Intro to Business › Section I · Motivating employees › Topic I.7
Trends in employee motivation
Firms that compete for skilled people increasingly treat motivation as an investment rather than a cost. This topic looks at the main ways they invest: training, open books, employee ownership, work-life benefits and new ways of managing knowledge workers, and at the absence and turnover costs that make the case for them.
Investing in people
The theories in this section agree that people work harder and stay longer when they grow, feel trusted and see a fair link between effort and reward. Recent practice builds on that in five ways: education and training, open-book management, employee ownership, work-life benefits, and new approaches to knowledge workers. Each costs money up front, so managers judge them partly by what they save in absence and turnover. None of them is a guaranteed fix. A programme works only if it meets real needs and if people believe the firm means it; a benefit announced and then quietly undermined can damage trust more than having no benefit at all.
Education, training and open books
Training raises skill and also signals that the firm values its people, which serves esteem and growth needs. Employees trained on new technology tend to resist change less because they feel competent to handle it. Section H's topic Training and development covers training methods. A related idea is open-book management, popularised by Jack Stack at Springfield Remanufacturing Corporation in Missouri and described in his book The Great Game of Business (1992). Staff are taught to read the firm's financial figures, see how their work moves them and often share in the gains. The aim is for employees to think like owners. It works only if people are taught what the numbers mean, not just shown them.
Employee ownership and ESOPs
An employee stock ownership plan, or ESOP, is a trust that holds company shares on behalf of employees, usually funded by the company rather than by employees' own money. The first ESOP was designed by the lawyer Louis Kelso in 1956, and the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 gave ESOPs their legal framework in the United States. Over time employees can become part or even majority owners. An ESOP differs from a stock option: an option is a right to buy shares at a fixed price, while an ESOP gives employees shares as part of their compensation. The belief behind ownership is that people who share in the firm's value take more care of customers and costs and stay longer.
Worked example: the risk of owning your employer
Employee ownership carries a risk that motivation theory does not show. Suppose an employee has 200,000 dollars of retirement savings, of which 150,000 dollars is in her employer's shares through an ESOP and 50,000 dollars is spread across other investments. 1. Share of savings in one company: \(150{,}000 \div 200{,}000 = 75\%\). 2. The company struggles and its share price falls 60%. 3. Loss: \(0.60 \times 150{,}000 = 90{,}000\) dollars. 4. Proportion of total savings lost: \(90{,}000 \div 200{,}000 = 45\%\), at the same time as her job may be at risk. 5. Check: the same fall on a holding of 20,000 dollars would cost 12,000 dollars. This is why US law requires ESOPs to let older participants diversify part of their holdings. Real decisions about savings need a qualified professional.
Work-life benefits
Many firms now help employees manage the demands of life outside work, aiming for people who are less stressed and more focused. Common benefits include on-site or subsidised childcare, eldercare support, paid family leave, wellness programmes and employee assistance programmes that offer confidential counselling. Sabbaticals give long-serving staff an extended break, paid or unpaid, to rest, travel or learn; the practice began in universities and has spread to some companies, which use it to reward loyalty and prevent burnout. Flexible and hybrid schedules, covered in the previous topic, belong here too. These benefits address work-family conflict, which the Psychology course's topic The social side of work traces to time pressure and spillover strain.
Motivating knowledge workers
Peter Drucker coined the term knowledge worker in 1959 for people who work mainly with information and expertise, such as engineers, analysts and programmers. Drucker argued that they are associates rather than subordinates, because within their speciality they know more than their manager. They tend to be motivated by autonomy, challenge and the respect of peers more than by close direction. One tool for engaging them is the community of practice, a term introduced by Jean Lave and Etienne Wenger in 1991: a group of people who share a craft or profession and learn from each other across departmental lines. Firms use such communities to spread expertise, solve problems and give specialists recognition from the people whose judgement they value most.
Absence and turnover
Absenteeism and turnover are two of the clearest signs that motivation is failing. The absence rate is the share of scheduled work time lost to unplanned absence. The turnover rate is usually measured as
Turnover is costly: each leaver means recruiting, training a replacement and lost output while the new person learns, and frequent departures can lower the morale of those who stay. Turnover among managers can be especially disruptive, as teams adjust to a stream of new bosses. People leave for many reasons, including career opportunities, pay and benefits, and poor supervision.
Worked example: does a retention programme pay?
A firm with an average headcount of 400 loses 72 employees a year. HR estimates each replacement costs 30% of a 45,000-dollar salary. 1. Turnover rate: \(72 \div 400 \times 100 = 18\%\). 2. Cost per leaver: \(0.30 \times 45{,}000 = 13{,}500\) dollars. 3. Annual turnover cost: \(72 \times 13{,}500 = 972{,}000\) dollars. 4. A mentoring and flexible-hours programme costing 250,000 dollars a year is expected to cut leavers to 54. 5. Saving: \(18 \times 13{,}500 = 243{,}000\) dollars, slightly less than the cost. 6. Verdict: on replacement cost alone the programme does not quite pay. The firm should also weigh harder-to-measure gains, such as morale and customer service, and test whether the cost estimate per leaver is realistic.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, confusing an ESOP, which gives employees shares through a trust, with a stock option, a right to buy shares at a fixed price. Second, ignoring the concentration risk of holding much of one's savings in an employer's shares. Third, treating open-book management as simply publishing the accounts; people must be taught to read them. Fourth, computing turnover against year-end headcount instead of average headcount. Fifth, judging retention programmes only on replacement cost and ignoring morale, or only on morale and ignoring cost. Sixth, managing knowledge workers by close direction, which wastes the expertise they were hired for.
Key takeaways
Firms increasingly invest in people through training, open-book management (Jack Stack, 1992), employee ownership, work-life benefits and new ways of managing knowledge workers. ESOPs, first designed in 1956 and given a legal framework in 1974, give employees shares through a trust but concentrate risk. Knowledge workers, Drucker's 1959 term, respond to autonomy and peer respect, and communities of practice harness that. Turnover rate = separations ÷ average headcount × 100, and its cost helps judge whether a programme pays.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Teaching staff to read and act on the firm's financial figures
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A company with an average headcount of 250 had 30 employees leave during the year. What is its turnover rate?
Question 2 of 5
How does an ESOP differ from a stock option?
Question 3 of 5
Which statement best describes open-book management?
Question 4 of 5
According to Peter Drucker, how should knowledge workers generally be managed?
Question 5 of 5
An employee holds 120,000 dollars of her 160,000 dollars of retirement savings in her employer's shares. If those shares fall by 50%, what share of her total savings does she lose?
