Intro to Business › Section F · Management and leadership › Topic F.4

Leading, guiding, and motivating

Plans and structures only work when people choose to put effort into them. Leading, the third management function, is about influence: where a leader's power comes from, which style suits which situation, and how leadership shapes an organisation's culture.

What leading means

Leadership means steering and motivating other people towards the organisation's goals. Managers are leaders by appointment: the structure gives them people to direct. But leadership is not limited to job titles. A respected nurse on a hospital ward or the most experienced programmer on a team may influence colleagues more than the official manager does, because people follow them by choice. Organisations need leadership at every level. Top managers use it to set and win support for the mission, vision and strategy; middle and supervisory managers use it every day as employees carry out plans within the structure that organising has built.

Five bases of power

To lead, a person must be able to influence others, and that ability is called power. The psychologists John French and Bertram Raven, writing in 1959, identified five bases of power. Legitimate power comes from a person's position in the organisation. Reward power comes from control over things people value, such as pay rises, bonuses or good assignments. Coercive power comes from the ability to impose negative outcomes, such as reprimands or dismissal. Expert power comes from specialised knowledge or skill. Referent power comes from personal charisma and the respect or admiration a person inspires. Most leaders draw on several bases at once.

Position power and personal power

The five bases fall into two groups. Legitimate, reward and coercive power come with the job: they are position power, and they disappear when the person leaves the post. Expert and referent power belong to the individual: they are personal power, and they travel with that person to a new role or even a new company. Research and experience suggest that relying mainly on coercion tends to win grudging compliance rather than commitment, while expert and referent power more often win genuine effort. That is one reason a newly promoted manager is usually advised to build credibility and trust rather than lean on the title.

Worked example: naming the power

Identify the main base of power in each case. 1. A plant manager tells staff that anyone who skips the new safety training will lose their overtime shifts: coercive, because the influence rests on a threatened penalty. 2. A finance clerk with no management title is asked by every department to explain the new tax software, and people follow her advice: expert. 3. A sales director announces that the top three performers will join an overseas trade fair: reward. 4. Staff accept a new rota because the store manager, whose job it is to set rotas, has approved it: legitimate. 5. Volunteers stay late because they admire their coordinator and want her approval: referent.

Three styles on a continuum

A leader's habitual way of influencing people is called leadership style, and styles can be placed on a continuum. At one end, autocratic leaders make decisions alone, give detailed instructions and expect them to be followed, with information flowing mainly downwards. This can be fast and decisive in emergencies or with untrained staff, but it often seems heavy-handed. In the middle, participative leaders share decision-making and encourage discussion. At the other end, free-rein or laissez-faire leaders (from the French for "let them do") hand a task and almost all authority to the group and step in only when asked. This suits highly skilled, motivated professionals, but frustrates people who need direction or feedback.

Three kinds of participation

Participative leadership itself takes three forms. A democratic leader asks for input from everyone and lets the group decide by vote, which can suit a practice of highly trained professionals, such as a group of physicians. A consensual leader encourages discussion and requires everyone involved to agree before a decision is final, the approach used by many mediators. A consultative leader asks subordinates for their views but keeps the final decision. The difference lies in who decides: the majority, everyone together, or the leader after listening. Kurt Lewin's late-1930s studies, covered in the sociology topic Group size, leadership, and conformity, were an early test of the wider contrast between autocratic, democratic and laissez-faire leaders.

Situational leadership and empowerment

No single style works all the time. Situational leadership, a model developed by Paul Hersey and Ken Blanchard from the late 1960s, holds that the best style depends on how competent and committed the followers are for a given task. A new employee may need a directive style, with clear instructions; once they master the job, the same direction can feel like distrust, and a participative or free-rein style works better. Participative and free-rein leaders rely on empowerment: giving employees more autonomy and discretion to make decisions, along with control over the resources to carry them out. Empowered employees tend to feel greater ownership of results.

Worked example: matching style to situation

A hotel manager, Rafael, faces three situations. Choose a style for each. 1. A fire alarm sounds during a busy evening: there is no time for discussion and staff must follow the evacuation plan exactly, so an autocratic style fits. 2. He wants to redesign the breakfast service and his experienced restaurant staff know the problems best: a consultative style lets him gather their ideas and still make the final call. 3. His events team of seasoned planners is organising a large conference they have run before: a free-rein style, with a clear budget and deadline, respects their expertise. 4. Lesson: the same manager rightly uses different styles as the task and people change.

Leadership and corporate culture

Corporate culture is the set of attitudes, values and standards of behaviour that distinguishes one organisation from another. It grows over time from the organisation's history, the vision of its founders and the dominant leadership style. Culture shows in the organisation's heroes (admired figures held up as examples), myths (stories passed from employee to employee), symbols (such as a logo) and ceremonies (such as annual awards). A company whose leaders punish every mistake breeds a culture of hiding problems; one whose leaders reward candour breeds one of reporting them early. The psychology topic The social side of work describes Edgar Schein's three levels of culture in more depth.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, assuming only managers lead: anyone who influences others by choice is exercising leadership. Second, confusing power bases, especially reward with legitimate power; the question is whether influence comes from the position itself or from control over rewards. Third, treating free-rein leadership as automatically popular; without clear goals and feedback, it can leave people feeling abandoned. Fourth, thinking consultative leadership means the group decides; the leader listens but keeps the final say. Fifth, looking for one best style; situational leadership argues that the right style depends on the followers' competence and commitment.

Key takeaways

Leadership is guiding and motivating others towards organisational goals, and it can come from anyone. French and Raven's five bases of power are legitimate, reward, coercive, expert and referent; the first three are position power and the last two personal power. Styles run from autocratic, through participative (democratic, consensual or consultative), to free-rein. Situational leadership matches style to the followers' competence and commitment, and empowerment shares decision-making with employees. Leadership style helps form corporate culture, visible in heroes, myths, symbols and ceremonies. Motivation theories follow in Section I, starting with Early motivation theories and the Hawthorne studies.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Leadership

Guiding and motivating others towards organisational goals

Can come from anyone, not only managers.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Engineers follow a senior colleague's advice on a design problem because she has solved similar problems for years, although she manages no one. Which base of power is she using?

Question 2 of 5

A manager asks her team for their views on a new schedule, listens carefully and then decides herself. Which style is this?

Question 3 of 5

Which three bases of power are forms of position power?

Question 4 of 5

According to situational leadership, which style best suits a brand-new employee learning an unfamiliar task?

Question 5 of 5

Which of these is evidence of a company's corporate culture?

← Previous topicNext topic →