Intro to Business › Section F · Management and leadership › Topic F.6
Managerial roles and skills
The four functions describe what management is for, but a manager's actual day is a stream of meetings, phone calls, crises and choices. Henry Mintzberg's ten roles describe that day, and Robert Katz's three skills describe what it takes to handle it at each level.
Functions versus roles
Planning, organising, leading and controlling are the purposes of management, but they do not say much about how managers spend their time. In the late 1960s the Canadian researcher Henry Mintzberg observed chief executives through their working weeks. His book The Nature of Managerial Work (1973) reported that their days were fragmented, fast-paced and full of brief, often spoken interactions, not long periods of quiet planning. He described the work as a set of roles. A role is a set of behaviours that people expect from someone in a particular position, and Mintzberg grouped managers' roles into three families.
Interpersonal roles
Interpersonal roles arise from a manager's formal authority and dealings with people. As figurehead, the manager performs symbolic and ceremonial duties, such as opening a new branch or signing official documents. As leader, the manager hires, trains, motivates and guides employees, for example helping team members set monthly goals. As liaison, the manager builds and maintains contacts with people outside their own unit, inside or outside the organisation, such as representing the retail division at a regional meeting or keeping in touch with suppliers. These relationships give the manager access to information, which leads naturally to the second family of roles.
Informational roles
Informational roles treat the manager as a hub for information. As monitor, the manager hunts for information that matters to the organisation, such as new regulations or a competitor's price change. As disseminator, the manager passes information to the people inside the organisation who need it, such as sharing current production figures with the shop floor. As spokesperson, the manager transmits information to people outside the organisation, for instance presenting results at a shareholders' meeting or speaking to the press after a product recall. Mintzberg argued that managers often know more about their unit than anyone else, precisely because so much information flows through them.
Decisional roles
Decisional roles use that information to make choices. As entrepreneur, the manager looks for new opportunities and starts change, such as introducing a new production process. As disturbance handler, the manager responds to unexpected events and crises, such as a fire, a strike or a key customer's sudden cancellation. As resource allocator, the manager decides who gets money, people, equipment and time, for example approving funds for new computers. As negotiator, the manager represents the organisation in significant negotiations, such as salary talks with a union or a contract with a major supplier. Together the three families give ten roles, and real managers move between them constantly.
Programmed and nonprogrammed decisions
Every role involves decisions, choices among alternatives made in response to a problem or an opportunity. The economist and organisation theorist Herbert Simon distinguished two kinds. Programmed decisions deal with routine situations that recur, so the organisation can write standard procedures for them, such as how to reorder stock when it falls below a set level or how to process a refund. Nonprogrammed decisions deal with new, unusual or complex situations that have no precedent, such as how to respond when a flood destroys a warehouse or whether to enter a new country. Nonprogrammed decisions take most judgement, and they are usually made higher up the hierarchy.
The decision-making process
Whether a decision is routine or new, managers typically move through five steps. 1. Recognise and define the problem or opportunity. 2. Gather information and identify alternative solutions. 3. Evaluate the alternatives and select one or more. 4. Implement the chosen alternative. 5. Gather feedback on whether it is working. Managers can get stuck at any step; endlessly comparing options is called analysis paralysis. Simon also pointed out that real decision-makers have limited time and information, a condition he called bounded rationality, so they often satisfice: they choose the first option that is good enough rather than searching for the perfect one.
Worked example: choosing a supplier
A bakery manager must choose a flour supplier and scores three options from 1 to 10. Weights: price 50%, reliability 30%, service 20%. Supplier A scores 8, 6 and 7; B scores 6, 9 and 8; C scores 9, 5 and 5. 1. Define the problem: the current supplier is closing. 2. Alternatives: A, B and C. 3. Evaluate: A, \(0.5(8) + 0.3(6) + 0.2(7) = 7.2\); B, \(0.5(6) + 0.3(9) + 0.2(8) = 7.3\); C, \(0.5(9) + 0.3(5) + 0.2(5) = 7.0\). 4. Select and implement B, although C is cheapest. 5. Feedback: track late deliveries for three months and revisit if B's reliability slips.
Katz's three managerial skills
In a 1955 Harvard Business Review article, Robert Katz argued that effective managers need three kinds of skill. Technical skills are specialised knowledge and the ability to apply it: preparing a financial statement, programming software or analysing market research. Human relations skills are the interpersonal abilities to understand people, communicate, motivate and work through others, such as giving useful feedback or empowering subordinates. Conceptual skills are the ability to see the organisation as a whole, understand how its parts depend on each other, and relate it to its environment. A skill, in this sense, is the ability to do something proficiently, and all three can be learned.
Skills at different levels
Katz noted that the mix of skills needed changes with the level of the job. Technical skills matter most for supervisory managers, who work closely with the employees producing goods and services and must often solve hands-on problems. Conceptual skills matter most for top managers, who set strategy for the whole organisation. Human relations skills matter at every level, because all managers achieve results through people; a manager with poor people skills may fall back on an autocratic style and alienate staff. Many organisations add a fourth set, global management skills: the ability to work across cultures, languages and time zones, often essential for international assignments.
Worked example: diagnosing a promotion
Jun, an excellent software engineer, is promoted to lead a team of eight. After three months, his team is behind schedule and two members complain he rewrites their code instead of explaining what is wrong. 1. Skills: his technical skills are strong. 2. The complaints point to weak human relations skills: he is not coaching or delegating. 3. Roles: he is neglecting the leader role and over-performing his old job. 4. Action: training in feedback and delegation, and a mentor from another team. Lesson: the skills that win a promotion are not always the skills the new job needs.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, mixing up Mintzberg's families: spokesperson is informational, figurehead is interpersonal, and negotiator is decisional. Second, confusing disseminator (sharing information inside the organisation) with spokesperson (sharing it outside). Third, calling any important decision nonprogrammed; the test is whether the situation is routine enough for a standard procedure. Fourth, saying technical skills matter most at the top; Katz placed conceptual skills there, with human relations skills important at every level. Fifth, assuming the highest-scoring option on one criterion, such as price, must win a weighted comparison.
Key takeaways
Henry Mintzberg (1973) described ten managerial roles in three families: interpersonal (figurehead, leader, liaison), informational (monitor, disseminator, spokesperson) and decisional (entrepreneur, disturbance handler, resource allocator, negotiator). Herbert Simon distinguished programmed decisions, for routine situations, from nonprogrammed ones, for new and complex situations, and noted that bounded rationality leads managers to satisfice. Decisions follow five steps, from defining the problem to gathering feedback. Robert Katz (1955) identified technical, human relations and conceptual skills: technical matter most for supervisors, conceptual for top managers, human relations at all levels.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A set of behaviours expected of someone in a position
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A plant manager explains the company's new safety figures to her shift supervisors at their weekly meeting. Which Mintzberg role is she playing?
Question 2 of 5
Which is an example of a programmed decision?
Question 3 of 5
A manager weights cost at 60% and quality at 40%. Option X scores cost 6 and quality 9; option Y scores cost 9 and quality 5. Which option wins, and with what score?
Question 4 of 5
According to Katz, which skill is most important for top managers?
Question 5 of 5
A manager picks the first job applicant who meets all the minimum requirements instead of interviewing everyone. Which idea does this illustrate?
