Electrical Engineering › Section F · Network theorems (dc) › Topic F.5
Millman's, substitution, and reciprocity theorems
Three smaller theorems round off the dc toolkit. Millman's theorem collapses parallel sources into one, the substitution theorem lets you swap a branch for anything that behaves the same, and the reciprocity theorem says a source and the current it causes can trade places.
Three special-purpose tools
Thevenin's and Norton's theorems work on any linear network. The three theorems in this topic are narrower, and each fits one kind of situation. Millman's theorem handles several voltage sources, each with its own series resistance, all connected in parallel, as with batteries or supplies sharing a load. The substitution theorem formalises a trick you have already used in ladder networks: replacing part of a circuit by something with the same terminal voltage and current. The reciprocity theorem applies to networks with a single source and tells you something surprising about symmetry.
Millman's theorem
Suppose \(N\) branches connect the same two nodes, each an ideal source \(E_k\) in series with a resistance \(R_k\), whose conductance is \(G_k = 1/R_k\). Convert each branch to a current source \(E_kG_k\) in parallel with \(G_k\), add the currents and the conductances, and convert back. The result is a single source and resistance:
A source takes the + sign if its + terminal faces the node you take as the + end of \(E_{eq}\), and − if it is reversed. The conductances are always added, whatever the source polarities.
Worked example: three parallel sources
Three branches join node a to ground, and a load \(R_L = 3.3\,\text{k}\Omega\) also joins a to ground. Branch 1: 10 V, + towards a, with 1.0 kΩ. Branch 2: 5 V, + towards ground, with 2.2 kΩ. Branch 3: 12 V, + towards a, with 4.7 kΩ. Find the load current. 1. Conductances: 1.00, 0.455 and 0.213 mS, total 1.667 mS. 2. Source currents, with branch 2 negative: \(10 - 2.27 + 2.55 = 10.28\,\text{mA}\). 3. So \(E_{eq} = \frac{10.28}{1.667} = 6.17\,\text{V}\) and \(R_{eq} = \frac{1}{1.667\,\text{mS}} = 600\,\Omega\). 4. Load:
and \(V_L = 1.58 \times 3.3 = 5.22\,\text{V}\). 5. Check: nodal analysis at a gives the same 5.22 V.
Parallel batteries, and the dual form
Sources in parallel, open circuits, and short circuits showed that mismatched batteries should not be paralleled; Millman's theorem adds the terminal voltage. Model a 12.6 V battery and a 12.2 V battery, each with 0.10 Ω internal resistance, connected in parallel with no load. The equivalent is 12.4 V behind 0.05 Ω, so the terminal sits at 12.4 V, and a current of \(\frac{12.6 - 12.2}{0.20} = 2.0\,\text{A}\) circulates from the fuller battery into the other, wasting energy and heating both. The theorem also has a dual: current sources each with a parallel resistance, connected in series, reduce to one current source in parallel with the sum of the resistances.
The substitution theorem
If the voltage across a branch and the current through it are known, that branch can be replaced by any other combination of elements with the same terminal voltage and current, and nothing else in the network changes. The rest of the circuit only "sees" the branch's voltage and current, so it cannot tell the difference. In particular, an ideal voltage source equal to the branch voltage, or an ideal current source equal to the branch current, will always do. The theorem does not find the values for you; you need them first, from another method. Its use is in splitting a network into simpler pieces, as when you work along a ladder.
Worked example: substituting the load
In the three-source example, the load has 5.22 V across it and 1.58 mA down through it. 1. Replace the 3.3 kΩ load with an ideal 5.22 V source, + towards a. Node a stays at 5.22 V. 2. Each branch current now follows from Ohm's law on its own: branch 1 delivers \(\frac{10 - 5.22}{1.0} = 4.78\,\text{mA}\) into a; branch 2 delivers \(\frac{-5 - 5.22}{2.2} = -4.64\,\text{mA}\), so it draws 4.64 mA out of a; branch 3 delivers \(\frac{12 - 5.22}{4.7} = 1.44\,\text{mA}\) into a. 3. Net into a: \(4.78 - 4.64 + 1.44 = 1.58\,\text{mA}\), exactly the load current, so the substitution changed nothing. A 1.58 mA current source pointing down would work equally well.
The reciprocity theorem
In a linear bilateral network containing one voltage source, let the source in branch x produce a current \(I\) in branch y. If the source is moved into branch y, and the place it left is replaced by a plain wire, the current in branch x will be the same \(I\). "Bilateral" means every element behaves the same in either direction, which resistors do and diodes do not. The source and the measured current simply trade places. The polarity must correspond in the two positions: if the source pushes current up through its own branch and the measured current flows down the other, the same pattern holds after the swap. The theorem is for single-source networks only.
Worked example: a ladder both ways
Node a and node b each connect to ground. Branch 1: a 12 V source, + towards a, in series with 1.0 kΩ from ground to a. Then 2.2 kΩ from a to ground, 1.5 kΩ from a to b, 3.3 kΩ from b to ground, and branch 5, 1.0 kΩ from b to ground. 1. Forward: the source sees \(2.12\,\text{k}\Omega\) and supplies 5.67 mA; 2.79 mA goes through 1.5 kΩ, and 2.14 mA flows down branch 5. 2. Swap: put the source in branch 5, + towards b, and leave 1.0 kΩ alone in branch 1. It now sees \(2.32\,\text{k}\Omega\) and supplies 5.18 mA; 3.117 mA goes through 1.5 kΩ, and branch 1 receives \(3.117 \times \frac{2.2}{3.2} = 2.14\,\text{mA}\), flowing down. 3. Same current, as predicted, although every intermediate value changed.
Common mistakes to avoid
First, in Millman's theorem, giving a reversed source a + sign, or subtracting its conductance; signs apply only to the source terms. Second, applying Millman's formula to branches that do not all connect the same two nodes. Third, thinking substitution solves a network; it needs a known voltage and current first. Fourth, using reciprocity with two or more sources, or with diodes, where it fails. Fifth, leaving the old source position open after moving the source; it must become a short, because a voltage source switched off is a short circuit.
Key takeaways
Millman's theorem reduces parallel source-resistor branches to one source \(E_{eq} = \sum(\pm E_kG_k)/\sum G_k\) behind \(R_{eq} = 1/\sum G_k\); its dual handles series current sources. Mismatched parallel batteries drive a circulating current. The substitution theorem replaces a branch with anything that has the same terminal voltage and current, such as an ideal source. The reciprocity theorem says that in a linear, bilateral, single-source network, the source and the resulting branch current can trade places without changing the current.
Flashcards
Flashcard
Parallel source-resistor branches reduce to one source and one resistance
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 5
Two branches connect node a to ground: 12 V with 1.0 kΩ, and 6.0 V with 1.0 kΩ, both with + towards a. What single source and resistance does Millman's theorem give?
Question 2 of 5
Two branches connect node a to ground: 10 V with 1.0 kΩ (+ towards a) and 4.0 V with 1.0 kΩ (+ towards ground). What is E_eq, positive at a?
Question 3 of 5
A resistor in a network has 6.0 V across it and 2.0 mA through it. By the substitution theorem, which replacement leaves the rest of the network unchanged?
Question 4 of 5
To which of these can the reciprocity theorem be applied directly?
Question 5 of 5
In a single-source resistor network, a 12 V source in branch x causes 3.0 mA in branch y. The source is moved into branch y (branch x is closed with a wire) and raised to 24 V. What current now flows in branch x?
