented company plans to sell weekly meal kits. 1. Rivalry: several large kit brands already compete hard on price, so rivalry is strong. 2. New entrants: little equipment is needed, so entry is easy and the threat is high. 3. Substitutes: supermarkets, takeaways and restaurant delivery all meet the same need, so the threat is high. 4. Suppliers: many farms and wholesalers sell ingredients, so supplier power is low. 5. Buyers: customers can cancel a subscription in seconds, so buyer power is high. Conclusion: four of five forces are strong, so profits will be hard to earn unless the firm finds a lasting advantage.
Three generic strategies
A competitive advantage is anything that lets a firm outperform its rivals. Porter argued that firms usually build it in one of three ways. Cost leadership means becoming the lowest-cost producer, so the firm can charge less than rivals or earn more at the same price; large discount retailers follow this path. Differentiation means offering something customers see as unique, such as design, quality, service or brand, and charging a premium for it. Focus means serving a narrow niche, through either low cost or differentiation, such as a firm that makes equipment only for left-handed musicians. Porter warned that firms which try to do everything at once risk being stuck in the middle.
Economies of scale and network effects
Two forces give large firms an edge. Economies of scale occur when the average cost per unit falls as output rises, because fixed costs are spread over more units and big buyers win bulk discounts. Very large firms can, however, suffer diseconomies of scale when they become too complex to manage efficiently. Network effects occur when a product becomes more valuable as more people use it, as with payment networks, online marketplaces and social media. A buyer joins the marketplace with the most sellers, and sellers join the one with the most buyers, so network effects can create winner-takes-most markets with strong barriers to entry.
Worked example: spreading fixed costs
An invented furniture maker has fixed costs of 600,000 dollars a year and variable costs of 4 dollars per flat-pack shelf. 1. At 50,000 shelves, average cost per shelf is
dollars. 2. At 200,000 shelves, it is \(600000 \div 200000 + 4 = 3 + 4 = 7\) dollars. 3. Compare: quadrupling output cut the average cost by more than half, because each shelf now carries a much smaller slice of the fixed costs. 4. Interpret: a rival making only 50,000 shelves cannot match a price of 10 dollars without losing money, while the larger firm still earns 3 dollars a shelf. That is economies of scale working as a barrier.
SWOT analysis
A simple tool for organising strategic thinking is SWOT analysis. It lists a firm's internal strengths and weaknesses and its external opportunities and threats. Strengths and weaknesses are things the firm controls, such as skilled staff, a strong brand, high costs or outdated systems. Opportunities and threats come from the external environment met in "The business environment": new markets, changing tastes, new rivals, new laws. Managers then build on strengths, fix or work around weaknesses, seize opportunities and guard against threats. For example, an independent bookshop facing online rivals might stop competing on price and use its expert staff and author events to differentiate.
Disruptive innovation
Clayton Christensen of Harvard described disruptive innovation in his 1997 book The Innovator's Dilemma. A disruptive product starts at the low end of a market, simpler and cheaper than what established firms sell, and they often ignore it because their best customers do not want it. It then improves until it displaces them. Digital photography is often cited as an example. A Kodak engineer built an early digital camera in 1975, but the company remained centred on film, and it filed for bankruptcy protection in 2012. Today generative artificial intelligence is widely expected to disrupt many service industries, though how far is still debated.
A changing workforce
Trends in the wider environment also reshape competition. The US workforce now spans several generations, from Generation Z to baby boomers, so a 60-year-old may well report to a manager under 30. Many older workers stay on past traditional retirement age, and firms use flexible hours and phased retirement to keep their experience. Firms that plan for retirements so knowledge is not lost, and build inclusive cultures for an increasingly diverse workforce, gain an edge in keeping talent.
Energy, relationships and alliances
Rising living standards in emerging economies such as China and India push up world energy demand. After Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022, European countries sharply cut their reliance on Russian gas, a reminder of the risk of depending on one supplier. Firms also compete through relationship management: building long-term ties with suppliers (supply chain management) and with customers (relationship marketing). Many firms form strategic alliances, cooperative agreements with other firms; Nike, for example, relies on independent factories to make most of its products.
Worked example: the value of keeping customers
An invented subscription service has 1,000 customers, each bringing 200 dollars of profit a year. Compare losing 15% of customers a year with losing 10%, ignoring new sign-ups. 1. At 15% loss, customers in years 1 to 3 are 1,000, 850 and 722.5, so profit is \(200 \times 2572.5 = 514500\) dollars. 2. At 10% loss, customers are 1,000, 900 and 810: profit \(200 \times 2710 = 542000\) dollars. 3. Difference: 27,500 dollars, from cutting losses by 5 points. 4. After three years of losses, \(1000 \times 0.85^3 \approx 614\) customers remain, against \(1000 \times 0.9^3 = 729\). Loyal customers also tend to buy more and recommend the firm.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, mixing up the halves of SWOT: strengths and weaknesses are internal, opportunities and threats external. Second, assuming cost leadership means poor quality; it means the lowest cost, which can come from scale and efficiency. Third, forgetting that substitutes are a separate force from rivals: a train competes with a bus company as a substitute even though it is a different industry. Fourth, thinking bigger is always cheaper; beyond some size, diseconomies of scale can raise costs. Fifth, treating disruptive innovation as any new technology; it specifically starts cheaper and simpler at the low end of a market.
Key takeaways
Porter's five forces are rivalry, new entrants, substitutes, supplier power and buyer power; strong forces squeeze profits. Competitive advantage comes from cost leadership, differentiation or focus. Economies of scale lower average cost as fixed costs spread over more output, and network effects can create dominant platforms. SWOT sets internal strengths and weaknesses against external opportunities and threats. Disruptive innovation can topple leaders, as digital photography did to Kodak. Wider trends, a multigenerational and diverse workforce, energy security, customer retention and strategic alliances, also shape how firms compete.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Rivalry, new entrants, substitutes, supplier power, buyer power
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A retailer squeezes its supply chain, buys in huge volumes and keeps stores simple so it can charge less than any rival. Which generic strategy is it following?
Question 2 of 5
A bus company notices that cheap ride-sharing apps are taking its passengers. Which of Porter's five forces is at work?
Question 3 of 5
A gym starts with 500 members and keeps 80% of its members each year, with no new sign-ups. How many members does it have after two years?
Question 4 of 5
In a SWOT analysis for a café, where does "a new office block opening next door" belong?
Question 5 of 5
A factory has fixed costs of 300,000 dollars and a variable cost of 5 dollars per unit. What happens to its average cost per unit if output rises from 20,000 to 60,000 units?
