Chemistry › Section G · Chemical bonding and molecular geometry › Topic G.4
Formal charge and resonance
The five-step method sometimes gives more than one acceptable Lewis structure. Formal charge helps you pick the most reasonable one, and resonance explains the molecules that no single structure can describe.
When one Lewis structure is not enough
Following the Lewis-structure steps for phosgene, \(\mathrm{COCl_2}\), you could make the double bond to oxygen or to one of the chlorines, and both versions give every atom an octet. For a formula such as HCN you might also wonder whether the atoms connect as H–C–N or H–N–C. Formal charge gives a quick, consistent way to compare such options. A second problem appears in molecules such as ozone, where experiments show two bonds are identical but every Lewis structure draws them differently. Resonance solves that one.
Calculating formal charge
The formal charge of an atom in a Lewis structure is the charge it would carry if every bonding pair were split equally between its two atoms. Count the atom's valence electrons as a free atom, V; its nonbonding electrons, N (two for each lone pair); and its bonding electrons, B (two for each bond line). Then
A quicker version: valence electrons, minus electrons in lone pairs, minus the number of bonds. The formal charges in a structure always add up to the overall charge: zero for a molecule, or the ion's charge for an ion. That sum is your check.
Worked example: ammonium and tetrafluoroborate
Find the formal charges in \(\mathrm{NH_4^+}\) and \(\mathrm{BF_4^-}\). 1. In \(\mathrm{NH_4^+}\), nitrogen has four bonds and no lone pairs: \(\text{FC} = 5 - 0 - \tfrac{1}{2}(8) = +1\). 2. Each hydrogen has one bond: \(1 - 0 - 1 = 0\). 3. Sum: \(+1 + 4(0) = +1\), matching the ion's charge. 4. In \(\mathrm{BF_4^-}\), boron has four bonds and no lone pairs: \(3 - 0 - 4 = -1\). 5. Each fluorine has three lone pairs and one bond: \(7 - 6 - 1 = 0\). 6. Sum: \(-1 + 4(0) = -1\), matching. Notice that the formal charge of −1 lands on boron, even though fluorine is far more electronegative.
Formal charge is bookkeeping
That last result shows why formal charge must not be mistaken for a real charge. It assumes perfectly equal sharing, which is true only between identical atoms. Oxidation numbers, from the topic on classifying reactions, make the opposite assumption, giving every shared pair to the more electronegative atom. Real atoms sit between those extremes, with partial charges set by electronegativity differences. In \(\mathrm{BF_4^-}\), most of the negative charge actually spreads over the fluorine atoms. Formal charge is still useful, because structures with small formal charges are usually the ones that match experiments.
Choosing the best structure
When several Lewis structures are possible, these guidelines usually pick out the best. 1. Prefer the structure in which every formal charge is zero. 2. If some must be non-zero, prefer the smallest values, ideally no more than +1 or −1, on the fewest atoms. 3. Avoid like charges on neighbouring atoms. 4. Put negative formal charges on the more electronegative atoms. These are guidelines, not laws. Carbon monoxide, with a triple bond and one lone pair on each atom, has formal charges of −1 on carbon and +1 on oxygen, breaking guideline 4, yet it is the best structure, because it is the only one that gives both atoms an octet.
Worked example: HCN or HNC, and phosgene
Use formal charges to choose the arrangement of HCN and the position of the double bond in \(\mathrm{COCl_2}\). 1. H–C≡N, with a lone pair on N: hydrogen \(1 - 0 - 1 = 0\), carbon \(4 - 0 - 4 = 0\), nitrogen \(5 - 2 - 3 = 0\). 2. H–N≡C, with a lone pair on C: hydrogen 0, nitrogen \(5 - 0 - 4 = +1\), carbon \(4 - 2 - 3 = -1\). 3. All zeros win, so the molecule is H–C≡N, as experiment confirms; HNC exists only as a less stable isomer. 4. Phosgene with C=O: every atom has formal charge 0. 5. With C=Cl instead, that chlorine is \(7 - 4 - 2 = +1\) and the singly bonded oxygen \(6 - 6 - 1 = -1\). 6. So the double bond belongs to oxygen.
Resonance: the ozone puzzle
Ozone, \(\mathrm{O_3}\), has 18 valence electrons. A valid Lewis structure has a central oxygen with one lone pair, a double bond to one end oxygen and a single bond to the other: formal charges of +1 in the centre, 0 on the doubly bonded end and −1 on the singly bonded end. But you could just as well put the double bond on the other side. If either drawing were literally true, ozone would have one short bond and one long one. Experiments find two identical O–O bonds, each about 128 pm long, between a typical O–O single bond (about 148 pm) and the O=O bond in oxygen gas (121 pm).
The resonance hybrid
When two or more valid Lewis structures share the same arrangement of atoms and differ only in where electrons are placed, each is called a resonance form, and the real molecule is a resonance hybrid, a blend of them all. The forms are drawn with a double-headed arrow between them. The hybrid does not flip back and forth: think of purple paint, which is not red one moment and blue the next, but purple all the time. In the forms, only electrons move; the atoms stay put. Each ozone bond is effectively halfway between single and double, a bond order of 1.5, which is why the two bonds are equal.
Worked example: the nitrate ion
Draw the resonance forms of \(\mathrm{NO_3^-}\) and describe its bonds. 1. Count: \(5 + 3(6) + 1 = 24\) valence electrons. 2. Nitrogen is central with three oxygens. Single bonds and outer octets use all 24, leaving nitrogen with 6, so one N–O becomes N=O. 3. Formal charges: N \(5 - 0 - 4 = +1\); the doubly bonded O \(6 - 4 - 2 = 0\); each singly bonded O \(6 - 6 - 1 = -1\). Sum: \(+1 + 0 - 2 = -1\), matching. 4. The double bond can sit on any of the three oxygens, giving three equivalent resonance forms. 5. In the hybrid, the three N–O bonds are identical, each with bond order \(\tfrac{4}{3} \approx 1.33\): four shared pairs spread over three bonds.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, in the quick version, subtracting one per lone pair instead of two, or two per bond instead of one. Second, forgetting to check that formal charges add up to the overall charge. Third, treating formal charge as the real charge on an atom. Fourth, drawing resonance forms that move atoms rather than electrons; a different skeleton is a different molecule, such as HNC. Fifth, believing a molecule switches between its resonance forms. Sixth, applying the guidelines so rigidly that you reject a structure like that of CO, which is best because it gives every atom an octet.
Key takeaways
Formal charge is FC = V − N − ½B, or valence electrons minus lone-pair electrons minus bonds, and the formal charges always add up to the overall charge. It is bookkeeping, not a real charge. The best Lewis structure usually has formal charges of zero, or the smallest possible, with any negative charge on the more electronegative atom and no like charges side by side. When several valid structures differ only in electron positions, the real species is a resonance hybrid: ozone's two bonds have bond order 1.5, and nitrate's three have bond order 4/3.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Charge an atom would have if every bonding pair were shared equally
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
In the ammonium ion, NH₄⁺, what is the formal charge on nitrogen?
Question 2 of 5
In a Lewis structure of ozone with one O=O and one O–O bond, what is the formal charge on the central oxygen, which has one lone pair?
Question 3 of 5
Formal charges suggest that hydrogen cyanide is H–C≡N rather than H–N≡C. Why?
Question 4 of 5
Which statement about the nitrate ion, NO₃⁻, is correct?
Question 5 of 5
What is the sum of the formal charges in any correct Lewis structure of the carbonate ion, CO₃²⁻?
