Intro to Business › Section H · Human resources and labor relations › Topic H.3
Employee selection
Once a pool of applicants exists, the firm has to decide who is most likely to succeed in the job. Good selection relies on job-related evidence gathered the same way for every candidate, not on gut feeling.
Choosing from the pool
Selection is the process of deciding which applicants have the qualifications and qualities needed to succeed in a particular job. Most firms use a series of steps: initial screening, employment testing, a selection interview, background and reference checks, sometimes a medical examination or drug test, and finally the decision to hire. Because an applicant can be turned down at any step and must clear each one to receive an offer, this is called the successive hurdles approach. Early hurdles are cheap and quick, so they come first; expensive steps such as panel interviews are saved for the shorter list who remain.
Initial screening
Screening compares each application or résumé with the minimum requirements in the job specification: the right qualification, a licence, a certain amount of relevant experience. Many firms add a short phone or video conversation of about 15 to 30 minutes to confirm basic facts, the applicant's availability and their interest in the job. The aim is not to find the best candidate yet, only to remove those who clearly do not meet the stated requirements. Applying the same criteria to everyone at this stage keeps the process fair and makes it easier to explain later why someone did not progress.
Employment tests
Tests measure qualities that interviews reveal poorly. Cognitive ability tests assess reasoning and learning speed; skills tests measure typing, coding or arithmetic; work samples ask the applicant to do a piece of the real job, such as preparing a short sales pitch; and personality inventories measure traits such as conscientiousness. A useful test must be reliable, giving consistent results if the same person takes it again, and valid, meaning scores are genuinely related to performance in this job. A test that is not job-related wastes time and can unfairly exclude groups of applicants.
Selection interviews
The interview is the most widely used selection tool. In an unstructured interview the conversation wanders wherever the interviewer takes it, so candidates are compared on different evidence. In a structured interview every candidate is asked the same job-related questions and answers are scored against agreed standards; research consistently finds structured interviews predict job performance better. Two common question types are behavioural questions, which ask about past actions ("Tell me about a time you handled an angry customer"), and situational questions, which pose a realistic scenario ("What would you do if a customer demanded a refund you could not give?"). Senior roles often use a panel of several interviewers.
Worked example: scoring a structured interview
A clinic hiring an IT support specialist rates each candidate from 1 to 5 on three criteria, weighted by importance: technical skill 40%, communication 30%, teamwork 30%. 1. Candidate A scores 5, 3 and 3. Weighted score: \(0.4(5) + 0.3(3) + 0.3(3) = 3.8\). 2. Candidate B scores 4, 4 and 4. Weighted score: \(0.4(4) + 0.3(4) + 0.3(4) = 4.0\). 3. Candidate B ranks first, even though A is the strongest technically. 4. Check: the weights add to \(0.4 + 0.3 + 0.3 = 1\), so each total stays on the 1 to 5 scale. The panel agreed the weights before interviewing, so the result reflects the job's needs rather than whichever candidate made the best first impression.
Checks, medical exams and drug tests
Applicants who pass the interview usually face background and reference checks to confirm employment history, qualifications and, for some roles, criminal records or credit history. In the US, when an employer uses a background-check company, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (1970) requires the applicant's written permission, and many states and cities add their own limits. Some jobs require a medical examination to confirm that a person can perform essential tasks; under the Americans with Disabilities Act (1990), such exams generally come only after a conditional job offer and must be given to everyone offered that kind of job. Drug testing is common in safety-sensitive work such as transport. This describes the general rules; real decisions need a qualified professional.
The decision to hire
When a candidate has cleared every hurdle, the hiring decision is usually made by the manager the new employee will report to, with HR advising on pay, policy and paperwork. An offer may be conditional, for example on passing a drug test or confirming a professional licence. Throughout, applicants should be treated rather like valued customers: acknowledged promptly, kept informed and thanked, including those who are turned down. A rejected applicant may be a future customer, a future applicant for a different role, or someone who tells friends and online reviewers how they were treated.
Worked example: fixing an interview question
An interviewer for a sales role plans to ask, "Do you have young children at home?" 1. Identify the real concern: the job involves travel two weeks each month. 2. Notice the problem: the question asks about family status rather than the job, and in the US questions like this can be used as evidence of sex discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. 3. Rewrite it around the requirement: "This role involves travel about two weeks each month. Are you able to meet that schedule?" 4. Ask it of every candidate, men and women alike. 5. Check: the new question gives the firm exactly the information it needs and nothing it should not use.
Keeping selection fair
Interviewers are human, and several biases distort judgements. The similar-to-me effect favours candidates who share the interviewer's background or interests; first impressions formed in the opening minutes colour everything after; and a single striking trait can outweigh the rest of the evidence. Structured questions, scoring guides, trained and diverse interview panels, and recording the reasons for each decision all reduce these effects. US federal law bars employment decisions based on race, colour, religion, sex, national origin, age (40 and over), disability or genetic information, so questions should stay on the job and its requirements.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, confusing reliability with validity: a test can give consistent scores and still fail to predict job performance. Second, treating the interview as a friendly chat; unstructured interviews compare candidates on different evidence. Third, mixing up question types: behavioural questions ask what you did, situational questions ask what you would do. Fourth, adding weighted scores without checking that the weights sum to 1. Fifth, asking about family, religion or health when the real concern is a job requirement that can be asked about directly.
Key takeaways
Selection decides which applicants are most likely to succeed, usually through successive hurdles: screening, testing, interview, checks, any medical exam or drug test, and the hiring decision. Useful tests are reliable and valid. Structured interviews, with the same scored questions for everyone, predict performance better than unstructured ones; behavioural questions ask about the past and situational ones about a scenario. Weighted scoring makes comparisons explicit. US law shapes background checks, medical exams and interview questions. Fair selection relies on job-related evidence and treats every applicant with respect.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Deciding which applicants are most likely to succeed in the job
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A firm screens résumés, then tests, then interviews, then checks references, and an applicant can be turned down at any step. What is this approach called?
Question 2 of 5
Criteria weights are 50% skill, 25% communication and 25% teamwork. A candidate scores 4, 2 and 5 out of 5. What is the weighted score?
Question 3 of 5
Which of these is a situational interview question?
Question 4 of 5
A test gives each applicant almost the same score when they retake it, but the scores show no link to later job performance. What is true of the test?
Question 5 of 5
A warehouse job requires lifting 20 kg boxes. Which interview question focuses on the job requirement?
