Intro to Business › Section B · Ethics and social responsibility › Topic B.4

Responsibilities to stakeholders

A company that is admired for its conduct meets its obligations to the people its decisions affect. This topic works through those groups one by one, employees, customers, society and the environment, and investors, and shows how firms handle the conflicts between them.

Who the stakeholders are

Stakeholders are the people and groups a business is answerable to, because its decisions affect them or because it depends on them. The main groups are employees, customers, investors and the general public, which includes local communities and, through them, the natural environment. Suppliers and lenders are often added. Stakeholders' interests overlap but also clash: shareholders may want higher dividends, employees higher pay, customers lower prices and neighbours less traffic from a new depot. Managing a socially responsible business, the subject of the previous topic, largely means balancing these claims openly and fairly rather than ignoring the groups with the least power.

Responsibilities to employees

A business's most basic contribution to its workers is a job, and with it an income. Beyond that, employers must provide a safe, healthy workplace free from discrimination and harassment; in the United States the Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 sets national safety standards, and the topic "Trends in ethics: diversity, data, and governance" covers anti-discrimination law. Responsible employers also pay fairly, offer as much job security as they can, and invest in training. Many empower employees to make decisions and suggest solutions to problems. Empowerment tends to raise employees' sense of self-worth, which can increase productivity and reduce absence.

Responsibilities to customers

A business must deliver what it promises and be honest in its dealings with customers. That means safe products, accurate information, fair prices and terms that are easy to understand, protection of customers' personal data, and a fair way to handle complaints. In 1962 President John F. Kennedy set out a consumer bill of rights: the right to safety, the right to be informed, the right to choose and the right to be heard. Many later consumer protection laws build on these ideas. Surveys suggest many consumers, especially younger ones, prefer brands they see as honest and socially responsible, so meeting these duties can also be good business.

Responsibilities to society

A business serves its community by providing jobs, goods and services, and by paying taxes that fund schools, hospitals and roads. Some firms make their commitment to society formal. A certified B Corporation is a for-profit company that has been assessed by the not-for-profit B Lab as meeting its standards for how the firm treats people and the planet, how openly it reports and how it is held to account, and that must be reassessed periodically. Many US states also offer a legal form called a benefit corporation, whose directors must consider the effect of decisions on society and the environment as well as on shareholders. Certification and legal form are separate: a firm can have either one, or both.

Protecting the environment

Businesses use natural resources and produce waste and emissions, so they share responsibility for protecting the environment. Many have set targets to cut greenhouse gas emissions, some aiming for net zero, meaning that any emissions left are balanced by removals from the atmosphere. Others switch to renewable energy, redesign packaging, cut water use or make products easier to repair and recycle. The risk on the other side is greenwashing: making misleading claims about a product's or company's environmental benefits, such as calling a product eco-friendly without evidence. Regulators in the US, the European Union and the UK have increased scrutiny of green claims, and greenwashing destroys trust once exposed.

Corporate philanthropy

Corporate philanthropy is charitable giving by companies. It includes cash donations, gifts of equipment and products, and support for employees' volunteer work, such as paid volunteering days or matching employees' own donations. After disasters, companies often send money, supplies and logistics help quickly, because they already run supply chains and transport networks. Some firms commit to a fixed share of their resources. The Pledge 1% movement, for example, asks companies to commit a share such as 1% of equity, profit, product or employee time to their communities. Philanthropy is the top layer of Carroll's pyramid, the most voluntary of a firm's responsibilities.

Worked example: a 1% pledge

An invented software firm with 400 employees and a pre-tax profit of 12 million dollars adopts a 1% pledge for profit and staff time. 1. Cash: \(0.01 \times 12000000 = 120000\) dollars a year to charities. 2. Time: each employee works about 2,000 hours a year, so total hours are \(400 \times 2000 = 800000\). 3. One per cent of that time: \(0.01 \times 800000 = 8000\) volunteer hours, about 20 hours, or two and a half working days, per employee. 4. Interpret: the time pledge may be worth more to charities than the cash, because skilled help is hard to buy. 5. Check: \(8000 \div 400 = 20\) hours each.

Responsibilities to investors

A company owes its investors honest, accurate financial reporting, careful use of their money and a reasonable return. Some investors also want their money to reflect their values. Social investing means limiting investments to securities, such as shares and bonds, of companies whose conduct fits the investor's beliefs, for instance by excluding tobacco, weapons or companies with poor environmental records. Many investors also weigh environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors when judging companies. ESG investing grew quickly in the 2010s but has become politically contested in some US states, and critics question how consistently ESG ratings measure real impact. Any real investment decision needs a qualified professional's advice.

Worked example: a factory decision

An invented appliance maker considers moving production from an ageing plant in a small town to a cheaper site. 1. Investors: lower costs could raise profits and the share price. 2. Employees: 600 jobs in the town are at risk; the firm could offer transfers, retraining or a phased closure. 3. Customers: prices might fall, but quality and delivery must be protected during the move. 4. Community: the town loses wages and tax revenue; the firm might help attract a new employer to the site. 5. Environment: the new plant could use cleaner energy. Conclusion: no option pleases everyone, but naming every stakeholder, measuring effects and explaining the choice openly is what responsibility to stakeholders looks like.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, treating shareholders as the only stakeholders; employees, customers and the general public are owed obligations too. Second, confusing a certified B Corporation, a certification awarded by B Lab, with a benefit corporation, a legal form set by state law. Third, accepting green claims at face value; greenwashing is common enough that evidence matters. Fourth, thinking social investing means one fixed rulebook; different investors and funds apply different screens. Fifth, assuming a decision can satisfy every stakeholder fully; responsibility means weighing conflicts openly, not pretending they do not exist.

Key takeaways

Stakeholders are the groups a business is responsible to: employees, customers, investors and the general public, including communities and the environment. Firms owe employees jobs, safety, fairness and respect; customers safe products, honest information and a hearing; society jobs, taxes and good citizenship, which some formalise as B Corps or benefit corporations; and the environment real reductions in harm, not greenwashing. Corporate philanthropy gives cash, products and time. Investors are owed honest reporting and a reasonable return, and some practise social investing or weigh ESG factors.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Stakeholders

The people and groups a business is answerable to

Employees, customers, investors, the public.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A city council worries that a firm's new depot will bring heavy traffic to a residential street. Which stakeholder group is the council speaking for?

Question 2 of 5

Which of these is a responsibility a business owes its employees?

Question 3 of 5

A firm with 250 employees, each working about 1,800 hours a year, pledges 1% of staff time to volunteering. How many volunteer hours is that a year?

Question 4 of 5

An investor refuses to buy shares in tobacco and weapons companies because they conflict with her beliefs. What is this practice called?

Question 5 of 5

A drinks company labels a bottle "planet-friendly" though it has no evidence of any environmental benefit. What is this an example of?

← Previous topicNext topic →