Electrical Engineering › Section N · Decibels, filters, and Bode plots › Topic N.3

Pass-band and stop-band filters

A radio picks one station out of dozens, and an audio interface removes a single interfering tone. Both jobs need filters that act on a band of frequencies, built either from R-C stages or from the resonant circuits met earlier in the course.

Selecting or rejecting a band

A pass-band filter passes frequencies between a lower critical frequency \(f_1\) and an upper one \(f_2\), and attenuates those outside; a stop-band filter, also called a band-reject or notch filter, does the reverse. The bandwidth is \(BW = f_2 - f_1\), with both edges set at 0.707 of the maximum output, as for the single cutoffs of R-C low-pass and high-pass filters. One subtlety matters here: in a band filter the maximum output is often less than the input, so the edges are found at 0.707 of the actual peak, not of \(V_i\). There are two main ways to build these filters: cascaded R-C stages, and resonant L-C circuits.

Cascading a high-pass and a low-pass stage

Put an R-C high-pass stage first and an R-C low-pass stage after it. Source \(V_i\) is between node a and ground; \(C_1\) runs from a to b and \(R_1\) from b to ground (the high-pass stage); then \(R_2\) runs from b to c and \(C_2\) from c to ground, with \(V_o\) across \(C_2\). If the high-pass cutoff is well below the low-pass cutoff, low frequencies are stopped by the first stage, high frequencies by the second, and a band between passes both. The second stage loads the first, because it sits across \(R_1\). Making \(R_2\) about ten times \(R_1\) keeps that loading small, but the peak output still falls short of \(V_i\).

Worked example: an R-C band-pass filter

In the cascade just described, \(C_1\) = 47 nF, \(R_1\) = 2.2 kΩ, \(R_2\) = 22 kΩ and \(C_2\) = 470 pF. 1. High-pass cutoff: \(\frac{1}{2\pi(2200)(47 \times 10^{-9})} = 1.54\) kHz. 2. Low-pass cutoff: \(\frac{1}{2\pi(22{,}000)(470 \times 10^{-12})} = 15.4\) kHz. 3. Centre of the band on a log scale: \(\sqrt{(1.54)(15.4)} = 4.87\) kHz. 4. There each stage alone would pass 0.953, so ignoring loading \(|A_v| = 0.953^2 = 0.909\); a full phasor analysis with loading gives 0.901. 5. The band edges lie where \(|A_v| = 0.707 \times 0.901 = 0.637\), which the full analysis puts at 1.29 kHz and 18.4 kHz, a bandwidth of about 17.1 kHz. Because the edges are measured from a peak below \(V_i\), the band comes out wider than the two cutoffs suggest.

Band-pass with a series resonant circuit

Resonant circuits give much narrower bands. Connect the source to a series string of L, C and an output resistor R, with \(V_o\) across R; the coil has its own resistance \(R_l\). At the series resonant frequency \(f_s = \frac{1}{2\pi\sqrt{LC}}\), the reactances cancel, the current is a maximum, and

V_{o\,\max} = \frac{R}{R + R_l}\,V_i

Away from resonance the net reactance grows and the output falls. The quality factor is \(Q_s = \frac{X_L}{R + R_l}\) at resonance, as in Series resonance and the quality factor, and \(BW = f_s/Q_s\), as in Impedance versus frequency and selectivity. For \(Q_s\) of about 10 or more, \(f_1\) and \(f_2\) lie close to \(f_s \pm BW/2\).

Band-pass with a parallel resonant circuit

A parallel L-C tank does the same job the other way round. Connect a resistor R from the source at node a to node b, and the tank, L in parallel with C, from b to ground, with \(V_o\) across the tank. Near the parallel resonant frequency the tank impedance \(Z_{Tp}\) is at its largest, so most of \(V_i\) appears across it:

V_{o\,\max} = \frac{Z_{Tp}}{Z_{Tp} + R}\,V_i

where \(Z_{Tp}\) is the tank's resistive impedance at resonance. Far from resonance one of the reactances is small, the tank looks nearly like a short, and the output collapses. The topic Parallel resonance gives the formulas for \(Z_{Tp}\), the resonant frequency and the quality factor with a practical coil.

Worked example: a series resonant band-pass filter

A filter has L = 1 mH with \(R_l\) = 10 Ω, C = 2.2 nF and an output resistor R = 47 Ω. Find the centre frequency, peak output ratio, bandwidth and band edges. 1. Resonance: \(f_s = \frac{1}{2\pi\sqrt{(10^{-3})(2.2 \times 10^{-9})}} = 107\) kHz. 2. Peak: \(\frac{V_o}{V_i} = \frac{47}{57} = 0.825\). 3. Quality factor: \(X_L = 2\pi f_s L = 674\,\Omega\), so \(Q_s = 674/57 = 11.8\). 4. Bandwidth: \(BW = 107{,}300/11.8 = 9.07\) kHz. 5. Edges: about \(107.3 \mp 4.5\), so 102.8 kHz and 111.8 kHz; an exact calculation gives 102.9 kHz and 111.9 kHz, confirming the approximation for this \(Q_s\).

Stop-band filters

Reversing which element carries the output turns a pass-band circuit into a stop-band one. Put R from the source at node a to node b, and a series L-C branch from b to ground, with \(V_o\) across that branch. At \(f_s\) the branch is nearly a short, limited only by the coil's resistance, so the output dips sharply; away from \(f_s\) its impedance is large and most of \(V_i\) appears at the output. This is a trap or notch: 470 pF with 53.9 µH traps 1.00 MHz. Alternatively, place a parallel tank in series between source and load: at resonance its high impedance blocks the signal from the load. Either way, the rejected frequency is where the pass-band version would peak.

Worked example: a double-tuned filter

One network can reject one frequency and pass another. A tank, \(L_p\) in parallel with C = 1 nF, sits in series with an inductor \(L_s\) between the source and a load resistor. It must reject 300 kHz and pass 900 kHz. 1. The tank resonates at the rejected frequency: \(L_p = \frac{1}{(2\pi \cdot 300\,\text{kHz})^2 (1\,\text{nF})} = 281\,\mu\text{H}\). Its high impedance there blocks the load. 2. At 900 kHz, \(X_{L_p} = 1.59\,\text{k}\Omega\) and \(X_C = 177\,\Omega\), so the tank is capacitive: \(Z = -j\frac{(1591)(177)}{1591 - 177} = -j199\,\Omega\). 3. Choose \(L_s\) to cancel it: \(L_s = \frac{199}{2\pi(900\,\text{kHz})} = 35.2\,\mu\text{H}\). 4. Check: at 900 kHz the series path has zero net reactance, so the whole source voltage reaches the load.

Common mistakes to avoid

First, setting the band edges at \(0.707V_i\) when the peak is below \(V_i\): use 0.707 of the actual maximum. Second, treating cascaded R-C stages as independent: the second stage loads the first, so the true response is a little lower and the edges shift. Third, finding the centre of an R-C band by averaging the cutoffs: on a log scale the centre is their geometric mean, \(\sqrt{f_{HP} f_{LP}}\). Fourth, forgetting the coil resistance \(R_l\) when finding \(Q_s\) and the peak output. Fifth, mixing up the outputs: across R gives a series-resonant pass-band, across the L-C branch a stop-band.

Key takeaways

Pass-band filters pass f₁ to f₂, stop-band filters reject that range, and BW = f₂ − f₁ with edges at 0.707 of the actual peak. A high-pass R-C stage followed by a low-pass stage with a higher cutoff makes a band-pass filter; loading lowers the peak, and making R₂ much larger than R₁ limits it. A series resonant circuit with the output across R peaks at f_s = 1/(2π√(LC)), with V_o,max = R/(R + R_l) × V_i and BW = f_s/Q_s. A parallel tank across the output also gives a pass-band. Taking the output across a series L-C branch, or putting a tank in series with the load, gives a stop-band. Double-tuned networks pass one frequency and reject another.

Flashcards

Flashcard

Pass-band filter

Passes frequencies between f₁ and f₂ and attenuates the rest

Also called a band-pass filter.

Test your understanding

Question 1 of 5

A band-pass filter peaks at 0.80 V_i. At what output level are the band edges f₁ and f₂ found?

Question 2 of 5

A series resonant band-pass filter has R = 39 Ω across the output and a coil with L = 2 mH and R_l = 11 Ω. With C = 1 nF, what is its bandwidth?

Question 3 of 5

An R-C band-pass cascade has a high-pass cutoff of 200 Hz and a low-pass cutoff of 8 kHz. Roughly where is the centre of its band on a log scale?

Question 4 of 5

A resistor feeds node b, and a series L-C branch connects node b to ground. Taking the output across the L-C branch makes the circuit behave as which filter?

Question 5 of 5

In a two-stage R-C band-pass cascade, why is R₂ usually made about ten times R₁?

← Previous topicNext topic →