Electrical Engineering › Section K · Methods of analysis and theorems (ac) › Topic K.1
Dependent sources, source conversions, mesh and nodal analysis (ac)
When a network has several sources that are neither in series nor in parallel, block reduction stops working. Mesh and nodal analysis, which you already know for dc, take over unchanged except that every coefficient is complex. This topic also introduces dependent sources, the building blocks of every transistor and amplifier model.
When reduction runs out
Two sources at different points of a network rarely sit in a neat series or parallel arrangement, so the methods of "Series-parallel ac networks" cannot finish the job. The systematic methods of "Mesh analysis" and "Nodal analysis" can. They work for ac exactly as for dc: write one equation per mesh or per node, then solve the set. The differences are that resistances become impedances, conductances become admittances, and the source values are phasors, so the equations have complex coefficients. A calculator or software that handles complex numbers makes the solving routine. As before, bold letters are rms phasors.
Independent and dependent sources
Every source so far has been independent: its value is fixed whatever the rest of the network does. A dependent, or controlled, source has a value set by a voltage or current elsewhere in the same network. There are four kinds: a voltage-controlled voltage source, \(\mathbf{E} = \mu\mathbf{V}_x\); a current-controlled voltage source, \(\mathbf{E} = r\mathbf{I}_x\); a voltage-controlled current source, \(\mathbf{I} = g\mathbf{V}_x\); and a current-controlled current source, \(\mathbf{I} = \beta\mathbf{I}_x\). The constants \(\mu\) and \(\beta\) have no units, r is in ohms and g in siemens. If the controlling quantity is zero, the dependent source is zero too, so a dependent voltage source then acts as a short and a dependent current source as an open.
Source conversions
A voltage source \(\mathbf{E}\) in series with an impedance Z behaves, at its terminals, exactly like a current source \(\mathbf{I} = \mathbf{E}/Z\) in parallel with the same Z, as "Current sources and source conversions" showed for dc. Going the other way, \(\mathbf{E} = \mathbf{I}Z\). The impedance is unchanged and complex, so the converted source generally has a different angle from the original. A dependent source converts the same way, carrying its controlling variable along, but only if that controlling voltage or current is not part of the impedance being converted: the conversion would make it disappear from the network.
Worked example: converting sources
1. A source \(\mathbf{E} = 20\angle 0^\circ\) V is in series with \(Z = 4 + j3\,\Omega = 5\angle 36.87^\circ\,\Omega\). The equivalent current source is
in parallel with the same \(4 + j3\,\Omega\). 2. A voltage-controlled voltage source of \(50\mathbf{V}_x\) is in series with 2 kΩ, and \(\mathbf{V}_x\) is measured elsewhere in the network. The equivalent is a current source of \(50\mathbf{V}_x/2000 = 0.025\mathbf{V}_x\) A, that is \(25\) mS times \(\mathbf{V}_x\), in parallel with 2 kΩ. 3. Check: in each case, open-circuit voltage divided by short-circuit current gives back the same impedance.
Mesh analysis with impedances
Assign a clockwise current to each window of a planar network. The format approach from dc carries over: for mesh k, the coefficient of its own current is the sum of all impedances around that mesh (its self-impedance), the coefficient of each neighbouring mesh current is minus the impedance shared with that neighbour, and the right-hand side is the sum of source voltages that would drive current clockwise around mesh k. The equations are symmetric about the diagonal when the network has only independent sources. A current source on a mesh boundary needs a supermesh, exactly as in dc. A dependent source adds one extra equation that links its controlling variable to the mesh currents.
Worked example: two meshes
Source \(\mathbf{E}_1 = 12\angle 0^\circ\) V has its + terminal at node a and − at ground. A 4 Ω resistor joins a to node b, a capacitive reactance of 8 Ω joins b to ground, an inductive reactance of 2 Ω joins b to node c, and \(\mathbf{E}_2 = 6\angle 0^\circ\) V has + at c and − at ground. 1. Equations, both mesh currents clockwise:
2. Determinant: \(D = (4 - j8)(-j6) - (j8)^2 = 16 - j24\). 3. Solve: \(\mathbf{I}_1 = -j24/D = 0.832\angle -33.7^\circ\) A and \(\mathbf{I}_2 = (-24 - j48)/D = 1.86\angle -60.3^\circ\) A. 4. The capacitor carries \(\mathbf{I}_1 - \mathbf{I}_2 = 1.18\angle 101.3^\circ\) A, downwards.
Nodal analysis with admittances
Choose a reference node, ground, and name the other nodes. For node k, the format approach gives the coefficient of its own voltage as the sum of admittances connected to it (its self-admittance), the coefficient of each neighbouring node voltage as minus the admittance joining them, and the right-hand side as the net source current entering node k. Voltage sources in series with an impedance are converted to current sources first, or, as in the next card, the branch current \((\mathbf{V}_k - \mathbf{E})/Z\) is written straight into Kirchhoff's current law. A voltage source between two non-reference nodes needs a supernode. Nodal analysis suits networks with fewer nodes than meshes.
Worked example: the same network by nodes
Solve the previous network with node b as the only unknown, since a and c are fixed by the sources. 1. Kirchhoff's current law at b, currents leaving:
2. Collect terms: \(\mathbf{V}_b(0.25 + j0.125 - j0.5) = 3 - j3\), so \(\mathbf{V}_b(0.25 - j0.375) = 3 - j3\). 3. Solve: \(\mathbf{V}_b = 4.24\angle -45^\circ / 0.451\angle -56.3^\circ = 9.41\angle 11.3^\circ\) V. 4. Check against the mesh result: the capacitor current \(\mathbf{V}_b/(-j8) = 1.18\angle 101.3^\circ\) A, and \((12 - \mathbf{V}_b)/4 = 0.832\angle -33.7^\circ\) A equals \(\mathbf{I}_1\). One equation replaced two.
Worked example: a dependent source
A simple amplifier model has an input voltage \(\mathbf{V}_1 = 10\angle 0^\circ\) mV at node 1. A voltage-controlled current source of \(g\mathbf{V}_1\), with \(g = 40\) mS, draws current out of node 2 and into ground. Node 2 also has a 4.7 kΩ resistor and a capacitive reactance of 4.7 kΩ, each to ground. 1. Load: \(Z = 4.7\text{k} \parallel (-j4.7\text{k}) = 3.32\angle -45^\circ\) kΩ. 2. Kirchhoff's current law at node 2: \(\mathbf{V}_2/Z + g\mathbf{V}_1 = 0\), so \(\mathbf{V}_2 = -gZ\mathbf{V}_1\). 3. Substitute: \(\mathbf{V}_2 = -(0.04)(3323\angle -45^\circ)(0.01) = 1.33\angle 135^\circ\) V. 4. Check: the gain is 133; the minus sign gives 180°, and the capacitor adds a further 45° of lag.
Common mistakes to avoid
1. Getting the sign of a mutual term wrong in the format approach: with all mesh currents clockwise it is always minus the shared impedance, so a shared \(-j8\,\Omega\) gives \(+j8\). 2. Converting a dependent source whose controlling variable lies in the impedance being converted. 3. Using magnitudes instead of phasors for source values, losing their angles. 4. Mixing impedances and admittances in the same nodal equation. 5. Forgetting the extra equation that ties a dependent source's controlling variable to the unknowns. 6. Mishandling signs with j: \(1/j = -j\), so a capacitive reactance of 8 Ω has admittance \(+j0.125\) S.
Key takeaways
Dependent sources take their value from a voltage or current elsewhere in the network: \(\mu\mathbf{V}_x\), \(r\mathbf{I}_x\), \(g\mathbf{V}_x\) or \(\beta\mathbf{I}_x\). Source conversion uses \(\mathbf{I} = \mathbf{E}/Z\) with the same complex Z, and works for a dependent source only if its control lies outside Z. Mesh analysis uses self-impedances on the diagonal and negative mutual impedances off it; nodal analysis does the same with admittances. Supermeshes and supernodes handle awkward sources, and a dependent source adds one controlling equation. Check results by solving a second way.
Flashcards
Flashcard
A source whose value is fixed whatever the network does
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
A current source of 10∠30° A is in parallel with Z = 3 − j4 Ω. What is the equivalent voltage source in series with Z?
Question 2 of 5
Mesh 1 contains a 5 Ω resistor and shares an inductive reactance of 4 Ω with mesh 2, which also contains a capacitive reactance of 6 Ω. Both mesh currents are clockwise. What is the coefficient of I₂ in mesh 1's equation?
Question 3 of 5
A dependent voltage source is in series with an impedance Z. When may it be converted into a dependent current source in parallel with Z?
Question 4 of 5
Node v is joined to a fixed 10∠0° V node by a 2 Ω resistor and to ground by a capacitive reactance of 2 Ω. Nothing else connects to v. What is the node voltage?
Question 5 of 5
A VCCS of gV₁, with g = 40 mS, draws current out of node 2 into ground. Node 2's only other connection is a load of 2.5∠−30° kΩ to ground. What is V₂/V₁?
