Intro to Business › Section B · Ethics and social responsibility › Topic B.3

Managing a socially responsible business

What does a business owe society beyond obeying the law and making money for its owners? Corporate social responsibility tries to answer that question, and the answers range from "nothing more" to "a great deal". This topic sets out the main ideas, the debate and the ways firms measure their impact.

What corporate social responsibility means

Corporate social responsibility (CSR) is a business's concern for the wellbeing of the wider society, expressed through obligations that go beyond what the law or contracts require. Two points follow from this definition. First, CSR is voluntary. Cleaning up a polluting factory because a regulator demands it is compliance, not CSR; cutting pollution further than the law requires is CSR. Second, the obligations are broad: they reach beyond the company's investors to workers, suppliers, customers, local communities and society at large. The management writer Peter Drucker suggested looking first at what an organisation does to society, and then at what it can do for society.

The pyramid of responsibilities

The management scholar Archie Carroll described CSR as a pyramid of four responsibilities, in a 1991 article. At the base is economic responsibility: be profitable, because a firm that cannot survive can do little else. Next is legal responsibility: obey the law. Above that is ethical responsibility: do what is right, just and fair, even where no law requires it. At the top is philanthropic responsibility: be a good corporate citizen by contributing resources to the community. The four are distinct but together make up the whole. The ordering does not mean profit matters more morally; it means each layer rests on the one below.

Worked example: placing actions on the pyramid

Place each action of an invented supermarket chain on Carroll's pyramid. 1. Raising prices slightly to cover rising costs so the business stays viable: economic. 2. Checking customers' ages before selling alcohol, as the law requires: legal. 3. Paying suppliers on time even when a delay would be legal and would help its cash: ethical. 4. Giving surplus food to local food banks and paying staff for volunteering days: philanthropic. 5. Check: only item 2 is required by law; items 3 and 4 are the voluntary responsibilities that CSR is about, and item 1 is the foundation that makes the others possible.

The debate: Friedman and the stakeholder view

Not everyone agrees that businesses should take on social goals. In a well-known 1970 New York Times Magazine essay, the economist Milton Friedman argued that the social responsibility of business is to increase its profits, within the rules of the game, without deception or fraud. Managers who spend shareholders' money on causes of their own choosing, he said, are in effect imposing taxes; social goals belong to individuals and governments. The stakeholder view replies that a business depends on its workers, customers, suppliers and communities, so it has duties to all of them, and that responsible behaviour often supports long-term success by building trust, loyalty and reputation.

Three kinds of behaviour

A company's conduct can be sorted into three broad categories. Illegal and irresponsible behaviour breaks the law and harms others, as in accounting fraud; it can ruin companies, employees' savings and whole communities, and it can lead to fines and prison. Irresponsible but legal behaviour stays inside the law yet still treats people badly, such as making health claims for a product without good evidence, aggressive selling to vulnerable customers, or abrupt mass layoffs with no support. Legal and responsible behaviour obeys the law and goes further, and most businesses aim to be in this group most of the time. The middle category is where CSR debates are most heated.

The triple bottom line

Because profit alone does not show a firm's full impact, the author John Elkington proposed in 1994 that companies report a triple bottom line: people, planet and profit, meaning social, environmental and financial performance. Many large companies now publish sustainability or impact reports alongside their annual financial reports, covering measures such as greenhouse gas emissions, water use, workplace injuries, staff diversity and community investment. Critics warn that such reports can be selective, highlighting good news and leaving out the bad, and that measures differ from firm to firm. Good practice is to report consistent measures every year, so readers can see trends rather than isolated claims.

Worked example: emissions intensity

An invented logistics firm emitted 12,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide on revenue of 40 million dollars last year, and 11,400 tonnes on revenue of 46 million dollars this year. 1. Last year's intensity: \(12000 \div 40 = 300\) tonnes per million dollars of revenue. 2. This year's: \(11400 \div 46 \approx 248\) tonnes per million dollars. 3. Change in intensity: \((248 - 300) \div 300 \approx -17\%\). 4. Change in total emissions: \((11400 - 12000) \div 12000 = -5\%\). 5. Interpret: both fell, but intensity fell much faster because the firm grew. A report showing only intensity could hide rising total emissions, so readers should look for both.

CSR in practice

Many companies combine several forms of CSR. Some give paid volunteering time, so that employees can help local charities during working hours. Some match employees' donations to good causes. Some redesign products and supply chains to cut waste and emissions. A few go further and change their ownership. In 2022 the founder of the outdoor-clothing company Patagonia transferred its ownership to a trust and a not-for-profit organisation, so that profits not reinvested in the business would fund environmental work. Supporters see a model of purpose-driven business; sceptics note that such choices are easiest for privately owned firms with loyal, premium customers.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, calling legally required actions CSR: compliance is the legal layer, while CSR is voluntary. Second, reading Carroll's pyramid as a moral ranking with profit at the top of importance; profit is the foundation, not the summit. Third, misquoting Friedman as saying firms may do anything for profit; he said within the rules, without deception or fraud. Fourth, assuming legal behaviour is always responsible; the irresponsible but legal category exists. Fifth, judging environmental progress from intensity figures alone, which can fall while total emissions rise.

Key takeaways

Corporate social responsibility is a business's concern for society's welfare through voluntary obligations beyond legal and contractual requirements, extending to workers, suppliers, customers, communities and society. Carroll's pyramid has economic, legal, ethical and philanthropic layers, with profitability as the base. Friedman argued that the social responsibility of business is to increase profits within the rules; the stakeholder view sees wider duties. Conduct may be illegal and irresponsible, irresponsible but legal, or legal and responsible. The triple bottom line reports people, planet and profit, and both total and intensity measures matter.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Corporate social responsibility (CSR)

Concern for society's welfare through obligations beyond what law or contracts require

Voluntary and broad.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Which responsibility forms the base of Carroll's pyramid of corporate social responsibility?

Question 2 of 5

Which statement best summarises Milton Friedman's 1970 argument?

Question 3 of 5

A company sells a supplement with bold health claims that are not backed by good evidence, in a way that does not break any law. Which category of behaviour is this?

Question 4 of 5

A firm's emissions rose from 5,000 to 5,200 tonnes while its revenue rose from 20 million to 26 million dollars. Which statement is correct?

Question 5 of 5

Which of these actions is an example of corporate social responsibility rather than legal compliance?

← Previous topicNext topic →