Intro to Business › Section F · Management and leadership › Topic F.5
Controlling
A plan tells you where you meant to go; controlling tells you where you actually are. This fourth management function sets standards, measures results, spots gaps and corrects them, and its findings start the next round of planning.
Are we on track?
Imagine a delivery firm that plans to deliver 98% of parcels on time this quarter. Without anyone counting late parcels, the plan is a wish. Controlling is the process of assessing the organisation's progress towards its goals. It means monitoring how a plan is being carried out and correcting deviations from it. Controlling is sometimes misread as micromanaging or policing staff, but its real job is information: it tells managers whether the planning, organising and leading were good enough, early enough to fix problems before they become crises. Every organisation controls something, whether money, quality, time, safety or customer satisfaction.
The control process
Controlling is usually described as a cycle of five stages. 1. Set performance standards: decide what level of performance the organisation wants, based on its strategic, tactical and operational plans. 2. Measure actual performance. 3. Compare actual performance with the standard to see whether there is a gap. 4. If there is a gap, find its cause and take corrective action. 5. Feed what was learned back into planning, so that standards and plans can be revised. Then the cycle repeats. The feedback stage is what links controlling to the other management functions and turns them into a continuous loop.
Setting good standards
The most useful performance standards state a measurable result to be reached within a set time, much like a SMART goal. "Sell more" is not a standard; "USD 150,000 in gross sales in March" is. Standards cascade: a sales division has a monthly target, and each salesperson has an individual share of it, so that performance can be checked at every level. Many organisations track their most important standards as key performance indicators (KPIs), a small set of numbers that show whether the organisation is succeeding, such as on-time delivery rate, customer complaints per 1,000 orders or cost per unit. Measurement must be accurate, timely and of the right thing.
Measuring and comparing
Comparison usually means calculating a variance, the difference between actual and standard performance. It is often expressed as a percentage of the standard:
Whether a positive variance is good depends on what is measured: sales above target are favourable, but costs above budget are unfavourable. Small variances are normal, so many managers set a tolerance range, for instance acting only when results miss the standard by more than 5%. This avoids wasting time on random noise while still catching real problems. Reporting systems that highlight where standards are not being met help managers catch problems early.
Worked example: a sales shortfall
A region's standard is USD 150,000 in sales for March. Actual sales are USD 132,000. The tolerance is 5%. 1. Variance in dollars: \(132{,}000 - 150{,}000 = -18{,}000\). 2. Percentage: \(-18{,}000 \div 150{,}000 = -0.12\), or \(-12\%\). 3. Compare with tolerance: a 12% shortfall exceeds 5%, so action is needed. 4. Find the cause: one territory had no salesperson for two weeks after a resignation. 5. Corrective action: cover the territory temporarily and speed up hiring. 6. Feedback: next year's plan includes a backup arrangement for vacancies. Notice that the action targets the cause, not just the number.
Two kinds of corrective action
When a gap appears, managers have two broad choices. They can act to bring performance back up to the standard, for example by retraining staff, repairing a machine or reallocating budget. Or, if the standard itself was unrealistic or the environment has changed, they can revise the standard. A café that set a sales target before a road closure blocked its street may reasonably lower the target for those months. The danger lies in using the second option too readily: lowering every standard that is missed removes the point of control. Managers should first ask whether the cause lies in performance or in the standard.
Controls before, during and after
Controls can also be classified by timing, a distinction found in most management textbooks. Feedforward (preventive) controls act before work begins, such as inspecting raw materials or checking a new hire's qualifications. Concurrent controls act while work is happening, such as a supervisor watching a production line or software that flags an unusual payment as it is made. Feedback controls act after the work is finished, such as monthly financial statements or customer surveys. Feedback controls give the fullest picture, but they arrive after any damage is done, so well-run firms combine all three.
Worked example: a call-centre standard
A call centre's standard is an average customer wait of 2.0 minutes, with a 10% tolerance. Weekly averages are 1.8, 2.1, 2.6 and 3.0 minutes. 1. Variances: week 1, \((1.8 - 2.0) \div 2.0 = -10\%\); week 2, \(+5\%\); week 3, \(+30\%\); week 4, \(+50\%\). 2. For waiting time a positive variance is unfavourable. 3. Weeks 1 and 2 are within tolerance. Weeks 3 and 4 are well outside it and the trend is worsening. 4. Investigation shows two agents left and a product launch raised call volumes. 5. Concurrent control: add temporary agents at peak hours now. 6. Feedforward control: plan extra staff before the next launch.
Why controlling matters
Controlling earns its place for three main reasons. First, it shows managers how well the other three functions worked: a missed target may reveal a poor plan, a weak structure or a motivation problem. Second, control systems direct employee behaviour towards organisational goals, because people pay attention to what is measured. Third, controls coordinate activities and resources across the organisation, so that, for instance, purchasing, production and sales work from the same figures. Some firms push controlling down to every employee: workers on a factory line may be empowered to stop production when they spot a defect, so quality is controlled at the source.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, skipping the comparison step and acting on raw numbers without a standard: 132,000 dollars of sales means nothing until you know the target. Second, assuming every positive variance is good; above-target costs or waiting times are unfavourable. Third, overreacting to tiny variances instead of using a sensible tolerance range. Fourth, treating the symptom rather than the cause, for example pressuring salespeople when the real problem is an empty territory. Fifth, lowering standards whenever they are missed. Sixth, relying only on feedback controls, which report problems after the damage is done.
Key takeaways
Controlling assesses progress towards goals and corrects deviations. Its process is to set standards, measure performance, compare the two, take corrective action and feed lessons back into planning. Good standards are measurable and time-bound, and key ones are tracked as KPIs. Variance equals actual minus standard, often as a percentage of the standard; whether it is favourable depends on the measure. Corrective action either restores performance or, when justified, revises the standard. Feedforward, concurrent and feedback controls act before, during and after work. Controlling evaluates the other functions, directs behaviour and coordinates resources.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Assessing progress towards goals and correcting deviations
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A department's monthly budget for supplies is 40,000 dollars, and it spends 43,400 dollars. What is the variance, and is it favourable?
Question 2 of 5
Which is the correct order of the control process?
Question 3 of 5
A restaurant checks every delivery of fresh fish for temperature and quality before it enters the kitchen. What type of control is this?
Question 4 of 5
A shop misses its sales target by 15% because a burst water main closed its street for a month. What is a reasonable corrective action?
Question 5 of 5
Which is NOT one of the main reasons controlling is important?
