Electrical Engineering › Section K · Methods of analysis and theorems (ac) › Topic K.2

Bridge networks and delta-Y conversions (ac)

A bridge compares an unknown impedance with known ones and detects the moment they match as a null, which makes it one of the most precise ways to measure inductance and capacitance. Delta-Y conversions then handle the bridges, and other awkward networks, that never balance.

Measuring by balancing

In "Bridge networks and Y-delta conversions" a Wheatstone bridge found an unknown resistance by adjusting known ones until a detector between two nodes read zero. An ac bridge does the same with impedances, fed by a sinusoidal source and watched by an ac detector such as a sensitive meter, an oscilloscope or headphones. Because the reading at balance is a null, the result depends only on the known components, not on the source amplitude or the detector's calibration. This makes bridges a classic method for measuring inductance, capacitance and the losses of real coils and capacitors. Bold letters below are phasors.

The ac balance condition

Describe the bridge by its nodes. The source connects node a to node b. Arm 1 joins a to c, arm 2 joins a to d, arm 3 joins c to b and arm 4 joins d to b, and the detector joins c to d. At balance no current flows in the detector, so c and d are at the same potential and arms 1 and 3 form a simple divider, as do arms 2 and 4. Equating \(\mathbf{V}_{ac}\) and \(\mathbf{V}_{ad}\) gives

\frac{Z_1}{Z_1 + Z_3} = \frac{Z_2}{Z_2 + Z_4} \;\Rightarrow\; Z_1 Z_4 = Z_2 Z_3

The products of opposite arms are equal.

Two conditions at once

The equation \(Z_1Z_4 = Z_2Z_3\) is complex, so it holds only if both its real and imaginary parts match, or equivalently both magnitudes and angles. An ac bridge therefore needs two independent adjustments to reach a true null, where a dc bridge needed one. Balance does not depend on the source voltage or on the detector's own impedance, since no detector current flows. It may depend on frequency: some bridges balance at every frequency once set, while others balance only at the frequency used, and their formulas then contain ω. Knowing which type you have tells you whether the source frequency must be accurate.

The Maxwell bridge

The Maxwell bridge measures a coil, modelled as a resistance \(R_x\) in series with an inductance \(L_x\), in arm 4. Arm 1 is a resistor \(R_1\) in parallel with a standard capacitor \(C_1\), and arms 2 and 3 are resistors \(R_2\) and \(R_3\). Solving \(Z_4 = Z_2Z_3/Z_1\), with \(1/Z_1 = 1/R_1 + j\omega C_1\), gives

Z_4 = R_2R_3\left(\frac{1}{R_1} + j\omega C_1\right)

so

R_x = \frac{R_2R_3}{R_1}, \quad L_x = R_2R_3C_1

Neither result contains ω, so the Maxwell bridge balances at any frequency. Using a capacitor as the standard is convenient, because good capacitors are closer to ideal than good inductors.

Worked example: a Maxwell bridge

A Maxwell bridge at 1 kHz balances with \(R_1 = 10\) kΩ, \(C_1 = 0.1\) µF, \(R_2 = 1\) kΩ and \(R_3 = 470\,\Omega\). Find the coil. 1. Resistance: \(R_x = (1000)(470)/10\,000 = 47\,\Omega\). 2. Inductance: \(L_x = (1000)(470)(0.1\,\mu\text{F}) = 47\) mH. 3. Quality of the coil: \(X_L = 2\pi(1000)(0.047) = 295\,\Omega\), so the coil's quality factor \(Q_l = X_L/R_x\) is about 6.3. 4. Check: computing the detector voltage with these values gives zero at 1 kHz and also at 5 kHz, as the frequency-independent formulas predict.

The Hay bridge

For a coil with a high ratio of reactance to resistance, typically above about 10, the Maxwell bridge needs an impractically large \(R_1\). The Hay bridge instead puts \(R_1\) in series with \(C_1\) in arm 1. Solving the balance with \(Z_1 = R_1 - j/(\omega C_1)\) gives

L_x = \frac{R_2R_3C_1}{1 + \omega^2C_1^2R_1^2}, \quad R_x = \frac{\omega^2C_1^2R_1R_2R_3}{1 + \omega^2C_1^2R_1^2}

Both now depend on frequency. For example, with \(R_1 = 100\,\Omega\), \(C_1 = 0.1\) µF and \(R_2 = R_3 = 1\) kΩ at 1 kHz, the coil is 99.6 mH with 39.3 Ω, a \(Q_l\) of about 16.

The capacitance comparison bridge

To measure a capacitor, compare it with a standard. Put the unknown, modelled as \(R_x\) in series with \(C_x\), in arm 4, a standard \(R_s\) in series with \(C_s\) in arm 3, and resistors \(R_1\) and \(R_2\) in arms 1 and 2. The balance \(R_1(R_x - j/\omega C_x) = R_2(R_s - j/\omega C_s)\) splits into two real equations:

R_x = \frac{R_2R_s}{R_1}, \quad C_x = \frac{R_1C_s}{R_2}

The series resistance represents the capacitor's losses. With \(R_1 = 1\) kΩ, \(R_2 = 2\) kΩ and \(C_s = 0.1\) µF, the unknown is 0.05 µF, and the balance holds at any frequency.

Delta-Y conversions with impedances

A bridge that is not balanced has current in every arm, and it contains no series or parallel pairs to reduce. Converting a delta into a Y, or a Y into a delta, fixes that, with the same formulas as dc but complex impedances. Name the delta's terminals a, b and c, with impedances \(Z_{ab}\), \(Z_{bc}\) and \(Z_{ca}\). Each Y arm runs from a terminal to a new centre node, and equals the product of the two delta impedances touching that terminal divided by their sum:

Z_a = \frac{Z_{ab}Z_{ca}}{Z_{ab} + Z_{bc} + Z_{ca}}

and similarly for \(Z_b\) and \(Z_c\). Going back, a delta impedance is the sum of the Y's pair products divided by the opposite Y arm.

Worked example: an unbalanced bridge

Find the impedance between nodes a and d of this network: \(Z_{ab} = j6\), \(Z_{ca} = -j6\), \(Z_{bc} = 6\), then b to d is 4 Ω and c to d is 4 Ω. 1. The delta a-b-c has sum \(j6 + 6 - j6 = 6\,\Omega\). 2. Y arms: \(Z_a = (j6)(-j6)/6 = 6\,\Omega\), \(Z_b = (j6)(6)/6 = j6\,\Omega\) and \(Z_c = (6)(-j6)/6 = -j6\,\Omega\). 3. From the centre to d, the paths \(j6 + 4\) and \(-j6 + 4\) are now in parallel: \((4 + j6)(4 - j6)/8 = 6.5\,\Omega\). 4. Total: \(Z_T = 6 + 6.5 = 12.5\,\Omega\), purely resistive. 5. Check: nodal analysis of the original network gives the same 12.5 Ω.

Balanced deltas and Ys

When all three delta impedances are identical, the conversion simplifies to

Z_Y = \frac{Z_\Delta}{3}, \quad Z_\Delta = 3Z_Y

So a delta of three \(9 + j12\,\Omega\) impedances, each \(15\angle 53.13^\circ\,\Omega\), becomes a Y of three \(3 + j4\,\Omega\) arms, each \(5\angle 53.13^\circ\,\Omega\). The shortcut needs the impedances to be identical in angle as well as magnitude: three impedances of 15 Ω at different angles do not count. Balanced deltas and Ys reappear constantly in three-phase power systems.

Common mistakes to avoid

1. Pairing adjacent arms instead of opposite arms in the balance condition. 2. Balancing only the magnitudes: the angles, or the real and imaginary parts, must match too. 3. Expecting every bridge to balance at all frequencies; the Hay bridge does not. 4. Dividing by the wrong delta impedance: each Y arm uses the two delta impedances that touch its own terminal. 5. Using \(Z_\Delta/3\) when the three impedances differ in angle. 6. Treating 'balanced' as meaning the source current is zero: only the detector current is zero.

Key takeaways

With arms 1 and 4 opposite, and 2 and 3 opposite, an ac bridge balances when \(Z_1Z_4 = Z_2Z_3\), a complex condition needing two adjustments. The Maxwell bridge gives \(R_x = R_2R_3/R_1\) and \(L_x = R_2R_3C_1\) at any frequency. The Hay bridge suits coils with a high \(Q_l\) and depends on ω. The capacitance comparison bridge gives \(C_x = R_1C_s/R_2\). Unbalanced networks yield to delta-Y conversion: a Y arm is the product of the two adjacent delta impedances over their sum, and identical impedances give \(Z_Y = Z_\Delta/3\).

Flashcards

Flashcard

AC bridge

Four impedance arms and a detector, balanced to a null

The null depends only on the known arms.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

An ac bridge has opposite arm pairs 1-4 and 2-3. At balance, Z₁ = 100 Ω, Z₂ = 200 Ω and Z₃ = 50 − j80 Ω. What is Z₄?

Question 2 of 5

A Maxwell bridge balances with R₁ = 5 kΩ in parallel with C₁ = 0.2 µF, and R₂ = R₃ = 1 kΩ. What are the coil's inductance and resistance?

Question 3 of 5

A capacitance comparison bridge balances with R₁ = 1.5 kΩ, R₂ = 1 kΩ and a standard C_s = 0.1 µF. What is the unknown capacitance?

Question 4 of 5

A delta is made of three identical impedances of 15∠30° Ω. What is each arm of the equivalent Y?

Question 5 of 5

A delta has Z_ab = 10 Ω, Z_bc = j10 Ω and Z_ca = −j10 Ω. What is the Y arm at terminal c?

← Previous topicNext topic →