Intro to Business › Section H · Human resources and labor relations › Topic H.2

Employee recruitment

A firm can only hire from the people who apply. Recruitment is the work of building a pool of qualified, interested applicants, from inside the organisation or outside it, fairly and at a sensible cost.

Filling a vacancy

When a new job is created or someone leaves, the job description and specification from the previous topic tell the firm what it is looking for. Recruitment is the next step: drawing enough suitably qualified people to apply that the firm has a real choice. It is different from selection, which chooses among those applicants and is covered in the next topic, Employee selection. A weak recruitment effort cannot be rescued by a brilliant interview process, because the best candidate may never have applied. Applicants come from two places: the internal labour market, meaning the firm's current employees, and the external labour market, the much larger pool of people outside it.

Recruiting from inside

Internal recruitment fills jobs through promotions and transfers. Many firms advertise vacancies to staff first through job postings on an intranet or noticeboard, and some run talent reviews in which managers nominate people who are ready to move up. A human resource information system (HRIS), a database holding each employee's skills, qualifications, work history, performance ratings and career interests, lets HR search quickly for internal candidates. A store chain looking for an assistant manager, for example, can list every supervisor who has completed its leadership course and received strong reviews before spending anything on outside advertising.

Inside or outside: the trade-offs

Internal recruitment is usually quicker and cheaper, rewards good performance, signals that there is a future in the firm, and reduces risk because the candidate's track record is already known. Its drawbacks are that it brings in no new ideas, can leave other staff resentful if the process seems unfair, and creates a fresh vacancy wherever the promoted person came from. External recruitment brings new skills and perspectives, widens the range of backgrounds in the workforce, and is the only option when nobody inside has the skills. It costs more, takes longer, and carries more uncertainty, because a stranger's performance is harder to predict.

External channels

Firms match the channel to the job. Online job boards and the firm's own careers web page reach large numbers cheaply. Professional networking sites and employee referral schemes, which pay staff a bonus when someone they recommend is hired, are common for managerial, technical and professional roles. Job fairs, one- or two-day events where employers describe openings and invite applications, suit firms hiring many people at once, such as hotels or theme parks before a busy season. Campus recruiting targets graduating students for entry-level professional jobs. Employment agencies supply temporary staff, and executive search firms, often called headhunters, approach people for senior roles who may not be looking for a move.

Online applications and screening software

Online recruiting lets a large employer receive thousands of applications for popular roles. To cope, most use an applicant tracking system, software that stores applications and screens them for keywords and minimum requirements drawn from the job specification. This saves time, but it has a known weakness: a well-qualified applicant who describes the same experience in different words may be rejected without a human ever reading the résumé. Newer tools that rank applicants automatically raise a further concern, because a system trained on a firm's past hires can repeat any bias in those decisions. Many employers therefore test their screening rules and keep a person involved in reviewing the results.

Worked example: working back from the hires

A hotel, call it Harbourview, needs 6 new front-desk staff. Past records give its recruiting yield ratios: 25% of applicants are invited to interview, 40% of those interviewed receive an offer, and 75% of offers are accepted. 1. Offers needed: \(6 \div 0.75 = 8\). 2. Interviews needed: \(8 \div 0.40 = 20\). 3. Applications needed: \(20 \div 0.25 = 80\). 4. The hotel spends 4,800 dollars on advertising and a job fair, so the cost per hire is \(4800 \div 6 = 800\) dollars. 5. Check forwards: 25% of 80 is 20 interviews, 40% of 20 is 8 offers, and 75% of 8 is 6 hires. If the campaign attracts only 50 applications, the hotel knows early that it must widen its search.

Recruitment branding and realistic previews

Applicants choose employers as well as the other way round. Recruitment branding, also called employer branding, means presenting an accurate and positive image of what it is like to work for the firm: its culture, values, development opportunities and the views of current employees. The word accurate matters. A realistic job preview tells candidates about the less attractive parts of a job too, such as night shifts, physically tiring work or demanding customers. Some people then withdraw, but those who accept know what to expect, and studies of realistic previews generally find that new hires who received one are somewhat less likely to quit early because the job surprised them.

Worked example: inside or outside?

A software company, call it Brightpath, must fill a new data-security manager role within three months. 1. HR searches its HRIS and finds two engineers with some security experience but no management experience. 2. The job specification calls for a security certification and several years of leading a team, which neither has yet. 3. Promoting one of them would also leave an engineering vacancy to fill. 4. The firm decides to recruit externally through a specialist professional network and an executive search firm. 5. To keep the internal route open for the future, it offers both engineers a development plan towards the certification. Check: the choice follows the job specification, not habit or convenience.

Fair and inclusive recruiting

Where and how a firm advertises shapes who applies. Relying only on employee referrals tends to produce applicants who resemble the current workforce, so many firms combine referrals with wide advertising. Job advertisements that use neutral wording and list only genuine requirements attract a broader pool. In the US, Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits employment discrimination, including in recruitment, based on race, colour, religion, sex or national origin, and the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 generally bars advertisements that state an age preference against people aged 40 or over. This topic describes how such laws work in general; real hiring decisions need advice from a qualified professional.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, confusing recruitment with selection: recruitment builds the pool, and selection chooses from it. Second, assuming internal recruitment is always better; it is cheaper and motivating, but it cannot supply skills the firm lacks. Third, working back from hires and stopping early, for example treating the number of interviews as the number of applications needed. Fourth, trusting screening software without checking whether it rejects qualified people. Fifth, using employer branding that oversells the job, which raises early turnover when reality disappoints.

Key takeaways

Recruitment attracts a pool of qualified applicants from the internal labour market (current staff) or the external labour market. Internal recruitment through promotions and transfers is quicker and cheaper and rewards staff; external recruitment brings new skills and perspectives at higher cost and risk. Channels include job boards, careers pages, networking sites, referrals, job fairs, campus visits, agencies and executive search firms. Yield ratios let planners work back from the hires they need. Recruitment branding should be accurate, and realistic job previews reduce early quitting. Fair recruiting advertises widely and follows anti-discrimination law.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Recruitment

Building a pool of suitably qualified applicants

Selection then chooses from the pool.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A bank emails all its branch staff about an opening for a loans officer and invites them to apply before the job is advertised publicly. What is the bank doing?

Question 2 of 5

A firm needs 4 hires. 80% of offers are accepted, 25% of interviewees get an offer, and 40% of applicants are interviewed. How many applications does it need?

Question 3 of 5

Why does a care home tell applicants plainly about weekend shifts and physically tiring work before they accept a job?

Question 4 of 5

Which is an advantage of external recruitment over internal recruitment?

Question 5 of 5

A firm's applicant tracking system rejects a strong applicant whose résumé says "client support" instead of the keyword "customer service". What weakness does this show?

← Previous topicNext topic →