Calculus › Section H · Applications of integrals › Topic H.3
Volume by cylindrical shells
Disks and washers slice a solid of revolution perpendicular to the axis. Cylindrical shells slice it the other way, peeling the solid into thin layers like the paper on a roll of towels, and they often turn a nasty integral into an easy one.
A roll of paper towels
Unroll a fresh sheet from a paper towel roll and you have a long thin rectangle: its length is the circumference \(2\pi r\) of the roll, its width is the height of the cylinder, and its thickness is one layer of paper. That is the whole idea of the shell method. Instead of cutting a solid of revolution into flat disks stacked along the axis, cut it into thin cylindrical shells nested around the axis, like tree rings around a trunk. Each shell is a rolled-up rectangle, and a rectangle's volume is easy: length times height times thickness.
Unrolling one shell
Rotate the region under \(y = f(x) \ge 0\) from \(x = a\) to \(x = b\) about the \(y\)-axis, and focus on one thin vertical strip at position \(x\), of width \(dx\), running from the \(x\)-axis up to the curve. Sweeping it around the axis produces a shell. Unroll it: the strip travels a circle of radius \(x\), so the unrolled length is the circumference \(2\pi x\); the shell's height is the strip's height \(f(x)\); its thickness is \(dx\). So one shell contributes about
and adding the shells gives
The factor \(2\pi x\) is the shell's circumference, so the radius \(x\) always appears inside the integral.
Radius and height, in general
Strip away the specific axis and the method reads: a shell's volume is \(2\pi\) times its radius times its height times its thickness. The radius is the distance from the strip to the axis of rotation. For rotation about the vertical line \(x = c\), a strip at position \(x\) has radius \(|x - c|\). The height is the length of the strip, measured parallel to the axis: top minus bottom for a vertical strip, right minus left for a horizontal one. About the \(x\)-axis, horizontal strips play the same role, and the integral runs in \(y\): \(V = 2\pi\int_c^d y\,g(y)\,dy\) when the region stretches from the \(y\)-axis out to \(x = g(y)\). Identify radius and height before writing anything down.
Worked example: about the y-axis
Rotate the region under \(y = 4 - x^2\) on \([0, 2]\) about the \(y\)-axis. A vertical strip at \(x\) sits \(x\) units from the axis, with height \(4 - x^2\), so
Cross-check with washers: \(x = \sqrt{4 - y}\), and \(V = \pi\int_0^4 (4 - y)\,dy = \pi\left[4y - \frac{y^2}{2}\right]_0^4 = 8\pi\). Both slicing directions agree. The shell integral avoided solving for \(x\) and kept a polynomial integrand throughout.
Worked example: about a shifted vertical line
Rotate the region under \(y = x^2\) on \([0, 1]\) about the line \(x = 2\). The strip at \(x\) is \(2 - x\) units from the axis (positive throughout, since the region lies left of the line), and its height is \(x^2\):
Washer cross-check, for confidence: at height \(y\) the region runs from \(x = \sqrt{y}\) to \(x = 1\), giving outer radius \(2 - \sqrt{y}\) and inner radius 1, and \(\pi\int_0^1\big[(2 - \sqrt{y})^2 - 1\big]dy = \frac{5\pi}{6}\) as well. The radius is measured from the axis, not from the \(y\)-axis.
Horizontal shells
Swap every role and shells work about horizontal axes too. Rotate the region between \(x = y^2\) and the \(y\)-axis, for \(0 \le y \le 3\), about the \(x\)-axis. Slice horizontally: the strip at height \(y\) sweeps a shell with radius \(y\) and length \(y^2\), so
The washer check runs in \(x\): at position \(x\) the region runs from \(y = \sqrt{x}\) up to \(y = 3\), so the outer radius is 3, the inner radius is \(\sqrt{x}\), and \(\pi\int_0^9 (9 - x)\,dx = \frac{81\pi}{2}\). The pattern never changes: radius times height times \(2\pi\), integrated in the variable that runs along the strips.
Choosing shells or washers
For any solid of revolution, both methods are available, and they must agree. The practical rule: strips parallel to the axis of rotation give shells; slices perpendicular to it give disks or washers. Shells shine when the region is described by \(y = f(x)\) but the axis is vertical, because washers would demand \(x\) as a function of \(y\), sometimes impossible to write cleanly. Washers shine when the boundary curves are already distances from the axis, like rotating about the \(x\)-axis. When in doubt, set up both; the easier integral wins, and if the two disagree, one of the setups is wrong.
Common mistakes to avoid
The signature error is dropping the radius: \(2\pi\int f(x)\,dx\) is not a shell volume, because each shell's volume contains the circumference \(2\pi x\), not just \(2\pi\). Second, using the wrong radius for a shifted axis: about \(x = 2\), the radius is \(2 - x\), not \(x\). Third, taking the height as the function value when the region's lower edge is another curve rather than the \(x\)-axis; the height is the strip's own length, top minus bottom. Fourth, forgetting that about a horizontal axis the shell integral runs in \(y\) with radius \(y\). And never mix conventions inside one integral: strips are either all vertical or all horizontal.
Key takeaways
Shells slice a solid of revolution into nested cylinders, each an unrolled rectangle of volume \(2\pi\) × radius × height × thickness. About the \(y\)-axis, \(V = 2\pi\int_a^b x\,f(x)\,dx\); about \(x = c\), replace the radius by \(|x - c|\); about the \(x\)-axis with horizontal strips, \(V = 2\pi\int y\,g(y)\,dy\). Choose shells when strips parallel to the axis keep the integrand simple, washers when slices perpendicular do, and expect both to give the same number.
Flashcards
Flashcard
V = 2π∫ x f(x) dx
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
The region under y = 4 − x² on [0, 2] is rotated about the y-axis. What is the volume?
Question 2 of 5
The region under y = x² on [0, 1] is rotated about the vertical line x = 2. What is the radius of the shell at position x?
Question 3 of 5
The region between x = y² and the y-axis, for 0 ≤ y ≤ 3, is rotated about the x-axis. What is the volume?
Question 4 of 5
The region under y = 4 − x² on [0, 2] is rotated about the y-axis. Which integral is the cylindrical shell setup?
Question 5 of 5
When do shells usually beat washers?
Standards: Beyond AP
