Chemistry › Section B · Atoms, molecules, and ions › Topic B.1

Early and modern atomic theory

Nobody has ever needed to see an atom to know a great deal about it. Careful weighing, glowing tubes and a beam fired at gold foil let chemists build, test and rebuild a picture of the atom, and every step shows how evidence beats a good guess.

An old idea waiting for evidence

In the fifth century BCE the Greek thinkers Leucippus and Democritus argued that matter could not be cut up forever: eventually you would reach tiny particles they called atomos, meaning uncuttable. Aristotle disagreed: for him all matter was a blend of earth, water, air and fire that could be divided without end, and his view held for about two thousand years. Neither side ran experiments. The turning point came in the late 1700s, when Antoine Lavoisier weighed reactions in sealed vessels and found that the total mass did not change.

Dalton's atomic theory

John Dalton, an English schoolteacher, set out an atomic theory in the first decade of the 1800s and published it in A New System of Chemical Philosophy (1808). Its main claims, in modern words: 1. All matter is made of extremely small particles called atoms. 2. All atoms of one element are identical in mass and properties. 3. Atoms of different elements differ from one another. 4. A compound forms when atoms of different elements join in a fixed, small whole-number ratio. 5. A chemical reaction rearranges atoms; it never creates or destroys them. Each claim could be tested against the mass measurements chemists were already making.

Three laws the theory explains

The law of conservation of mass says mass is neither gained nor lost in a chemical reaction, which follows if atoms are only rearranged. The law of definite proportions, from Joseph Proust in the 1790s, says a pure compound always has the same make-up by mass, whatever its source; that follows if the atom ratio is fixed. Dalton added the law of multiple proportions: when two elements form more than one compound, the masses of one element that combine with a fixed mass of the other are in a small whole-number ratio. In \(\text{SO}_2\) and \(\text{SO}_3\), the oxygen per gram of sulfur is in the ratio 2 : 3, because each molecule holds 2 or 3 oxygen atoms.

Worked example: testing the mass laws

Three samples contain only hydrogen and oxygen. A: 1.26 g hydrogen with 10.0 g oxygen. B: 0.504 g hydrogen with 4.00 g oxygen. C: 0.378 g hydrogen with 6.00 g oxygen. 1. Find grams of oxygen per gram of hydrogen. A: \(10.0 \div 1.26 = 7.94\). B: \(4.00 \div 0.504 = 7.94\). C: \(6.00 \div 0.378 = 15.9\). 2. A and B match, so they can be the same compound, as definite proportions requires. 3. C differs, so it is a different compound. 4. Compare: \(15.9 \div 7.94 = 2.00\), a small whole number, as multiple proportions predicts. Check: A and B fit water, \(\text{H}_2\text{O}\); C fits hydrogen peroxide, \(\text{H}_2\text{O}_2\), with twice the oxygen per hydrogen.

Thomson finds the electron

In 1897 J. J. Thomson studied cathode rays, beams that stream from the negative electrode (the cathode) when a high voltage is applied across a glass tube pumped nearly empty of air. The rays bent towards a positively charged plate, so they were negative. By balancing the bending caused by electric and magnetic fields, Thomson measured their charge-to-mass ratio, and it was the same whatever metal the electrodes were made of. The particles were far lighter than any atom: an electron is about 1,840 times lighter than a hydrogen atom. Thomson concluded that these particles, now called electrons, are part of every atom, so atoms are not indivisible after all.

Millikan measures the charge

Thomson knew the ratio of charge to mass but neither value alone. From 1909 Robert Millikan sprayed tiny oil drops between two charged plates, gave them electric charges and adjusted the voltage until the electric force on each drop balanced its weight. Every charge he measured was a whole-number multiple of one smallest value, the elementary charge:

e = 1.602 \times 10^{-19}\ \text{C}

That is the size of the charge on one electron. Dividing it by Thomson's ratio, \(1.759 \times 10^{11}\ \text{C/kg}\), gives the electron's mass: \(\frac{1.602 \times 10^{-19}\ \text{C}}{1.759 \times 10^{11}\ \text{C/kg}} = 9.11 \times 10^{-31}\ \text{kg}\).

Worked example: finding the charge quantum

Four oil drops carry 4.81, 8.00, 12.82 and \(6.41 \times 10^{-19}\) C. Is the charge quantised, and how many extra electrons does each carry? 1. Try the smallest value as the unit: \(8.00 \div 4.81 = 1.66\), not a whole number, so the smallest drop must carry more than one unit. 2. Try \(e = 1.602 \times 10^{-19}\) C. Then \(4.81 \div 1.602 = 3.00\), \(8.00 \div 1.602 = 4.99\), \(12.82 \div 1.602 = 8.00\) and \(6.41 \div 1.602 = 4.00\). 3. All are whole numbers within measurement error, so the drops carry 3, 5, 8 and 4 extra electrons. 4. Check: \(5 \times 1.602 = 8.01\), which matches 8.00 to within rounding.

Rutherford's gold foil

Something positive must balance the electrons. Thomson's plum pudding model (1904) pictured electrons dotted through a spread-out ball of positive charge. To test it, Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden, working with Ernest Rutherford, fired alpha particles (small, fast, positive particles given off by some radioactive elements) at a very thin sheet of gold foil. A spread-out charge could only nudge them. Most passed straight through, but a few swerved sharply and a very small fraction bounced almost straight back. In 1911 Rutherford explained this: nearly all of an atom's mass and all of its positive charge sit in a tiny central nucleus, and the rest of the atom is mostly empty space occupied by electrons.

Protons, isotopes and neutrons

By about 1920 Rutherford had shown that the hydrogen nucleus is a building block of every other nucleus and named it the proton, a positive particle. Meanwhile, in 1913 Frederick Soddy found that some elements have atoms with different masses but identical chemistry, and called them isotopes. A puzzle remained: the protons in a nucleus supplied only about half of its mass, or less. In 1932 James Chadwick found the answer, the neutron, a particle with no charge and almost the same mass as a proton. That explained isotopes: they share a proton count and differ only in how many neutrons they hold.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, mixing up the mass laws: definite proportions compares samples of one compound; multiple proportions compares two different compounds of the same elements. Second, expecting the multiple-proportions ratio always to be 2 : 1; it can be 3 : 2 or 4 : 1, as long as it is small and whole. Third, saying cathode rays bend towards the negative plate; they are negative, so they are pulled towards the positive one. Fourth, thinking the gold foil showed atoms are solid; most alpha particles passed through, showing mostly empty space. Fifth, treating Dalton as simply right: atoms can be divided, and isotopes mean atoms of one element can differ in mass.

Key takeaways

Dalton's theory explained conservation of mass, definite proportions and multiple proportions by picturing atoms that combine in whole-number ratios and are only rearranged in reactions. Thomson's cathode rays revealed the electron and its charge-to-mass ratio; Millikan's oil drops gave its charge, \(1.602 \times 10^{-19}\) C, and so its mass, \(9.11 \times 10^{-31}\) kg. Rutherford's gold foil experiment replaced the plum pudding with a tiny, dense, positive nucleus surrounded by mostly empty space. The proton, isotopes and Chadwick's neutron completed the modern picture.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Atomos

Greek word meaning uncuttable, the origin of the word atom

Leucippus and Democritus, fifth century BCE, with no experiments.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

Two compounds contain only nitrogen and oxygen. Per 1.000 g of nitrogen, compound P contains 0.571 g of oxygen and compound Q contains 2.284 g of oxygen. What is the ratio of oxygen in Q to oxygen in P?

Question 2 of 5

Three oil drops carry charges of 4.81, 6.41 and 9.62 × 10⁻¹⁹ C. Using e = 1.602 × 10⁻¹⁹ C, how many extra electrons does the 9.62 × 10⁻¹⁹ C drop carry?

Question 3 of 5

In the gold foil experiment, which observation showed that an atom's positive charge is packed into a tiny, dense nucleus?

Question 4 of 5

Which part of Dalton's atomic theory did the discovery of isotopes show to be wrong?

Question 5 of 5

What convinced Thomson that electrons are part of every atom?

← Previous topicNext topic →