Chemistry › Section P · Thermodynamics › Topic P.1
Spontaneity
Thermochemistry tells you how much heat a change gives out or takes in, but not whether the change will happen at all. Thermodynamics answers that second question, and it begins with a simple observation: many changes run one way on their own and never run back.
Which way will it go?
Drop a sugar cube into hot tea and it dissolves; you never see sugar crystals reassemble from sweet tea. A hot pan left on the counter cools to room temperature, but a pan at room temperature never heats itself up. A bicycle chain left in the rain rusts, yet rust never turns back into shiny iron by itself. Each of these changes has a natural direction. Being able to predict that direction for any chemical reaction, without having to try it, is one of the most useful things chemistry can do, and the next three topics build the tools for it.
Spontaneous and nonspontaneous processes
A spontaneous process is one that, under the stated conditions, can proceed on its own once it has started, with no continuous supply of energy from outside. A nonspontaneous process happens only while something outside keeps driving it: water flows uphill only while a pump runs, and water splits into hydrogen and oxygen only while a current passes. If a process is spontaneous in one direction, the reverse is nonspontaneous under the same conditions. Conditions matter. At 25 °C and 1 atm, ice melts spontaneously and liquid water does not freeze; at −10 °C the opposite is true. So a statement about spontaneity is only complete when the temperature and pressure are given.
Spontaneous does not mean fast
Spontaneity says nothing about speed. A mixture of hydrogen and oxygen can sit in a sealed flask at room temperature for years with no visible change, yet one spark makes it explode into water, because the reaction was spontaneous all along. Diamond is less stable than graphite at everyday pressures, so its conversion to graphite is spontaneous, but at room temperature it is so slow that no change has ever been measured. Diamond is called thermodynamically unstable but kinetically stable. Thermodynamics tells you whether a change can happen; kinetics, the study of reaction rates, tells you how fast. A catalyst can speed a spontaneous reaction up, but it cannot make a nonspontaneous one go.
Is giving out heat the answer?
A natural first guess is that spontaneous processes are the ones that release energy, like a ball rolling downhill. Many are exothermic: burning methane has ΔH° ≈ −890 kJ per mole, and rusting releases heat too. But the guess fails. Ice melting at room temperature is endothermic, with ΔH = +6.01 kJ mol⁻¹, and it is spontaneous. Water evaporates from a puddle on a cool day while absorbing heat. Ammonium nitrate, \(\mathrm{NH_4NO_3}\), dissolves readily in water while absorbing 25.7 kJ mol⁻¹, which is how instant cold packs work. The sign of ΔH alone cannot predict spontaneity, so something else must be involved.
The dispersal of matter
Picture two flasks joined by a closed tap: one holds a gas, the other is evacuated, and the pair is insulated from everything else. Open the tap and the gas spreads until both flasks hold equal amounts. No heat crosses the insulation, so q = 0. The gas pushes against an empty flask, where the external pressure is zero, so it does no work: w = 0. By the first law, \(\Delta U = q + w = 0\). The change happened with no energy change at all. What changed is how the matter is spread out: it now fills twice the volume, evenly. Perfume spreading through a room and dye colouring a whole glass of water are the same kind of change.
The dispersal of energy
Now touch a hot metal block to a cold one. Heat flows from the hot block to the cold one until their temperatures match. The total energy of the pair is unchanged; it has simply been shared out more evenly among all the particles of both blocks instead of being concentrated in one. The reverse, with one block spontaneously growing hotter while the other cools, is never seen. Across the examples so far, the common thread is that spontaneous processes tend to leave matter, energy or both more widely and evenly spread. The next topic turns this idea into a measurable quantity, entropy.
Worked example: an instant cold pack
A cold pack holds 10.0 g of ammonium nitrate (molar mass 80.04 g mol⁻¹) and a pouch of water. Dissolving it absorbs 25.7 kJ mol⁻¹. How much heat does the pack take from your skin, and what does this show? 1. Moles: \(n = \frac{10.0}{80.04} = 0.1249\) mol. 2. Heat absorbed: \(q = 0.1249 \times 25.7 = 3.21\) kJ, so ΔH = +3.21 kJ for the process. 3. Interpret: the process is endothermic, yet once the pouch breaks it runs on its own until the solid has dissolved. 4. Conclusion: a positive ΔH did not stop a spontaneous change, so energy alone cannot decide direction. 5. Check: 10 g is about one-eighth of a mole, and an eighth of 25.7 is about 3.2 kJ.
Worked example: reading dispersal
For each spontaneous change, say how matter is redistributed. (a) Air hissing out of a punctured tyre. (b) Dew forming on grass on a cold night. (c) Table salt dissolving in a glass of water. 1. In (a), the air moves from a small, crowded space into the open atmosphere, so matter becomes far more dispersed. 2. In (b), water vapour spread through the air becomes droplets of liquid, so the water itself becomes less dispersed. 3. Dew forms only because the condensing water releases heat into the cold surroundings, spreading energy there; this hints that the surroundings must be counted too. 4. In (c), ions locked in a crystal spread evenly through the whole liquid, so matter becomes more dispersed.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, equating spontaneous with fast or immediate: a spontaneous reaction may be far too slow to notice. Second, assuming every spontaneous process is exothermic; melting ice and dissolving ammonium nitrate are endothermic. Third, forgetting the conditions: freezing is spontaneous below 0 °C and nonspontaneous above it, at 1 atm. Fourth, thinking a catalyst can make a reaction spontaneous; it only changes the rate. Fifth, calling a process that needs a match or spark to start nonspontaneous; a one-off push is not the continuous input that defines a nonspontaneous change.
Key takeaways
A spontaneous process can proceed on its own under the stated conditions; its reverse is then nonspontaneous and needs a continuous outside drive. Spontaneity depends on temperature and pressure, and says nothing about rate: diamond turning to graphite is spontaneous but immeasurably slow. The sign of ΔH cannot decide direction, because some spontaneous changes are endothermic. A gas expanding into a vacuum changes no energy at all, which shows that the spreading out of matter and energy is what spontaneous processes have in common.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A change that can proceed on its own under the stated conditions, with no continuous outside input
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Which statement about a spontaneous process is correct?
Question 2 of 5
Diamond is less stable than graphite at everyday pressures. Why do diamonds last for centuries?
Question 3 of 5
An insulated container holds a gas on one side of a partition and a vacuum on the other. The partition is removed and the gas spreads out. Which set of values is correct for the gas?
Question 4 of 5
Dissolving ammonium nitrate (80.04 g mol⁻¹) absorbs 25.7 kJ mol⁻¹. How much heat is absorbed when 16.0 g dissolves?
Question 5 of 5
Which process is nonspontaneous at 25 °C and 1 atm?
